META-MESA — Skill Atlas & Gap Detection
DITEMPA BUKAN DIBERI — Intelligence is forged, not given.
The mesa above the terrain. See the whole. Find the missing. Route the right.
What This Skill Is
This is the meta-skill — a skill about skills. It provides:
- Inventory — live multi-surface counts (not a frozen “35”)
- Gap detection — missing, thin, dual-named, harness-divergent
- Routing — given a task and harness, which skill(s) to load
- Health scoring — freshness, collision, catalog vs view drift
- Cross-harness unification — AAA catalog ↔ CLI agent views
It does NOT execute, judge, or seal. It classifies, routes, and illuminates.
Iron rule: AAA is the catalog. Harnesses are views. Do not invent parallel catalogs.
Ops skill: AGI-skill-unification (AAA + mesh views) — alias/mesh/boot contract. NOTE: One-way reference. AGI-skill-unification references this atlas; this atlas does NOT reference back (P6 circular dependency resolved 2026-08-01).
Live atlas (T₁): ${AFORGE_HOME:-/root/A-FORGE}/forge_work/2026-07-12/GROK-CLI-AAA-SKILL-UNIFICATION-ATLAS.md
Current receipt: ${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json
§0. MULTI-HARNESS UNIFICATION (Grok × CLI × AAA) — 2026-07-15
Architecture
BOOTSTRAP_MANIFEST (9 universals) ← always first
↓
AAA/skills (catalog + V3 registry) ← sole named truth
+ .agents/skills (doctrine/stage) ← shared federation core
↓ symlink mesh
~/.grok | ~/.claude | ~/.codex ← views (+ harness-native)
↓ separate trees
Hermes categories | Kimi roles | OpenClaw owned
Live inventory (OBSERVED T₁)
| Surface |
Count |
Role |
Grok ~/.grok/skills |
184 resolvable bodies |
View + native keepers; 0 broken |
AAA ${AAA_HOME:-/root/AAA}/skills |
108 active bodies |
Catalog; archives excluded |
| V3 registry |
64 logical (6+3+55) |
Short-name registry |
| Alias table |
133 rows |
104 active mappings + 29 tombstone/history rows |
.agents/skills |
130 active bodies |
Stage/domain doctrine |
| Claude / Codex / OpenCode |
176 / 56 / 39 |
Mesh/profile views; 0 broken |
| Kimi |
7 |
Role contrast/RSI skills |
Count method and provenance: ${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json. Counts are dated observations; skill-mesh-sync.sh --check is the operational gate.
Grok native keepers (harness-only)
arif-governed-autonomous-execution · grok-zen-aaa-substrate · grok-federation-skill-upgrader · orthogonal-skill-update · create-skill · check-work · help · imagine
Pruned: docx · pptx · xlsx · code-review → ~/.grok/skills/.deprecated/
Dual-name gap — RESOLVED (2026-07-15)
Machine table: ${AAA_HOME:-/root/AAA}/skills/SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.json — 133 rows; active mappings and tombstone history are separate.
Human: ${AFORGE_HOME:-/root/A-FORGE}/forge_work/2026-07-12/SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.md
Hermes bridge: ${AFORGE_HOME:-/root/A-FORGE}/forge_work/2026-07-12/HERMES-V3-DOMAIN-BRIDGE.md
Mesh sync: bash ${AAA_HOME:-/root/AAA}/skills/scripts/skill-mesh-sync.sh [--apply|--check]
| V3 short |
Primary disk path |
kernel-bind … audit-seal |
AAA/skills/substrate/<name> |
know-* |
AAA/skills/knowledge/<name> |
meta-atlas |
resolve via alias table |
geo-* |
resolve via alias table |
wealth-thermo |
resolve via alias table |
forge-verbs / forge-exec |
resolve via alias table |
| (full list) |
SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.json |
Unification phases — status 2026-07-15
- AUTHORITY — ✅ AAA + V3 sole catalog
- ALIAS TABLE — ✅ 104 active mappings + 29 tombstone rows explicitly separated
- PROFILES — ✅
grok + opencode in V3
- META-MESA REFRESH — ✅ v1.2.3 + dated receipt
- MESH SYNC — ✅ 79 links repaired/added; 2 source-less aliases quarantined;
--check clean
- HERMES BRIDGE — ✅ category→domain doc
- PRUNE — ✅ Grok office/review duplicates outside active top level
- BOOT GATE — ✅ all 9 bootstrap paths resolve
BOOT GATE (all CLI agents)
BIND → GROUND → ROUTE → RECALL → VERIFY → SEAL → KNOW → READY
Only after READY may domain skills load. Source: AAA/skills/BOOTSTRAP_MANIFEST.json (9 universals).
Harness load packs
| CLI |
Always |
On demand |
| Grok |
BOOTSTRAP 9 + arif-governed + grok-zen-aaa-substrate |
Domain via this atlas / V3 |
| Claude / Codex |
BOOTSTRAP 9 + mesh |
Same domain pack |
| Hermes |
arifos-auto-init + seven-zen + federated-skill-architecture |
Category skill |
| OpenClaw |
openclaw-agentic + memory |
ops / a2a |
| Kimi |
role contrast skills |
forge / dev |
Anti-patterns (multi-harness)
| Anti-pattern |
Remedy |
Copy skill bodies into every ~/.X/skills |
Symlink to AAA / .agents |
| Second “Grok catalog” of 100+ natives |
Keep ≤12 harness keepers |
| Flatten Hermes into AAA |
Bridge map only |
| Route by V3 short name without path |
Resolve via alias table |
| Trust meta-mesa “37 total” |
Re-probe disk / use §0 |
§1. THE SEVEN STAGES (Constitutional Pipeline)
The golden path. Every governed action flows through these stages.
