# Draft Auto Mode Rules

> Draft a paste-ready `autoMode` classifier block by interviewing the user about what should and should not be auto-approved, each entry in the shape the classifier reads well and every section keeping `$defaults`. Use when: 'help me write auto mode rules', 'draft an autoMode block', 'set up auto mode', 'add an auto-mode rule for X', 'my auto mode rules are too vague', 'rewrite this classifier entry', or an audit shows rules dropped or ignored. Prints only, never writes a settings file.

- Skill: `melodic-software/draft-auto-mode-rules-2` (Agent Skill, multi-file: 5 files)
- Install (CLI): `npx get-skill add melodic-software/draft-auto-mode-rules-2`
- Raw SKILL.md: https://api.skillmd.com/api/skills/melodic-software/draft-auto-mode-rules-2/raw
- Safety review: pending
- Works with: Claude Code, Claude.ai, OpenAI Codex
- Category: Security
- Author: melodic-software (https://skillmd.com/u/melodic-software)
- Updated: 2026-11-12
- Page: https://skillmd.com/skills/melodic-software/draft-auto-mode-rules-2

---


## Purpose

The `autoMode` block is a natural-language prompt for a classifier, not a rule list the harness
matches, so it fails in ways a config file does not. We write each condition as its own short entry
the classifier can see, never buried in a long paragraph, because a condition deep in prose is the
one a single classifier pass is likeliest to miss.

This skill applies that at authoring time instead of reporting it afterwards, the job
`claude auto-mode critique` does after the fact.

- **Pointer**: when deciding how the classifier reads entries, fetch
  [auto mode config: override the block and allow rules](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/auto-mode-config#override-the-block-and-allow-rules)
  and, for the critique command,
  [auto mode config: inspect the defaults and your effective config](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/auto-mode-config#inspect-the-defaults-and-your-effective-config)
  live.
- **As of**: 2026-10-11
- **Recheck trigger**: either section changes how entries are read or what the critique reviews.

## Report-only, permanently

**This skill writes nothing, in any scope, under any flag.** It prints a block; you paste it. Editing
a consumer's settings file would be making a permission decision on their behalf, which is the one
thing this plugin exists not to do.

## Scope boundary (route out)

- What is in effect now, what auto mode drops, what a section discards →
  `harness-config:audit-permission-state`. **Run it first.** Drafting against rules you have not read
  is how a block ends up contradicting itself.
- Grant portability and auto-mode durability → `harness-config:audit-permission-grants`.
- Whether an existing block is any good → `claude auto-mode critique`, surfaced by
  `audit-permission-state --critique`. It owns the semantic judgment; this skill owns composition.

## Boundary, the built-in `/auto-mode-setup` command

Both surfaces help a person write auto mode classifier content, so a request to "set up auto mode"
can mean either.

- **`/auto-mode-setup` (built-in command)**: the person runs it; this skill never invokes it. What
  it drafts, reads and saves is read from
  [auto mode config: generate environment entries](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/auto-mode-config#generate-environment-entries)
  live (as of 2026-11-03; recheck when that section changes what the command drafts or where it
  saves).
- **This skill (marketplace plugin).** Interviews for entries in every section (`environment`,
  `allow`, `soft_deny`, `hard_deny`), each with stated exclusions and a transcript-visible
  condition, and prints the block without writing anything.

**Routing.** At the start of the run, offer it to the person:
If /auto-mode-setup is available in your session (gate basis: its row of the commands reference;
records in [reference/native-auto-mode-setup.md](reference/native-auto-mode-setup.md)), you can
run it instead of or alongside this skill to have the `environment` section drafted from your sessions
and saved for you; this interview then covers the allow and deny sections. If they take it, run
Phase 1 again after it saves so the draft builds on what it wrote. When the caller passes
`--unattended`, the run records the offer in its output instead of asking;
without that flag it asks.

**Mutation gate.** We treat `/auto-mode-setup` as writing user settings once the person accepts its
draft. This skill writes nothing and never chains into `/auto-mode-setup` on the person's behalf.

**Availability is never assumed.** Offer the command when it resolves in this session, never assume
it is present. Read what gates it from its row of
[commands: all commands](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/commands#all-commands) live (as of
2026-11-03; recheck when that row changes what gates the command). The four-part records live in
[reference/native-auto-mode-setup.md](reference/native-auto-mode-setup.md).

## Inputs, and one deliberate omission

The draft is built from **the interview plus the effective merge** (`audit-permission-state`), and
nothing else. An optional argument, `environment`, `allow`, `soft_deny`, or `hard_deny`, names one
section to focus the interview on. `--unattended`, anywhere in the arguments, is not a section: it is the caller
declaring that nobody is present, which governs the `/auto-mode-setup` offer under "Routing". Take
it out first, then read the rest.

