# Editorial QA

> Pre-publish QA framework for content. Brief adherence, voice consistency, fact accuracy, structure and clarity, AI-content audit, SEO and AEO compliance, internal linking and schema validation, QA at scale via sampling, the QA workflow, and the discipline that distinguishes catch-problems QA from checkbox QA. Triggers on editorial QA, content review, pre-publish review, content audit, content QA process, AI-content audit, hallucination check, content sampling, programmatic QA, voice consistency check, brief adherence check. Also triggers when a content team is shipping sloppy work, when AI-co-authored content is reaching publish unaudited, when a QA process burns reviewers out, or when a programmatic SEO set needs sampling discipline. On a voice consistency check, this skill owns checking a draft against an existing voice system at the publish gate; use `brand-voice` when the voice system itself needs defining or documenting.

- Skill: `slipcast-dev/editorial-qa` (Agent Skill)
- Install (CLI): `npx get-skill add slipcast-dev/editorial-qa`
- Raw SKILL.md: https://api.skillmd.com/api/skills/slipcast-dev/editorial-qa/raw
- Safety review: pending
- Works with: Claude Code, Claude.ai, OpenAI Codex
- Category: Marketing & Growth
- Author: Slipcast-dev (https://skillmd.com/u/slipcast-dev)
- Updated: 2026-11-15
- Page: https://skillmd.com/skills/slipcast-dev/editorial-qa

---


# Editorial QA

A senior editor's playbook for pre-publish content QA. The discipline that catches problems BEFORE content ships, not after.

Most content QA is broken in one of two directions. The thin version is "did I read it once and is the spelling OK," which catches typos but misses brief drift, voice inconsistency, hallucinated facts, AI tells, and structural problems that reach readers as "this is fine but not memorable." The thick version is a 47-item checklist that nobody completes honestly because it is process theater: checkboxes nobody actually believes catch problems.

This skill is the discipline of catch-problems QA. Each check earns its keep by catching a specific class of failure that would reach readers if missed. Checks that do not catch anything get cut. Checks the production volume cannot sustain get redesigned (sampling instead of full audit, automated instead of manual). The QA framework is what is left when you remove the theater.

The skill covers three production shapes: single editorial pieces (one at a time, full QA), AI-generated drafts (with the AI-content audit that did not exist as prominently 2 years ago), and programmatic SEO sets at scale (sampling discipline, threshold gating). Each needs its own QA shape; the underlying methodology composes across all three.

When to use this skill: building a content QA process from scratch, auditing an existing QA process that ships sloppy work or burns out the team, designing QA gates for an AI-assisted workflow, or building sampling discipline for programmatic SEO sets.

---

## What this skill is for

This skill spans pre-publish quality control. It plugs in at the END of every other content skill's output. The six-skill content suite distinction:

- `content-strategy` is program scope: what to produce.
- `pillar-content-architecture` is hub scope: how the topical hub fits together.
- `content-brief-authoring` is per-piece scope: briefs each piece.
- `content-and-copy` is execution scope: writes each piece.
- `programmatic-seo` is scaled scope: generates many pages from data.
- This skill is gate scope: verifies before publish.

Every skill above produces a draft. This skill is what gets drafts to publishable. It is the gate where quality is actually enforced.

The audience: editorial leads, content directors, in-house content QA, agencies with production lines, content ops managers, anyone running a writer (human or AI) and accountable for what ships. The voice is senior editor to junior editor or content marketer. Specific, opinionated, honest about where QA earns its keep versus where it becomes process theater.

---

## Reference files

- [`references/brief-adherence-checklist.md`](references/brief-adherence-checklist.md) - Every brief field as a QA check, with how to verify and what failure looks like.
- [`references/voice-consistency-patterns.md`](references/voice-consistency-patterns.md) - Vocabulary, rhythm, stance, register, mid-piece sampling discipline for long pieces.
- [`references/fact-accuracy-and-citation-discipline.md`](references/fact-accuracy-and-citation-discipline.md) - Verification methodology, hallucination detection, citation rules, source-age guidelines.
- [`references/structure-and-clarity-review.md`](references/structure-and-clarity-review.md) - Lede patterns, sectioning principles, endings, structural anti-patterns.
- [`references/ai-content-audit-patterns.md`](references/ai-content-audit-patterns.md) - 11 AI tells, 6 hallucination patterns, voice drift detection, worked example with revision.
- [`references/seo-aeo-compliance-checklist.md`](references/seo-aeo-compliance-checklist.md) - SEO and AEO checks combined into one workflow.
- [`references/internal-linking-and-schema-validation.md`](references/internal-linking-and-schema-validation.md) - Link discipline, anchor text variation, schema patterns and validation.
- [`references/qa-at-scale-patterns.md`](references/qa-at-scale-patterns.md) - Sampling strategy, automated checks, manual review at scale, threshold gating.
- [`references/qa-workflow-templates.md`](references/qa-workflow-templates.md) - Ownership, sequencing, halt versus flag versus auto-fix, escalation patterns.
- [`references/common-qa-failures.md`](references/common-qa-failures.md) - 11+ failure patterns with diagnoses and fixes.

---


## Conditional methods

Before applying a method below, read its linked section. For a narrow task select only relevant methods; for a full audit/design use the framework and relevant failure patterns. Existing references remain available for deeper details.

- Catch-problems QA vs checkbox QA: [method](references/domain-guide.md#catch-problems-qa-vs-checkbox-qa).
- Brief adherence check: [method](references/domain-guide.md#brief-adherence-check).
- Voice consistency check: [method](references/domain-guide.md#voice-consistency-check).
- Fact accuracy and citation discipline: [method](references/domain-guide.md#fact-accuracy-and-citation-discipline).
- Structure and clarity check: [method](references/domain-guide.md#structure-and-clarity-check).
- AI-content audit: [method](references/domain-guide.md#ai-content-audit).
- SEO and AEO compliance check: [method](references/domain-guide.md#seo-and-aeo-compliance-check).
- Internal linking and schema validation: [method](references/domain-guide.md#internal-linking-and-schema-validation).
- QA at scale: [method](references/domain-guide.md#qa-at-scale).
- The QA workflow: [method](references/domain-guide.md#the-qa-workflow).
- Common failure modes: [method](references/domain-guide.md#common-failure-modes).
- The framework: 12 considerations for editorial QA: [method](references/domain-guide.md#the-framework-12-considerations-for-editorial-qa).
- Closing: QA is where quality gets enforced: [method](references/domain-guide.md#closing-qa-is-where-quality-gets-enforced).