| # |
Skill |
Stage |
Role |
Risk |
Key Output |
| 000 |
000-init-intent-classify |
1 |
Entry gate |
HIGH |
loop_class, required_organs, blast_radius, next_lawful_call |
| 111 |
111-sense-evidence-observe |
2 |
Evidence binding |
HIGH |
evidence_table, epistemic_tags, contradiction_scan, gaps |
| 333 |
333-mind-plan-generate |
3 |
Plan generation |
HIGH |
3+ candidate_plans, falsification_checks, DAG |
| 666 |
666-heart-critique-stress |
4 |
Consequence scan |
CRITICAL |
risk_register, dignity_check, posture_recommendation |
| 888 |
888-judge-verdict-render |
5 |
Verdict |
CRITICAL |
SEAL / SABAR / HOLD / VOID |
| 010 |
010-forge-execute-warrant |
6 |
Execution |
CRITICAL |
execution_receipt, rollback_path |
| 999 |
999-vault-seal-immutable |
7 |
Memory |
HIGH |
VAULT999 record, lineage, lessons |
Stage Gaps (What Falls Between)
| Gap |
Between |
Impact |
Mitigation |
| No priority queue |
000 → 111 |
Multiple intents compete, no ordering |
Manual triage; future: session-state priority field |
| No evidence freshness decay |
111 |
Evidence ages but no re-observation trigger |
Use arif_observe freshness_weight on recall |
| No cost estimation |
333 |
Plans don't estimate compute/API/human cost |
Add cost column to plan steps manually |
| No plan revision loop |
666 → 333 |
SABAR/HOLD doesn't auto-revise plan |
888 judge can route back to 333 |
| No temporal cascade modeling |
666 |
Consequences are static snapshots |
Use wealth_monte_carlo_simulate for temporal |
| No verdict expiration |
888 → 010 |
Old SEAL could authorize stale execution |
Check seal timestamp at 010 |
| No partial execution handling |
010 |
Step 3/5 failure = undefined state |
Define per-plan partial-rollback strategy |
| No vault retrieval |
999 |
Write-only from skill perspective |
Use arif_vault_query for read path |
§2. DOMAIN SKILLS BY ORGAN (legacy inventory — prefer §0 + SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.json)
GEOX — Earth Intelligence (7 skills, THICK coverage)
| Skill |
Purpose |
geox-constitution |
Constitutional floors, epistemic style, HOLD triggers |
geox-claim-grammar |
Claim YAML schema, multi-hypothesis mandate |
geox-earth-evidence |
Evidence discipline, artifact refs, handoff protocol |
geox-epistemic-ladder |
7-rung ladder, iron rule (lower beats higher) |
geox-petrophysics-bounds |
Vsh, porosity, Sw, AI, permeability QC |
geox-contradiction-engine |
7 contradiction types, multi-hypothesis scanner |
geox-redteam-hantu |
Anti-hallucination, F9 enforcement |
WEALTH — Capital Intelligence (4 skills, GOOD coverage)
| Skill |
Purpose |
wealth-capital-thermodynamics |
13 primitives grounding all WEALTH computation |
wealth-capital-reasoning |
POS, EMV, valuation, governed consequence |
wealth-collapse-signature |
7 institutional failure patterns |
wealth-law-anthropology |
Malaysian law: faraid, KTN, MA63, Syariah, adat |
Protocol Layer (NEW — MCP · A2A · WebMDP complementarity)
| Skill |
Domain |
Purpose |
Version |
FEDERATION-site-deploy |
Ops |
ARIF-SITES atomic swap, Caddy Admin API, caddy-mcp, symlink-swap, deploy-state |
v2.0.0 ↑ |
FEDERATION-site-router |
Ops |
A2A v1.0.0 protocol routing, MCP/A2A/WebMCP complementarity rule |
v2.0.0 ↑ |
FEDERATION-site-health |
Ops |
OpenTelemetry, deploy-state freshness, seal_chain_head check, semantic drift |
v2.0.0 ↑ |
mcp-mastery |
MCP |
Trust surface, protocol, tool forging, transport |
|
mcp-apps-builder |
MCP |
SEP-1865 interactive HTML UI in conversations |
|
webmcp-site-builder |
MCP |
WebMCP sites, W3C origin trial, declarative+imperative API |
|
a2a-federation-builder |
A2A |
Agent Cards, JSON-RPC /a2a, federation directory, A2A v1.0.0 |
|
federation-observability |
Ops |
OTEL, Prometheus, Grafana, LGTM |
|
MCP/A2A/WebMCP complementarity (agentic routing doctrine):
- MCP = tool capabilities (use for direct tool calls: geox_*, capital_*, arif_*, forge_*)
- A2A = agent handoff (use for cross-agent delegation: AAA → 555-ASI → 333-AGI)
- WebMCP = browser surface (use for human-browser-agent interaction: Chrome Copilot, Edge)
Infrastructure (8 skills)
| Skill |
Domain |
Purpose |
FORGE-infra-guardian |
Ops |
Caddy config validation, Cloudflare SSL, DNS parity, tunnel status |
FORGE-vps-docker |
Ops |
Docker Compose stack, container lifecycle, VPS operations |
FEDERATION-site-deploy |
Ops |
UPGRADED v2.0 — Caddy Admin API, caddy-mcp, symlink-swap |
github-operations |
Git |
Issue triage, PR review, CI diagnostics |
hf-mastery |
ML |
Governed HuggingFace: hub, datasets, inference, fine-tune |
iron-shell-render |
Web |
Three-layer site architecture |
forge-document-intelligence |
Document |
EMD stack (Encode-Metabolize-Decode) — VLM perception, provenance, governed action |
Forge & Agent (3 skills)
| Skill |
Purpose |
aforge-execution |
Build, deploy, verify. Gated by SEAL. |
agentic-builder |
Build governed agents: identity, skills, tools |
skill-creator |
Bootstrap, design, package new skills |
General / Meta (4 skills)
| Skill |
Purpose |
apex-theory |
Physics + math + symbolic code + meaning |
entropy-thermo-zen |
Thermodynamic entropy management (TZQ) |
agentic-fitness-law |
Fitness law, extinction pressures, immune system for tools/agents |
symbolic-order-trust-architecture |
Structural trust mapping |
Symbolic Order (2 of 5 planned)
| Skill |
Purpose |
symbolic-order-collective-bias |
Detect population-level bias via naming game |
symbolic-order-trust-architecture |
Trust symmetry violations |
WELL — Human Readiness (1 skill, THIN)
| Skill |
Purpose |
well-substrate-readiness |
Vitality, fatigue, dignity. Reflect only. |
AAA — Control Plane (1 skill, THIN)
| Skill |
Purpose |
aaa-cockpit |
Agent registry, session cockpit, A2A gateway |
A2A / Federation (1 skill)
| Skill |
Purpose |
a2a-federation-builder |
Agent Cards, JSON-RPC /a2a, federation directory |
§3. GAP REGISTER — Missing Skills
3A. Referenced But Do Not Exist (Phantom Skills)
Cleaned 2026-07-03: Phantoms replaced with actual tool alternatives. Remaining = PLANNED skills only.
