# Heap Discipline

> Memory allocation discipline for the ESP32-C3 (~380KB RAM, no PSRAM, single 48KB framebuffer). Use whenever writing or reviewing code that allocates: new / malloc / std::vector / std::string, buffers, caches, or anything held across a loop or an activity lifecycle. Covers makeUniqueNoThrow vs raw new/malloc, fragmentation avoidance, reserve-before-push_back, alloc-once-reuse, stack vs heap sizing, and the chunked grayscale buffer pattern.

- Skill: `crosspoint-reader/heap-discipline` (Agent Skill)
- Install (CLI): `npx skillmds@latest add crosspoint-reader/heap-discipline`
- Raw SKILL.md: https://api.skillmd.com/api/skills/crosspoint-reader/heap-discipline/raw
- Safety review: pending
- Works with: Claude Code, Claude.ai, OpenAI Codex
- Category: Coding & Dev Tools
- Author: crosspoint-reader (https://skillmd.com/u/crosspoint-reader)
- Updated: 2026-09-17
- Page: https://skillmd.com/skills/crosspoint-reader/heap-discipline

---


# Heap Discipline (ESP32-C3)

CLAUDE.md states the allocation rules. This is the procedure you run while
writing the code and the gate you run before handing it back.

The constraint that makes every call matter: ~380KB RAM, no PSRAM, one 48KB
framebuffer. **Fragmentation, not total usage, is what kills this device.**
Free-heap can read fine while the largest free block is too small for the next
allocation. Optimize for not leaving holes, not just for using fewer bytes.

## Allocation decision procedure

Ask in order; stop at the first yes.

1. **Stack?** Local, bounded, under ~256 bytes total: plain array/struct. No
   heap, no fragmentation. Keep frames lean; the task stack is small.
2. **Compile-time constant?** `static constexpr` lives in flash, costs zero DRAM.
3. **Allocated once and reused for an activity's lifetime?** Allocate in
   `onEnter`, hold in a member, release in `onExit`. Never per-frame, never
   per-iteration.
4. **Dynamic and fallible?** `makeUniqueNoThrow<T>(...)` /
   `makeUniqueNoThrow<T[]>(n)` from `lib/Memory/Memory.h`. Null-check, `LOG_ERR`
   with the size, return false. It frees on every exit path.
5. **A C/SDK API takes ownership and frees it itself?** Only then raw
   `new (std::nothrow)` / `malloc`, with a comment naming who frees it.

Bare `new` / `new[]` is never correct here: under `-fno-exceptions` it calls
`abort()` on OOM instead of returning null.

## Fragmentation rules

- `std::vector`: `reserve(n)` before any `push_back` loop. Each growth is
  alloc-copy-free (three heap ops) and leaves a hole. Unknown n: estimate high.
- No repeated `new`/`delete` or growing containers inside a loop or render path.
  Hoist the allocation out of the loop.
- Large contiguous blocks fragment worst. Full-screen-class buffers use the
  chunked `storeBwBuffer` / `restoreBwBuffer` path in `GfxRenderer` so they
  never demand one contiguous 48KB block. Reuse that path. Do not malloc a
  second full-screen buffer.
- `std::string` / Arduino `String`: acceptable on cold paths (file I/O, one-shot
  setup). Banned on hot/render paths. Build text with a stack `char[]` +
  `snprintf`; if a `std::string` is unavoidable, `reserve` it first.

## Justify every allocation

Per CLAUDE.md's evidence rule: when you add a heap allocation, state in one line
why stack/static/reuse was rejected and the worst-case size. If you cannot name
the size, you cannot budget it, and you should not allocate it.

## Self-review before handoff

- [ ] No bare `new`/`new[]`. Every fallible alloc is `makeUniqueNoThrow`, or a
      raw alloc with an explicit owner comment.
- [ ] Every allocation is null-checked with `LOG_ERR` before the error return.
- [ ] No allocation inside a loop or render path that could be hoisted.
- [ ] Every `push_back` loop has a preceding `reserve`.
- [ ] Anything allocated in `onEnter` is released in `onExit`; member `HalFile`
      closed there too.
- [ ] No second full-screen buffer; grayscale uses store/restoreBwBuffer.
- [ ] Each new allocation carries a one-line size + why-not-stack/static note.