Peer Review Simulator

Skill for simulating peer review feedback on manuscripts

a5c-ai Updated 1.7k repo stars

File contents

Peer Review Simulator Skill

Purpose

Simulate peer review feedback on manuscripts to identify potential issues and improve quality before submission.

Capabilities

  • Analyze manuscript quality
  • Identify methodological issues
  • Check statistical validity
  • Assess presentation clarity
  • Generate reviewer comments
  • Prioritize improvements

Usage Guidelines

  1. Load manuscript
  2. Analyze structure
  3. Review methodology
  4. Check statistics
  5. Generate feedback
  6. Prioritize issues

Process Integration

Works within scientific discovery workflows for:

  • Pre-submission review
  • Quality improvement
  • Manuscript refinement
  • Author preparation

Configuration

  • Review criteria
  • Strictness levels
  • Focus areas
  • Output formats

Output Artifacts

  • Review reports
  • Comment summaries
  • Issue prioritization
  • Improvement suggestions

a5c-ai/babysitter/tree/main/library/specializations/domains/science/scientific-discovery/skills/peer-review-simulator commit a4229be115

Frequently asked questions

npx skillmds@latest add a5c-ai/peer-review-simulator