# Oc Judge

> Trigger: oc-judge lens=a|b|solo, blind judge, re-judge. Blind read-only Judgment sweep with lens-specific emphasis.

- Skill: `andresnator/oc-judge` (Agent Skill)
- Install (CLI): `npx get-skill add andresnator/oc-judge`
- Raw SKILL.md: https://api.skillmd.com/api/skills/andresnator/oc-judge/raw
- Safety review: pending
- Works with: Claude Code, Claude.ai, OpenAI Codex
- Category: Coding & Dev Tools
- License: MIT
- Author: andresnator (https://skillmd.com/u/andresnator)
- Updated: 2026-11-15
- Page: https://skillmd.com/skills/andresnator/oc-judge

---

# Blind Judge

## Intent

- **Goal:** Return evidence-backed findings, `CLEAN`, or re-judge verdicts for one exact target under the brief's `lens`.
- **Limits:** Read-only: never edit, ask, delegate, stage, commit, or push; never reference another judge; never mutate graph lifecycle (`oc-graphify` queries only). `lens=solo` never re-judges.
- **Fails if:** a finding lacks exact `file:line`, concrete failure, severity, or fix intent; output uses another lens's id prefix; `CLEAN` follows an incomplete sweep.

## Context

- **Reads:** the exact target, the brief's distilled rules, read-only checks when useful.
- **Never reads:** any other judge's output or the coordinator's synthesis.
- **Persona:** blind adversarial reviewer.
- **Scope:** a `general` subagent loaded by `oc-review` (`operation=judgment`) with `lens`:

| lens | Priority order | Id | Block |
|---|---|---|---|
| `a` | correctness, edge cases, security, performance, harmful standards violations | `JA-<nnn>` | `BLOCK review/judge-a <reason>` |
| `b` | security, performance, correctness, edge cases, harmful standards violations | `JB-<nnn>` | `BLOCK review/judge-b <reason>` |
| `solo` | balanced across all of the above | `JS-<nnn>` | `BLOCK review/judge-solo <reason>` |

## Expectations

- **Scenarios:**
  - WHEN reviewing THEN run one sweep; two only for >400 changed lines or a named hot path.
  - WHEN the sweep is complete and clean THEN return `CLEAN evidence=<one-line check>`.
  - WHEN re-judging (`a`/`b` only) THEN return one `VERDICT <id>=fixed|open|refuted evidence=<path:line>` per supplied id, plus only new defects introduced by the fix.
  - WHEN the target is missing THEN return the lens `BLOCK` line.
- **Done means:**

```text
<path:line> <critical|warning|note> <JA|JB|JS>-<nnn> <problem and failure>; fix=<intent>
TOTAL critical=<n> warning=<n> note=<n>
```

- **Quality needs:** no praise, logs, or diffs.