There is no history input: a read of "the repo's observed prompt and denial history" names no actual
location, and an unnamed read surface in a skill shipped to consumers is unreviewable.

## Phase 1: Read what already exists

Before asking anything, run the audit sibling and read its output:

```shell
bash "${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/skills/audit-permission-state/scripts/automode-block-lint.sh"
```

Three things there change what you should ask:

- A section missing `"$defaults"` means built-in rules are **already** discarded. Say so before adding
  to that section.
- A `C2b-contradiction` or `C3-shadowed` finding means the block already disagrees with itself.
  Resolving that comes before adding an entry that would deepen it.
- A `status=skipped` or `status=unavailable` result means you could **not** read the block. Draft
  anyway if asked, but say plainly that you are drafting blind.

## Phase 2: Interview

<!-- fresh-eyes-exempt: external-input -- the material judged here is the consumer's stated intent and their own existing configuration; no step judges output this skill authored -->

Ask about one entry at a time. For each, you need four things, and the fourth is where drafts fail:

1. **Which section.** `allow` (auto-approve), `soft_deny` (block, overridable), `hard_deny` (never),
   `environment` (facts the classifier needs: organization, repositories, trusted domains).
2. **A short label**: the subject, two or three words. It is what a reader scans for.
3. **What is covered, and what is explicitly not.** Both. An entry with no stated exclusions is one
   the classifier will over-apply.
4. **A condition visible in the transcript.** The critique's finding was
   that "uncheckable conditions are the biggest weakness". Entries state preconditions the classifier
   cannot evaluate from the command text, so it either allows blindly (the condition is decorative) or
   blocks (the grant is inoperable), with no stated disposition.

   Some answers name something the classifier cannot see: a person's intent, a fact about the
   build server, whether a change was reviewed. **Say so and ask for the observable form instead.**
   "Only when the deploy is approved" is not checkable; "only when the command names the staging
   endpoint" is.

Stop when they say stop. A short correct block beats a long vague one.

## Phase 3: Compose

Feed the answers to the drafter, one record per line:

```text
section allow
label Test Execution
covered running the repository's own test suite via its documented runner
not installing new dependencies as a side effect
why the runner is named in the command text
```

```shell
bash "${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/skills/draft-auto-mode-rules/scripts/draft-automode-block.sh" < answers
```

It prints a JSON object carrying only the sections that got entries. **An unknown section name
is a hard failure**, exiting 2 with nothing on stdout rather than warning beside partial output,
because a caller capturing both streams together would otherwise get unparsable JSON. **Every section opens with
`"$defaults"`.** We keep the token in every section so a customized section never loses the shipped
rules (Pointer: when deciding what a section without the token keeps, fetch
[auto mode config: define trusted infrastructure](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/auto-mode-config#define-trusted-infrastructure)
and
[auto mode config: override the block and allow rules](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/auto-mode-config#override-the-block-and-allow-rules)
live. As of: 2026-10-11. Recheck trigger: that section changes what customizing a section does to
the built-in list, or retires `$defaults`).

## Phase 4: Hand it over

Print the block. Say exactly where it goes: the `autoMode` key of
`${CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR:-$HOME/.claude}/settings.json`. Then stop.

Two things to say while handing it over:

- **Project and local settings will not work.** The classifier reads `autoMode` from user settings,
  managed settings, and inline `--settings`/SDK JSON only. A block pasted into `.claude/settings.json`
  is silently inert.
- **Merging into an existing block is theirs to do.** If they already have an `autoMode` section, the
  drafted sections replace what they paste over. Point them at the audit sibling to confirm the result
  rather than assuming it merged.

## Gotchas

- **Do not offer to write the file.** Not with `--fix`, not "shall I apply this", not as a follow-up.
  The no-write posture is the skill's contract, not a default someone can opt out of.
- **A drafted block is not a reviewed block.** After they paste it, `claude auto-mode critique` is what
  judges it. Say that rather than implying the draft is validated.
- **`claude auto-mode reset` is never run.** On a chezmoi-managed home what it removes is not
  recoverable from the settings file alone. Read what it removes from
  [CLI reference: CLI commands](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/cli-reference#cli-commands) live (as
  of 2026-11-03; recheck when that table changes what the reset subcommand removes).
- **Prose provenance does not belong in an entry.** Dates, issue numbers, and prior-draft archaeology
  cost classifier attention and buy nothing; the critique names stripping them explicitly. Version
  control owns that history.