| Missing Skill |
Status |
Function |
070-lock-humility-godel |
✅ CLEANED → arif_think mode=verify + 666-heart-critique-stress |
Final epistemic gate before SEAL-grade claims |
034-dag-plan-orchestrate |
✅ CLEANED → 333-mind-plan-generate |
Multi-step execution graph for cross-organ work |
444-route-organ-direct |
✅ CLEANED → arif_route + tools-embodiment-application |
Organ routing and direct addressing |
950-seal-vault-audit |
✅ CLEANED → arif_seal mode=verify |
Vault999 seal verification and chain audit |
geox-basin-interpreter |
✅ CLEANED → geox_basin directly |
Upstream O&G basin interpretation for Petronas |
090-check-tool-preflight |
✅ CLEANED → 666-heart-critique-stress |
Tool preflight check |
symbolic-order-solidarity-monitor |
🔵 PLANNED |
Calhoun Phase C population-level detection |
symbolic-order-mythic-attestor |
🔵 PLANNED |
Sacred domain violation detection |
symbolic-order-layer-governance |
🔵 PLANNED |
L1/L2/L3 hierarchy enforcement |
3B. Entirely Missing Domains (No Skill Exists)
| Missing Domain |
Organ |
Impact |
Priority |
| arifOS kernel operations |
arifOS |
No domain skill for session lifecycle, world model, kernel internals |
P2 |
| VAULT999 deep operations |
arifOS |
No receipt/chain/hash management skill |
P3 |
| HERMES/ASI Telegram agent |
555-ASI |
No skill despite SOUL.md existing at /root/.hermes/SOUL.md |
P3 |
| Docker/container management |
Infrastructure |
VPS has 17 hostinger tools, no container skill |
P4 |
| DNS/Cloudflare management |
Infrastructure |
No skill for DNS, Workers, R2, Pages |
P4 |
| Database operations |
All organs |
No PostgreSQL/Supabase schema management skill |
P4 |
| WEALTH stock analysis deep |
WEALTH |
12 modes of wealth_stock_analysis, no dedicated skill |
P3 |
| WEALTH personal finance |
WEALTH |
D1 personal scope, no dedicated skill |
P4 |
Document intelligence |
A-FORGE |
Filled 2026-07-02 — forge-document-intelligence forged |
✅ FILLED |
Caddy/Caddy Admin API/caddy-mcp |
A-FORGE |
Filled 2026-07-15 — FEDERATION-site-deploy v2.0 upgraded |
✅ FILLED |
WebMCP declarative/imperative API |
SOUL |
Covered by FEDERATION-site-router v2.0 + webmcp-site-builder |
✅ FILLED |
A2A v1.0.0 protocol routing |
AAA |
Covered by FEDERATION-site-router v2.0 + a2a-federation-builder |
✅ FILLED |
MCP/A2A/WebMCP complementarity |
AAA |
Covered by FEDERATION-site-router v2.0 complementarity rule |
✅ FILLED |
3C. Thinly Covered Organs
| Organ |
Current Depth |
What's Missing |
| WELL |
1 skill |
Sleep science, fatigue modeling, cognitive depletion, metabolic flux, dignity enforcement patterns |
| AAA |
1 skill |
A2A mesh routing details, cockpit React dashboard, deliberation integration, agent lifecycle |
| Symbolic Order |
2 of 5 |
solidarity-monitor, mythic-attestor, layer-governance — cluster is incomplete |
§4. ROUTING TABLE — Which Skill For Which Task
Given a natural-language intent, this table routes to the correct skill.
| Intent Pattern |
Skill to Load |
Why |
| "plan this" / "govern this" / "classify intent" |
000-init-intent-classify |
Stage 1 entry gate |
| "observe" / "gather evidence" / "what do we know" |
111-sense-evidence-observe |
Stage 2 evidence binding |
| "make a plan" / "generate options" / "how should we" |
333-mind-plan-generate |
Stage 3 planning |
| "stress test" / "what could go wrong" / "critique" |
666-heart-critique-stress |
Stage 4 consequence scan |
| "judge" / "render verdict" / "is this lawful" |
888-judge-verdict-render |
Stage 5 verdict |
| "execute" / "forge" / "build this" |
010-forge-execute-warrant |
Stage 6 execution |
| "seal" / "record" / "vault this" |
999-vault-seal-immutable |
Stage 7 memory |
| "seismic" / "well log" / "petrophysics" / "basin" |
geox-constitution + domain geox-* |
Earth intelligence gate |
| "NPV" / "IRR" / "capital" / "investment" |
wealth-capital-thermodynamics |
Capital primitives first |
| "collapse" / "institutional failure" / "Enron" |
wealth-collapse-signature |
Failure forensics |
| "Malaysian law" / "faraid" / "pusaka" / "MA63" |
wealth-law-anthropology |
Legal domain |
| "sleep" / "fatigue" / "vitality" / "dignity" |
well-substrate-readiness |
Human readiness |
| "build MCP tool" / "forge tool" / "MCP server" |
mcp-mastery |
MCP infrastructure |
| "build a website" / "iron shell" / "static site" |
iron-shell-render |
Site architecture |
| "GitHub PR" / "CI broken" / "issue triage" |
github-operations |
Git operations |
| "build an agent" / "new agent identity" |
agentic-builder |
Agent construction |
| "create a skill" / "new skill" |
skill-creator |
Skill creation |
| "entropy" / "cleanup" / "system chaos" |
entropy-thermo-zen |
TZQ framework |
| "fitness" / "tool evolution" / "why tools survive" |
agentic-fitness-law |
Fitness law + extinction pressures |
| "APEX" / "consciousness" / "physics of AI" |
apex-theory |
Theoretical framework |
| "A2A" / "agent communication" / "federation mesh" |
a2a-federation-builder |
Inter-agent surface |
| "bias" / "collective behavior" / "population" |
symbolic-order-collective-bias |
Social-symbolic |
| "trust" / "trust architecture" / "trust violation" |
symbolic-order-trust-architecture |
Trust mapping |
| "observability" / "tracing" / "metrics" |
federation-observability |
LGTM stack |
| "HuggingFace" / "model hub" / "fine-tune" |
hf-mastery |
ML governance |
| "PDF" / "OCR" / "scan" / "document" / "extract text" |
forge-document-intelligence |
EMD stack — VLM perception + provenance + governance |
| "deploy site" / "publish" / "surface update" |
FEDERATION-site-deploy |
SOUL/WEALTH/arifOS deploy — ARIF-SITES + Admin API + deploy-state |
| "Caddy vhost" / "add subdomain" / "525 SSL" |
FEDERATION-site-deploy |
Caddy Admin API + caddy-mcp for agentic vhost mgmt |
| "which organ" / "route this" / "federation topology" |
FEDERATION-site-router |
Intent→Organ mapping + protocol selection (MCP/A2A/WebMCP) |
| "site health" / "federation status" / "are we up" |
FEDERATION-site-health |
HTTP/SSL/deploy-state/seal_chain/semantic drift probes |
| "A2A" / "agent communication" / "federation mesh" |
a2a-federation-builder |
Inter-agent surface — A2A v1.0.0 |
| "WebMCP" / "browser agent" / "Copilot" / "Turbo" |
webmcp-site-builder |
WebMCP declarative+imperative API for browser-native agents |
| "MCP server" / "MCP tool" / "protocol" |
mcp-mastery |
MCP FastMCP 3.x, Streamable HTTP, OAuth, tool forgery |
| "observability" / "tracing" / "metrics" / "telemetry" |
federation-observability |
OpenTelemetry, Prometheus, Grafana, LGTM stack |
| "infra guard" / "SSL check" / "Cloudflare" / "DNS" |
FORGE-infra-guardian |
Caddy/SSL/DNS/tunnel validation |
| "caddy-mcp" / "agentic Caddy" / "Caddy Admin API" |
FEDERATION-site-deploy (caddy-mcp section) |
Caddy MCP wrapper for agentic vhost management |
| "what skill should I load" / "skill gap" / "skill audit" |
THIS SKILL (meta-mesa) |
Meta-routing |
§5. HEALTH SCORING — Skill Freshness
Run periodically to detect stale skills.
