# Code Review

> Software engineering best practices for code review. Use when reviewing code, analyzing code quality, checking for bugs, security vulnerabilities, or providing feedback on code changes.

- Skill: `shino369/code-review` (Agent Skill)
- Install (CLI): `npx skillmds@latest add shino369/code-review`
- Raw SKILL.md: https://api.skillmd.com/api/skills/shino369/code-review/raw
- Safety review: pending (external: skill-scanner PASS, skillspector PASS)
- Works with: Claude Code, Claude.ai, OpenAI Codex
- Category: Security
- Author: shino369 (https://skillmd.com/u/shino369)
- Updated: 2026-09-10
- Page: https://skillmd.com/skills/shino369/code-review

---


# Code Review Best Practices

## Core Principles

**Review Mindset:**

- Be constructive, explain the "why"
- Prioritize by severity (critical vs nice-to-have)
- Suggest alternatives, not just problems
- Acknowledge good work

**Goals:**

1. Catch bugs before production
2. Improve code quality
3. Share knowledge
4. Prevent security vulnerabilities
5. Ensure consistency

## Security Review

### OWASP Top 10 Critical Checks

**Injection Attacks:**

- SQL: Use parameterized queries, never concatenate user input
- Command: Avoid shell commands with user input, sanitize properly
- Code: Validate all eval(), exec(), dynamic execution
- NoSQL/LDAP/XML: Use safe APIs

**Authentication & Authorization:**

- Verify auth checks on protected endpoints
- Proper session management (timeout, secure cookies)
- Authorization logic prevents privilege escalation
- Password policies enforced

**Sensitive Data:**

- No hardcoded secrets (API keys, passwords, tokens)
- Encryption at rest and in transit
- PII/PHI minimally logged
- No sensitive data in URLs or error messages

**XSS Prevention:**

- All user input escaped/sanitized for output context
- Content-Security-Policy headers configured
- Framework built-in escaping (React JSX, template engines)

**Deserialization:**

- Never deserialize untrusted data without validation
- Prefer JSON over pickle/marshal
- Validate object types post-deserialization

**Misconfiguration:**

- No default credentials in production
- Error messages don't leak internals
- Security headers present (HSTS, X-Frame-Options)

**API Security:**

- Rate limiting on sensitive endpoints
- CORS properly configured
- Input validation on all endpoints
- No sensitive data in GET requests

### Common Security Issues

- **Path Traversal**: Validate paths, prevent `../` attacks
- **SSRF**: Validate URLs, restrict internal network access
- **Open Redirects**: Whitelist redirect destinations
- **Race Conditions**: Check TOCTOU bugs
- **Timing Attacks**: Constant-time comparison for secrets
- **Regex DoS**: Avoid complex regex on user input

## Code Quality

### Readability & Maintainability

**Naming:**

- Clear, descriptive names that reveal intent
- Consistent conventions (camelCase, snake_case, PascalCase)
- Avoid abbreviations unless domain-standard

**Function Design:**

- Single responsibility, small (<50 lines ideal)
- Clear input/output, minimal side effects
- Pure functions where possible

**Complexity:**

- Low cyclomatic complexity (<10)
- Avoid deep nesting (max 3-4 levels)
- Early returns to reduce nesting
- Extract complex conditions into named functions

**Documentation:**

- Comments explain "why", not "what"
- Public APIs documented
- No commented-out code (use version control)

### Error Handling

- All errors handled (catch, log, recover or fail fast)
- No bare except/catch without handling
- Informative error messages (what, why, action)
- Proper error types (not generic Exception)
- Resources cleaned up (finally/defer/using)

**Anti-patterns:**

- Swallowing exceptions silently
- Catching too broadly
- Using exceptions for flow control
- Returning null instead of error
- Not validating inputs

### Code Duplication

- No copy-paste code blocks
- Extract common logic to reusable functions
- Use inheritance/composition appropriately
- Be pragmatic: 3+ copies = refactor time

## Performance

### Algorithm & Data Structure Efficiency

- Check time complexity (O(n²) → O(n log n) or O(n))
- Appropriate space complexity
- Right data structure (HashMap vs Array, Set vs List)
- Efficient algorithms for common problems

### Common Issues

**Database:**

- N+1 query problems (use joins/batch)
- Missing indexes on filtered/sorted columns
- SELECT \* instead of specific columns
- Queries inside loops

