Results for “methodology-critique”

Evaluate scientific manuscripts and grant proposals with structured, checklist-based peer review covering methodology, statistics, reproducibility, ethics, and reporting standards.

Spec Craft

4-phase systematic debugging methodology with root cause analysis and evidence-based verification. Use when debugging complex issues.

Challenge system assumptions against accumulated evidence. Triages observations and tensions, detects patterns, generates proposals. The scientific method applied to knowledge systems. Triggers on "/rethink", "review observations", "challenge assumptions", "what have I learned".

Analyze the spatial and structural qualities of a screen design, evaluating balance, whitespace, rhythm, and gestalt principles to identify compositional weaknesses and propose specific fixes.

Clinical copy-editor that reviews text for communication issues. Use when user says review for prose or improve the prose

马东（综艺制作人）认知与表达框架（压缩蒸馏）：赛制叙事、金句剪枝、辩论产品化 触发：奇葩说、乐夏 等。非操纵舆论教程

Conduct failure mode and effects analyses. TRIGGERS - Use when user needs help with fmea-guide related tasks.

Eng manager-mode plan review. (gstack)

北岛（诗人）认知与表达框架（压缩蒸馏）：冷意象、否定句诗学、流亡与记忆 触发：回答、朦胧诗 等。不伪造诗句

Debugging is the scientific method under time pressure.

Multi-perspective dialectical reasoning with cross-evaluative synthesis. Spawns parallel evaluative lenses (STRUCTURAL, EVIDENTIAL, SCOPE, ADVERSARIAL, PRAGMATIC) that critique thesis AND critique each other's critiques, producing N-squared evaluation matrix before recursive aggregation. Triggers on /critique, /dialectic, /crosseval, requests for thorough analysis, stress-testing arguments, or finding weaknesses. Implements Hegelian refinement enhanced with interleaved multi-domain evaluation and convergent synthesis.

Capture friction as methodology notes. Three modes — explicit description, contextual (review recent corrections), session mining (scan transcripts for patterns). Triggers on "/remember", "/remember [description]".

Knowledge Craft

Systematic peer review toolkit. Evaluate methodology, statistics, design, reproducibility, ethics, figure integrity, reporting standards, for manuscript and grant review across disciplines.

Conduct failure mode and effects analyses. TRIGGERS - Use when user needs help with fmea-guide related tasks.

LLaVA-Critic: Learning to Evaluate Multimodal Models

Eng manager-mode plan review. Lock in the execution plan — architecture, data flow, diagrams, edge cases, test coverage, performance. Walks through issues interactively with opinionated recommendations. Use when asked to "review the architecture", "engineering review", or "lock in the plan". Proactively suggest when the user has a plan or design doc and is about to start coding — to catch architecture issues before implementation. (gstack) Voice triggers (speech-to-text aliases): "tech review", "technical review", "plan engineering review".

御坂美琴（少年漫）认知与表达框架（压缩蒸馏）：炮姐傲娇、正义感、学园都市梗 触发：某科学的超电磁炮 等。虚构

袁朗（军旅剧虚构）认知与表达框架（压缩蒸馏）：老 A 冷血人设、试探与打磨、精英残酷浪漫 触发：士兵突击 等。虚构

Routes quality reviews to specialized critic agents based on file type or flags, covering peer review, code review, and manuscript polish.

Test Craft

明台（谍战虚构）认知与表达框架（压缩蒸馏）：公子成长、技能蒙太奇、信仰落地 触发：伪装者 等。禁止间谍违法教程