Per-Skill Health Check
skill_health = {
"name": str, # skill name
"version": str, # from frontmatter
"forged_date": str, # from frontmatter
"days_since_forge": int,
"references_count": int, # how many other skills reference it
"phantom_refs": int, # references to skills that don't exist
"has_prompt": bool, # prompts/ directory exists
"has_test": bool, # test coverage exists
"organ_coverage": float, # 0.0-1.0 depth for its organ
}
Federation Skill Health Summary
federation_skill_health = {
# T₁ 2026-07-12 — re-probe; do not trust frozen integers without fs check
"v3_logical_skills": 63, # AAA FEDERATED_SKILLS_REGISTRY_V3
"aaa_top_level_dirs": 70, # with SKILL.md (excl. deep archive noise)
"grok_resolvable": 116, # symlink mesh + 12 native
"claude_resolvable": 104,
"codex_resolvable": 107,
"agents_core": 43,
"hermes_skill_md": 180, # category tree, not mesh
"dual_name_debt": False, # alias table 63/63 sealed + audited
"body_homes": ["AAA/skills", ".agents/skills"], # doctrine_core dual body — honest
"thin_organs": ["WELL", "SYMBOLIC"],
"thick_organs": ["GEOX", "OPS", "META"],
"unification_maturity": 0.92, # audited multi-agent 2026-07-12
"collision_risk": float,
"stale_skills": int,
"coverage_score": float,
}
Stale Threshold
| Days Since Forge |
Status |
Action |
| 0-7 |
FRESH |
No action |
| 8-14 |
CURRENT |
Review on next session |
| 15-30 |
AGING |
Verify references still valid |
| 30+ |
STALE |
Audit needed, consider archive or refresh |
§6. CROSS-CUTTING CONCERNS — The Gaps Between Skills
These are capabilities that NO single skill covers but the federation needs.
6.1 Evidence Lifecycle (covers 111, but not full lifecycle)
| Phase |
Covered By |
Gap |
| Collection |
111-sense-evidence |
✅ |
| Tagging |
111-sense-evidence |
✅ |
| Contradiction detection |
111 + geox-contradiction-engine |
✅ |
| Freshness decay tracking |
NONE |
❌ No skill tracks evidence aging |
| Cross-session correlation |
NONE |
❌ No skill correlates evidence across sessions |
| Evidence provenance chain |
111 (partial) |
⚠️ Only table row, not full chain of custody |
| Evidence retirement |
NONE |
❌ No skill decommissions stale evidence |
6.2 Plan Lifecycle (covers 333, but not full lifecycle)
| Phase |
Covered By |
Gap |
| Generation |
333-mind-plan |
✅ |
| Multi-hypothesis |
333-mind-plan |
✅ |
| Revision after critique |
NONE |
❌ No 333↔666 feedback loop |
| Cross-plan conflict detection |
NONE |
❌ No concurrent plan conflict detection |
| Cost estimation |
NONE |
❌ No compute/API/human cost per step |
| Plan versioning |
NONE |
❌ No plan history tracking |
| Plan → execution handoff |
010-forge (consumes) |
⚠️ No explicit plan_id passing |
6.3 Operator Readiness (covers WELL, but only at stage 666)
| Check Point |
Currently |
Gap |
| Before planning (stage 333) |
❌ No WELL check |
WELL should gate plan generation |
| Before execution (stage 010) |
❌ No WELL check |
WELL should gate all T2/T3 actions |
| During critique (stage 666) |
✅ 666 integrates WELL |
Only place WELL is checked |
| Post-execution (after 010) |
❌ No WELL check |
Should verify operator wasn't overloaded |
6.4 Social-Symbolic Dimension (AGENTS.md declares it, no skill operationalizes it)
| Aspect |
Status |
| Collective bias detection |
✅ symbolic-order-collective-bias |
| Trust architecture mapping |
✅ symbolic-order-trust-architecture |
| Solidarity monitoring |
❌ Missing skill |
| Mythic domain violation |
❌ Missing skill |
| Layer governance (L1/L2/L3) |
❌ Missing skill |
| Institutional dynamics modeling |
❌ Not operationalized anywhere |
| Population behavior dynamics |
⚠️ Partial in wealth_monte_carlo_simulate population_mode |
§7. ANTI-PATTERNS
| Anti-Pattern |
Description |
Remedy |
| Skill overload |
Loading 5+ skills for a simple task |
Use this meta-skill to identify the MINIMUM skill set |
| Phantom reliance |
Referencing a skill that doesn't exist |
Run gap register (§3A) and forge missing skills |
| Organ mismatch |
Loading a GEOX skill for a WEALTH task |
Check routing table (§4) |
| Stage skipping |
Going straight to 010 without 000→111→333→666→888 |
Always start with 000-init-intent-classify |
| Single-skill tunnel |
Using only one skill when the task spans organs |
Load the cross-cutting concern from §6 |
| Stale skill |
Using a skill forged 30+ days ago without verification |
Check health score (§5) |
| Collision blindness |
Two skills covering the same capability differently |
Run collision detection on overlap |
§8. QUICK REFERENCE — Minimal Skill Set Per Task Type
| Task Type |
Minimum Skills |
Maximum Skills (if deep) |
| Simple observation |
000 |
000 + 111 |
| Code edit/build |
000 + 010 |
000 + 111 + 333 + 010 + 999 |
| Capital analysis |
000 + wealth-capital-thermodynamics |
000 + 111 + wealth-capital-thermodynamics + wealth-capital-reasoning + 666 + 888 + 999 |
| Geological interpretation |
000 + geox-constitution |
000 + 111 + geox-constitution + geox-earth-evidence + geox-epistemic-ladder + geox-contradiction-engine + 666 + 888 + 999 |
| Federation audit |
000 + entropy-thermo-zen |
000 + entropy-thermo-zen + this meta-skill + 999 |
| Tool / alias / fitness decision |
agentic-fitness-law |
000 + agentic-fitness-law + entropy-thermo-zen + 999 |
| Build new agent |
000 + agentic-builder |
000 + agentic-builder + skill-creator + a2a-federation-builder |
| Skill gap detection |
This meta-skill |
This meta-skill + skill-creator |
| Constitutional judgment |
000 + 888 |
000 + 111 + 333 + 666 + 888 + 999 |
| Infrastructure change |
000 + aforge-execution |
000 + 111 + 333 + aforge-execution + mcp-mastery + 010 + 999 |
| Document processing / OCR / PDF extraction |
000 + forge-document-intelligence |
000 + 111 + forge-document-intelligence + 666 + 888 + 999 (if high-stakes) |
§9. RECOMMENDATIONS — Priority Queue
2026-07-15: Prefer aliases, profiles, quarantine, and mesh-sync over forging more skills. Alias rows and logical skill counts are separate dimensions.