**Caching:**

- Repeated expensive calculations
- Duplicate API calls
- Static data not cached
- Appropriate cache TTL

**Resource Management:**

- Files/connections/streams closed
- No memory leaks (circular refs, event listeners)
- Unbounded collections (need limits/pagination)

**Frontend:**

- Unnecessary re-renders (React useMemo, useCallback)
- Large bundles (code splitting)
- Images not optimized
- Blocking JavaScript in critical path

## Architecture & Design

### SOLID Principles

- **Single Responsibility**: One reason to change
- **Open/Closed**: Open for extension, closed for modification
- **Liskov Substitution**: Subtypes substitutable for base types
- **Interface Segregation**: Small, focused interfaces
- **Dependency Inversion**: Depend on abstractions

### Other Key Principles

- **DRY**: Don't Repeat Yourself
- **KISS**: Keep It Simple
- **YAGNI**: Don't over-engineer
- **Separation of Concerns**: Distinct responsibilities
- **Composition over Inheritance**

### Code Structure

- Proper layer separation (presentation, business, data)
- Dependencies flow one direction
- No circular dependencies
- Modules cohesive and loosely coupled
- Configuration separated from code

## Testing

### Coverage & Quality

- Critical paths tested
- Edge cases covered (empty, null, max values)
- Error paths tested
- Tests deterministic (no flaky tests)
- Tests isolated (no shared state)

**Test Quality:**

- Arrange-Act-Assert structure
- One assertion focus per test
- Descriptive test names
- No test logic (tests are simple)
- Realistic test data
- External dependencies mocked appropriately

## Review Process

### Before Review

1. Understand context (PR description, tickets)
2. Check scope (< 400 lines ideal)
3. Run code locally
4. Verify CI passes

### During Review

1. Start with architecture/approach
2. Use security/performance/quality checklists
3. Review tests first (explain intended behavior)
4. Ask questions, don't assume

### Providing Feedback

**Structure:**

- Severity: Critical (must fix) vs Nice-to-have
- What: Specific issue
- Why: Why it matters
- How: Concrete alternative

**Tone:**

- Use "we" language: "We should..." not "You should..."
- Ask questions: "Have we considered...?"
- Be specific: "Function has complexity 32, consider refactoring"

**Example:**
❌ "This is bad"
✅ "Using string concatenation in loop creates O(n²) complexity. Use StringBuilder for O(n)."

## Priority Checklist

### Critical (Must Fix)

- [ ] Security vulnerabilities (injection, XSS, auth bypass)
- [ ] Data loss/corruption risks
- [ ] Memory/resource leaks
- [ ] Breaking API changes without versioning
- [ ] Race conditions/concurrency bugs

### High Priority

- [ ] Performance issues (O(n²), N+1 queries)
- [ ] Missing input validation
- [ ] Hardcoded configuration
- [ ] Missing error logging
- [ ] No tests for new functionality

### Medium Priority

- [ ] Code duplication (3+ instances)
- [ ] High complexity (>15 cyclomatic)
- [ ] Missing documentation for public APIs
- [ ] Deep nesting (>4 levels)
- [ ] Large functions (>100 lines)

### Low Priority

- [ ] Minor style inconsistencies
- [ ] Could be more idiomatic
- [ ] Variable names could be clearer
- [ ] Magic numbers → constants

## Language-Specific Notes

**JavaScript/TypeScript:**

- Use const over let, avoid var
- Proper async/await (handle rejections)
- Use === not ==
- TypeScript: Proper types, avoid any
- Null/undefined handling

**Python:**

- Follow PEP 8
- Type hints for public APIs
- Context managers (with)
- No mutable default arguments

**Java:**

- Proper exception hierarchy
- Try-with-resources
- Access modifiers (private/protected/public)
- Immutability (final fields)

**Go:**

- Error handling on every call
- defer for cleanup
- No goroutine leaks (context cancellation)
- Small, focused interfaces

## Best Practices Summary

1. **Security First**: OWASP Top 10 vulnerabilities
2. **Test Coverage**: Meaningful tests exist
3. **Error Handling**: All errors handled
4. **Performance**: Watch O(n²), N+1, memory leaks
5. **Readability**: Clear, self-documenting code
6. **Maintainability**: Low complexity, no duplication
7. **Documentation**: Public APIs documented
8. **Consistency**: Follow team conventions
9. **Constructive**: Be helpful, not critical
10. **Prioritize**: Critical first, style last