Buy-in — Reviewer Persuasion Doc (The Buy-In Doc)
Implementation done, but others' approval remains an unknown. Know what reviewers
will ask in advance — it becomes known.
/unknowns:quiz (or /quiz for copied installs) validates my understanding;
buy-in prepares others' trust.
Origin: The Buy-In Doc — see skills/loop/references/talk-source.md.
Procedure
- From
$ARGUMENTS, identify target work and audience (reviewers, team, decision-makers). No arguments → this session's implemented work, audience = reviewers. Inputs: the plan/spec, the prototype, and IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES.md. - Demo first: working result at top of doc — execution output, screenshot/GIF, interactive demo operable inside the doc if possible. Target read time: 90 seconds.
- Preempt objections: anticipate ~5 questions/objections reviewers would raise, answer each with evidence, and give every answer a reference the reviewer can follow (spec §, IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES.md entry date, metric, test run, file:line). No unsupported rebuttals — no evidence, move it to limitations.
- Spec at a glance: area / decision / ref table, one row per settled decision.
- Known limitations and unresolved unknowns: if IMPLEMENTATION_NOTES.md exists, pull recorded deviations and unresolved risks here. Not hiding is the basis of trust.
- Sign-off list: name people/teams needing to approve, with roles, and assign what each must check.
- Rollback plan: one paragraph on how to revert if things break.
Output
Ladder: Artifact tool → .unknowns/<YYYY-MM-DD>-buy-in-<slug>.html → markdown, same
structure (use markdown directly when the target is a PR body).
Reaction control = sign-off checklist, one checkbox per approver item; assembles into a
review-comment draft ("Reply with a ✓ on your piece").
Details: skills/loop/references/output-routing.md
Integration
- Run
/unknowns:quizbefore writing — work the user can't explain can't be defended in a buy-in doc either. - The
unknowns:independent-revieweragent (spawned with the Agent tool) produces the strongest evidence for objection responses, including its "verified" list.