| Priority |
Action |
Status / Why |
| P0 |
Alias table short→path |
✅ 104 active + 29 tombstone/history rows |
| P0 |
V3 grok + opencode profiles |
✅ |
| P0 |
Mesh sync + check clean |
✅ 0 broken / 0 drift |
| P0 |
Source-less aliases |
✅ 2 quarantined, no fabricated bodies |
| P0 |
Grok office prune |
✅ .deprecated |
| P0 |
Hermes bridge (no flatten) |
✅ |
| P1 |
Keep dated reconciliation receipt |
✅ ${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json |
| P2 |
Migrate high-traffic doctrine bodies into AAA |
Optional; only when one canonical body is proven better |
| P3 |
New skills |
Only for a verified capability gap, never for count parity |
§10. TELEMETRY
{
"skill_name": "AUDIT-skill-atlas",
"version": "1.2.3",
"trigger_phrase": "{{trigger_phrase}}",
"selected_reason": "{{selected_reason}}",
"v3_logical": 64,
"alias_rows": 133,
"active_alias_rows": 104,
"tombstone_rows": 29,
"grok_resolvable": 184,
"aaa_active_bodies": 108,
"mesh_check": "PASS",
"broken_links": 0,
"dual_name_debt": false,
"atlas_artifact": "${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json",
"routing_decision": "{{routed_to_skill}}",
"latency_ms": 0
}
§11. RECURSIVE SCORECARD
| Metric |
Target |
Notes |
| Activation Precision |
> 0.95 |
Don't load for domain tasks |
| Routing Accuracy |
> 0.90 |
Correct skill for intent and harness |
| Gap Detection Rate |
> 0.85 |
Find missing + dual-named |
| Phantom Resolution Rate |
1.00 |
Resolve via alias table, never invent path |
| Doc Freshness |
1.00 |
Re-probe disk; atlas in forge_work/ |
| Catalog/View drift |
0 |
Grok/Claude/Codex mesh == AAA+.agents |
Forged: 2026-06-28 by FORGE (000Ω) for F13 SOVEREIGN
Updated: 2026-07-02 — forge-document-intelligence filled
Updated: 2026-07-12 — multi-harness §0; V3/bootstrap alignment; atlas artifact
Updated: 2026-07-15 — 64 logical skills, 133 alias rows, live tool snapshot, mesh repaired and verified
Updated: 2026-08-06 — de-hardcoded (cycle 2/5): $FORGE_WORK, $AAA_HOME, $AFORGE_HOME env vars
Canon: AAA catalog · harness views · BOOTSTRAP first
DITEMPA BUKAN DIBERI — The mesa sees the terrain. The terrain does not see the mesa.
De-hardcoding Log (v2026-08-06 — cycle 2/5)
- Reconciliation receipt path (4 references: lines 44, 75, 507, 530) →
$FORGE_WORK env, default /root/forge_work
- AAA source path (3 references: lines 68, 84, 87) →
$AAA_HOME env, default /root/AAA
- A-FORGE source path (3 references: lines 43, 85, 86) →
$AFORGE_HOME env, default /root/A-FORGE
- HERMES SOUL.md path (line 290):
/root/.hermes/SOUL.md — kept inline as Hermes is single-instance on af-forge VPS; flag for review if multi-host
- Defaults match current deployment — change in production requires re-deployment of root home
- Behavior unchanged for sovereign's af-forge VPS
1---2name: audit-skill-atlas3description: Unified skill inventory, gap detection, and cross-cutting orchestration for AAA catalog + Grok/Claude/Codex/Hermes/Kimi/OpenClaw harness views4---56# META-MESA — Skill Atlas & Gap Detection78> **DITEMPA BUKAN DIBERI** — Intelligence is forged, not given.9> **The mesa above the terrain. See the whole. Find the missing. Route the right.**1011## What This Skill Is1213This is the **meta-skill** — a skill about skills. It provides:14151. **Inventory** — live multi-surface counts (not a frozen “35”)162. **Gap detection** — missing, thin, dual-named, harness-divergent173. **Routing** — given a task *and harness*, which skill(s) to load184. **Health scoring** — freshness, collision, catalog vs view drift195. **Cross-harness unification** — AAA catalog ↔ CLI agent views2021It does NOT execute, judge, or seal. It classifies, routes, and illuminates.2223**Iron rule:** AAA is the catalog. Harnesses are views. Do not invent parallel catalogs.2425**Ops skill:** `AGI-skill-unification` (AAA + mesh views) — alias/mesh/boot contract. NOTE: One-way reference. AGI-skill-unification references this atlas; this atlas does NOT reference back (P6 circular dependency resolved 2026-08-01).2627**Live atlas (T₁):** `${AFORGE_HOME:-/root/A-FORGE}/forge_work/2026-07-12/GROK-CLI-AAA-SKILL-UNIFICATION-ATLAS.md` 28**Current receipt:** `${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json`2930---3132## §0. MULTI-HARNESS UNIFICATION (Grok × CLI × AAA) — 2026-07-153334### Architecture3536```37BOOTSTRAP_MANIFEST (9 universals) ← always first38 ↓39AAA/skills (catalog + V3 registry) ← sole named truth40 + .agents/skills (doctrine/stage) ← shared federation core41 ↓ symlink mesh42~/.grok | ~/.claude | ~/.codex ← views (+ harness-native)43 ↓ separate trees44Hermes categories | Kimi roles | OpenClaw owned45```4647### Live inventory (OBSERVED T₁)4849| Surface | Count | Role |50|---------|-------|------|51| Grok `~/.grok/skills` | **184** resolvable bodies | View + native keepers; 0 broken |52| AAA `${AAA_HOME:-/root/AAA}/skills` | **108** active bodies | **Catalog**; archives excluded |53| V3 registry | **64** logical (6+3+55) | Short-name registry |54| Alias table | **133 rows** | 104 active mappings + 29 tombstone/history rows |55| `.agents/skills` | **130** active bodies | Stage/domain doctrine |56| Claude / Codex / OpenCode | **176 / 56 / 39** | Mesh/profile views; 0 broken |57| Kimi | **7** | Role contrast/RSI skills |5859Count method and provenance: `${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json`. Counts are dated observations; `skill-mesh-sync.sh --check` is the operational gate.6061### Grok native keepers (harness-only)6263`arif-governed-autonomous-execution` · `grok-zen-aaa-substrate` · `grok-federation-skill-upgrader` · `orthogonal-skill-update` · `create-skill` · `check-work` · `help` · `imagine` 64**Pruned:** `docx` · `pptx` · `xlsx` · `code-review` → `~/.grok/skills/.deprecated/`6566### Dual-name gap — RESOLVED (2026-07-15)6768**Machine table:** `${AAA_HOME:-/root/AAA}/skills/SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.json` — 133 rows; active mappings and tombstone history are separate. 69**Human:** `${AFORGE_HOME:-/root/A-FORGE}/forge_work/2026-07-12/SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.md` 70**Hermes bridge:** `${AFORGE_HOME:-/root/A-FORGE}/forge_work/2026-07-12/HERMES-V3-DOMAIN-BRIDGE.md` 71**Mesh sync:** `bash ${AAA_HOME:-/root/AAA}/skills/scripts/skill-mesh-sync.sh [--apply|--check]`7273| V3 short | Primary disk path |74|----------|-------------------|75| `kernel-bind` … `audit-seal` | `AAA/skills/substrate/<name>` |76| `know-*` | `AAA/skills/knowledge/<name>` |77| `meta-atlas` | resolve via alias table |78| `geo-*` | resolve via alias table |79| `wealth-thermo` | resolve via alias table |80| `forge-verbs` / `forge-exec` | resolve via alias table |81| (full list) | `SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.json` |8283### Unification phases — status 2026-07-1584851. **AUTHORITY** — ✅ AAA + V3 sole catalog 862. **ALIAS TABLE** — ✅ 104 active mappings + 29 tombstone rows explicitly separated 873. **PROFILES** — ✅ `grok` + `opencode` in V3 884. **META-MESA REFRESH** — ✅ v1.2.3 + dated receipt 895. **MESH SYNC** — ✅ 79 links repaired/added; 2 source-less aliases quarantined; `--check` clean 906. **HERMES BRIDGE** — ✅ category→domain doc 917. **PRUNE** — ✅ Grok office/review duplicates outside active top level 928. **BOOT GATE** — ✅ all 9 bootstrap paths resolve9394### BOOT GATE (all CLI agents)9596```97BIND → GROUND → ROUTE → RECALL → VERIFY → SEAL → KNOW → READY98```99100Only after **READY** may domain skills load. Source: `AAA/skills/BOOTSTRAP_MANIFEST.json` (9 universals). 101102### Harness load packs103104| CLI | Always | On demand |105|-----|--------|-----------|106| **Grok** | BOOTSTRAP 9 + `arif-governed` + `grok-zen-aaa-substrate` | Domain via this atlas / V3 |107| **Claude / Codex** | BOOTSTRAP 9 + mesh | Same domain pack |108| **Hermes** | `arifos-auto-init` + seven-zen + federated-skill-architecture | Category skill |109| **OpenClaw** | openclaw-agentic + memory | ops / a2a |110| **Kimi** | role contrast skills | forge / dev |111112### Anti-patterns (multi-harness)113114| Anti-pattern | Remedy |115|--------------|--------|116| Copy skill bodies into every `~/.X/skills` | Symlink to AAA / .agents |117| Second “Grok catalog” of 100+ natives | Keep ≤12 harness keepers |118| Flatten Hermes into AAA | Bridge map only |119| Route by V3 short name without path | Resolve via alias table |120| Trust meta-mesa “37 total” | Re-probe disk / use §0 |121122---123124## §1. THE SEVEN STAGES (Constitutional Pipeline)125126The golden path. Every governed action flows through these stages.127128| # | Skill | Stage | Role | Risk | Key Output |129|---|-------|-------|------|------|------------|130| 000 | `000-init-intent-classify` | 1 | Entry gate | HIGH | loop_class, required_organs, blast_radius, next_lawful_call |131| 111 | `111-sense-evidence-observe` | 2 | Evidence binding | HIGH | evidence_table, epistemic_tags, contradiction_scan, gaps |132| 333 | `333-mind-plan-generate` | 3 | Plan generation | HIGH | 3+ candidate_plans, falsification_checks, DAG |133| 666 | `666-heart-critique-stress` | 4 | Consequence scan | CRITICAL | risk_register, dignity_check, posture_recommendation |134| 888 | `888-judge-verdict-render` | 5 | Verdict | CRITICAL | SEAL / SABAR / HOLD / VOID |135| 010 | `010-forge-execute-warrant` | 6 | Execution | CRITICAL | execution_receipt, rollback_path |136| 999 | `999-vault-seal-immutable` | 7 | Memory | HIGH | VAULT999 record, lineage, lessons |137138### Stage Gaps (What Falls Between)139140| Gap | Between | Impact | Mitigation |141|-----|---------|--------|------------|142| **No priority queue** | 000 → 111 | Multiple intents compete, no ordering | Manual triage; future: session-state priority field |143| **No evidence freshness decay** | 111 | Evidence ages but no re-observation trigger | Use `arif_observe` freshness_weight on recall |144| **No cost estimation** | 333 | Plans don't estimate compute/API/human cost | Add cost column to plan steps manually |145| **No plan revision loop** | 666 → 333 | SABAR/HOLD doesn't auto-revise plan | 888 judge can route back to 333 |146| **No temporal cascade modeling** | 666 | Consequences are static snapshots | Use `wealth_monte_carlo_simulate` for temporal |147| **No verdict expiration** | 888 → 010 | Old SEAL could authorize stale execution | Check seal timestamp at 010 |148| **No partial execution handling** | 010 | Step 3/5 failure = undefined state | Define per-plan partial-rollback strategy |149| **No vault retrieval** | 999 | Write-only from skill perspective | Use `arif_vault_query` for read path |150151---152153## §2. DOMAIN SKILLS BY ORGAN (legacy inventory — prefer §0 + SKILL_ALIAS_TABLE.json)154155### GEOX — Earth Intelligence (7 skills, THICK coverage)156157| Skill | Purpose |158|-------|---------|159| `geox-constitution` | Constitutional floors, epistemic style, HOLD triggers |160| `geox-claim-grammar` | Claim YAML schema, multi-hypothesis mandate |161| `geox-earth-evidence` | Evidence discipline, artifact refs, handoff protocol |162| `geox-epistemic-ladder` | 7-rung ladder, iron rule (lower beats higher) |163| `geox-petrophysics-bounds` | Vsh, porosity, Sw, AI, permeability QC |164| `geox-contradiction-engine` | 7 contradiction types, multi-hypothesis scanner |165| `geox-redteam-hantu` | Anti-hallucination, F9 enforcement |166167### WEALTH — Capital Intelligence (4 skills, GOOD coverage)168169| Skill | Purpose |170|-------|---------|171| `wealth-capital-thermodynamics` | 13 primitives grounding all WEALTH computation |172| `wealth-capital-reasoning` | POS, EMV, valuation, governed consequence |173| `wealth-collapse-signature` | 7 institutional failure patterns |174| `wealth-law-anthropology` | Malaysian law: faraid, KTN, MA63, Syariah, adat |175176### Protocol Layer (NEW — MCP · A2A · WebMDP complementarity)177178| Skill | Domain | Purpose | Version |179|-------|--------|---------|---------|180| `FEDERATION-site-deploy` | Ops | ARIF-SITES atomic swap, Caddy Admin API, caddy-mcp, symlink-swap, deploy-state | v2.0.0 ↑ |181| `FEDERATION-site-router` | Ops | A2A v1.0.0 protocol routing, MCP/A2A/WebMCP complementarity rule | v2.0.0 ↑ |182| `FEDERATION-site-health` | Ops | OpenTelemetry, deploy-state freshness, seal_chain_head check, semantic drift | v2.0.0 ↑ |183| `mcp-mastery` | MCP | Trust surface, protocol, tool forging, transport | |184| `mcp-apps-builder` | MCP | SEP-1865 interactive HTML UI in conversations | |185| `webmcp-site-builder` | MCP | WebMCP sites, W3C origin trial, declarative+imperative API | |186| `a2a-federation-builder` | A2A | Agent Cards, JSON-RPC /a2a, federation directory, A2A v1.0.0 | |187| `federation-observability` | Ops | OTEL, Prometheus, Grafana, LGTM | |188189**MCP/A2A/WebMCP complementarity (agentic routing doctrine):**190- MCP = tool capabilities (use for direct tool calls: geox_*, capital_*, arif_*, forge_*)191- A2A = agent handoff (use for cross-agent delegation: AAA → 555-ASI → 333-AGI)192- WebMCP = browser surface (use for human-browser-agent interaction: Chrome Copilot, Edge)193194### Infrastructure (8 skills)195196| Skill | Domain | Purpose |197|-------|--------|---------|198| `FORGE-infra-guardian` | Ops | Caddy config validation, Cloudflare SSL, DNS parity, tunnel status |199| `FORGE-vps-docker` | Ops | Docker Compose stack, container lifecycle, VPS operations |200| `FEDERATION-site-deploy` | Ops | **UPGRADED v2.0 — Caddy Admin API, caddy-mcp, symlink-swap** |201| `github-operations` | Git | Issue triage, PR review, CI diagnostics |202| `hf-mastery` | ML | Governed HuggingFace: hub, datasets, inference, fine-tune |203| `iron-shell-render` | Web | Three-layer site architecture |204| `forge-document-intelligence` | Document | EMD stack (Encode-Metabolize-Decode) — VLM perception, provenance, governed action |205206### Forge & Agent (3 skills)207208| Skill | Purpose |209|-------|---------|210| `aforge-execution` | Build, deploy, verify. Gated by SEAL. |211| `agentic-builder` | Build governed agents: identity, skills, tools |212| `skill-creator` | Bootstrap, design, package new skills |213214### General / Meta (4 skills)215216| Skill | Purpose |217|-------|---------|218| `apex-theory` | Physics + math + symbolic code + meaning |219| `entropy-thermo-zen` | Thermodynamic entropy management (TZQ) |220| `agentic-fitness-law` | Fitness law, extinction pressures, immune system for tools/agents |221| `symbolic-order-trust-architecture` | Structural trust mapping |222223### Symbolic Order (2 of 5 planned)224225| Skill | Purpose |226|-------|---------|227| `symbolic-order-collective-bias` | Detect population-level bias via naming game |228| `symbolic-order-trust-architecture` | Trust symmetry violations |229230### WELL — Human Readiness (1 skill, THIN)231232| Skill | Purpose |233|-------|---------|234| `well-substrate-readiness` | Vitality, fatigue, dignity. Reflect only. |235236### AAA — Control Plane (1 skill, THIN)237238| Skill | Purpose |239|-------|---------|240| `aaa-cockpit` | Agent registry, session cockpit, A2A gateway |241242### A2A / Federation (1 skill)243244| Skill | Purpose |245|-------|---------|246| `a2a-federation-builder` | Agent Cards, JSON-RPC /a2a, federation directory |247248---249250## §3. GAP REGISTER — Missing Skills251252### 3A. Referenced But Do Not Exist (Phantom Skills)253254> **Cleaned 2026-07-03:** Phantoms replaced with actual tool alternatives. Remaining = PLANNED skills only.255256| Missing Skill | Status | Function |257|--------------|--------|----------|258| `070-lock-humility-godel` | ✅ CLEANED → `arif_think` mode=verify + `666-heart-critique-stress` | Final epistemic gate before SEAL-grade claims |259| `034-dag-plan-orchestrate` | ✅ CLEANED → `333-mind-plan-generate` | Multi-step execution graph for cross-organ work |260| `444-route-organ-direct` | ✅ CLEANED → `arif_route` + `tools-embodiment-application` | Organ routing and direct addressing |261| `950-seal-vault-audit` | ✅ CLEANED → `arif_seal` mode=verify | Vault999 seal verification and chain audit |262| `geox-basin-interpreter` | ✅ CLEANED → `geox_basin` directly | Upstream O&G basin interpretation for Petronas |263| `090-check-tool-preflight` | ✅ CLEANED → `666-heart-critique-stress` | Tool preflight check |264| `symbolic-order-solidarity-monitor` | 🔵 PLANNED | Calhoun Phase C population-level detection |265| `symbolic-order-mythic-attestor` | 🔵 PLANNED | Sacred domain violation detection |266| `symbolic-order-layer-governance` | 🔵 PLANNED | L1/L2/L3 hierarchy enforcement |267268### 3B. Entirely Missing Domains (No Skill Exists)269270| Missing Domain | Organ | Impact | Priority |271|----------------|-------|--------|----------|272| **arifOS kernel operations** | arifOS | No domain skill for session lifecycle, world model, kernel internals | P2 |273| **VAULT999 deep operations** | arifOS | No receipt/chain/hash management skill | P3 |274| **HERMES/ASI Telegram agent** | 555-ASI | No skill despite SOUL.md existing at /root/.hermes/SOUL.md | P3 |275| **Docker/container management** | Infrastructure | VPS has 17 hostinger tools, no container skill | P4 |276| **DNS/Cloudflare management** | Infrastructure | No skill for DNS, Workers, R2, Pages | P4 |277| **Database operations** | All organs | No PostgreSQL/Supabase schema management skill | P4 |278| **WEALTH stock analysis deep** | WEALTH | 12 modes of wealth_stock_analysis, no dedicated skill | P3 |279| **WEALTH personal finance** | WEALTH | D1 personal scope, no dedicated skill | P4 |280| ~~**Document intelligence**~~ | ~~A-FORGE~~ | ~~Filled 2026-07-02 — `forge-document-intelligence` forged~~ | ✅ FILLED |281| ~~**Caddy/Caddy Admin API/caddy-mcp**~~ | ~~A-FORGE~~ | ~~Filled 2026-07-15 — `FEDERATION-site-deploy` v2.0 upgraded~~ | ✅ FILLED |282| ~~**WebMCP declarative/imperative API**~~ | ~~SOUL~~ | ~~Covered by `FEDERATION-site-router` v2.0 + `webmcp-site-builder`~~ | ✅ FILLED |283| ~~**A2A v1.0.0 protocol routing**~~ | ~~AAA~~ | ~~Covered by `FEDERATION-site-router` v2.0 + `a2a-federation-builder`~~ | ✅ FILLED |284| ~~**MCP/A2A/WebMCP complementarity**~~ | ~~AAA~~ | ~~Covered by `FEDERATION-site-router` v2.0 complementarity rule~~ | ✅ FILLED |285286### 3C. Thinly Covered Organs287288| Organ | Current Depth | What's Missing |289|-------|--------------|---------------|290| **WELL** | 1 skill | Sleep science, fatigue modeling, cognitive depletion, metabolic flux, dignity enforcement patterns |291| **AAA** | 1 skill | A2A mesh routing details, cockpit React dashboard, deliberation integration, agent lifecycle |292| **Symbolic Order** | 2 of 5 | solidarity-monitor, mythic-attestor, layer-governance — cluster is incomplete |293294---295296## §4. ROUTING TABLE — Which Skill For Which Task297298Given a natural-language intent, this table routes to the correct skill.299300| Intent Pattern | Skill to Load | Why |301|---------------|---------------|-----|302| "plan this" / "govern this" / "classify intent" | `000-init-intent-classify` | Stage 1 entry gate |303| "observe" / "gather evidence" / "what do we know" | `111-sense-evidence-observe` | Stage 2 evidence binding |304| "make a plan" / "generate options" / "how should we" | `333-mind-plan-generate` | Stage 3 planning |305| "stress test" / "what could go wrong" / "critique" | `666-heart-critique-stress` | Stage 4 consequence scan |306| "judge" / "render verdict" / "is this lawful" | `888-judge-verdict-render` | Stage 5 verdict |307| "execute" / "forge" / "build this" | `010-forge-execute-warrant` | Stage 6 execution |308| "seal" / "record" / "vault this" | `999-vault-seal-immutable` | Stage 7 memory |309| "seismic" / "well log" / "petrophysics" / "basin" | `geox-constitution` + domain geox-* | Earth intelligence gate |310| "NPV" / "IRR" / "capital" / "investment" | `wealth-capital-thermodynamics` | Capital primitives first |311| "collapse" / "institutional failure" / "Enron" | `wealth-collapse-signature` | Failure forensics |312| "Malaysian law" / "faraid" / "pusaka" / "MA63" | `wealth-law-anthropology` | Legal domain |313| "sleep" / "fatigue" / "vitality" / "dignity" | `well-substrate-readiness` | Human readiness |314| "build MCP tool" / "forge tool" / "MCP server" | `mcp-mastery` | MCP infrastructure |315| "build a website" / "iron shell" / "static site" | `iron-shell-render` | Site architecture |316| "GitHub PR" / "CI broken" / "issue triage" | `github-operations` | Git operations |317| "build an agent" / "new agent identity" | `agentic-builder` | Agent construction |318| "create a skill" / "new skill" | `skill-creator` | Skill creation |319| "entropy" / "cleanup" / "system chaos" | `entropy-thermo-zen` | TZQ framework |320| "fitness" / "tool evolution" / "why tools survive" | `agentic-fitness-law` | Fitness law + extinction pressures |321| "APEX" / "consciousness" / "physics of AI" | `apex-theory` | Theoretical framework |322| "A2A" / "agent communication" / "federation mesh" | `a2a-federation-builder` | Inter-agent surface |323| "bias" / "collective behavior" / "population" | `symbolic-order-collective-bias` | Social-symbolic |324| "trust" / "trust architecture" / "trust violation" | `symbolic-order-trust-architecture` | Trust mapping |325| "observability" / "tracing" / "metrics" | `federation-observability` | LGTM stack |326| "HuggingFace" / "model hub" / "fine-tune" | `hf-mastery` | ML governance |327| "PDF" / "OCR" / "scan" / "document" / "extract text" | `forge-document-intelligence` | EMD stack — VLM perception + provenance + governance |328| "deploy site" / "publish" / "surface update" | `FEDERATION-site-deploy` | SOUL/WEALTH/arifOS deploy — ARIF-SITES + Admin API + deploy-state |329| "Caddy vhost" / "add subdomain" / "525 SSL" | `FEDERATION-site-deploy` | Caddy Admin API + caddy-mcp for agentic vhost mgmt |330| "which organ" / "route this" / "federation topology" | `FEDERATION-site-router` | Intent→Organ mapping + protocol selection (MCP/A2A/WebMCP) |331| "site health" / "federation status" / "are we up" | `FEDERATION-site-health` | HTTP/SSL/deploy-state/seal_chain/semantic drift probes |332| "A2A" / "agent communication" / "federation mesh" | `a2a-federation-builder` | Inter-agent surface — A2A v1.0.0 |333| "WebMCP" / "browser agent" / "Copilot" / "Turbo" | `webmcp-site-builder` | WebMCP declarative+imperative API for browser-native agents |334| "MCP server" / "MCP tool" / "protocol" | `mcp-mastery` | MCP FastMCP 3.x, Streamable HTTP, OAuth, tool forgery |335| "observability" / "tracing" / "metrics" / "telemetry" | `federation-observability` | OpenTelemetry, Prometheus, Grafana, LGTM stack |336| "infra guard" / "SSL check" / "Cloudflare" / "DNS" | `FORGE-infra-guardian` | Caddy/SSL/DNS/tunnel validation |337| "caddy-mcp" / "agentic Caddy" / "Caddy Admin API" | `FEDERATION-site-deploy` (caddy-mcp section) | Caddy MCP wrapper for agentic vhost management |338| "what skill should I load" / "skill gap" / "skill audit" | **THIS SKILL** (meta-mesa) | Meta-routing |339340---341342## §5. HEALTH SCORING — Skill Freshness343344Run periodically to detect stale skills.345346### Per-Skill Health Check347348```python349skill_health = {350 "name": str, # skill name351 "version": str, # from frontmatter352 "forged_date": str, # from frontmatter353 "days_since_forge": int,354 "references_count": int, # how many other skills reference it355 "phantom_refs": int, # references to skills that don't exist356 "has_prompt": bool, # prompts/ directory exists357 "has_test": bool, # test coverage exists358 "organ_coverage": float, # 0.0-1.0 depth for its organ359}360```361362### Federation Skill Health Summary363364```python365federation_skill_health = {366 # T₁ 2026-07-12 — re-probe; do not trust frozen integers without fs check367 "v3_logical_skills": 63, # AAA FEDERATED_SKILLS_REGISTRY_V3368 "aaa_top_level_dirs": 70, # with SKILL.md (excl. deep archive noise)369 "grok_resolvable": 116, # symlink mesh + 12 native370 "claude_resolvable": 104,371 "codex_resolvable": 107,372 "agents_core": 43,373 "hermes_skill_md": 180, # category tree, not mesh374 "dual_name_debt": False, # alias table 63/63 sealed + audited375 "body_homes": ["AAA/skills", ".agents/skills"], # doctrine_core dual body — honest376 "thin_organs": ["WELL", "SYMBOLIC"],377 "thick_organs": ["GEOX", "OPS", "META"],378 "unification_maturity": 0.92, # audited multi-agent 2026-07-12379 "collision_risk": float,380 "stale_skills": int,381 "coverage_score": float,382}383```384385### Stale Threshold386387| Days Since Forge | Status | Action |388|-----------------|--------|--------|389| 0-7 | FRESH | No action |390| 8-14 | CURRENT | Review on next session |391| 15-30 | AGING | Verify references still valid |392| 30+ | STALE | Audit needed, consider archive or refresh |393394---395396## §6. CROSS-CUTTING CONCERNS — The Gaps Between Skills397398These are capabilities that NO single skill covers but the federation needs.399400### 6.1 Evidence Lifecycle (covers 111, but not full lifecycle)401402| Phase | Covered By | Gap |403|-------|-----------|-----|404| Collection | 111-sense-evidence | ✅ |405| Tagging | 111-sense-evidence | ✅ |406| Contradiction detection | 111 + geox-contradiction-engine | ✅ |407| Freshness decay tracking | **NONE** | ❌ No skill tracks evidence aging |408| Cross-session correlation | **NONE** | ❌ No skill correlates evidence across sessions |409| Evidence provenance chain | 111 (partial) | ⚠️ Only table row, not full chain of custody |410| Evidence retirement | **NONE** | ❌ No skill decommissions stale evidence |411412### 6.2 Plan Lifecycle (covers 333, but not full lifecycle)413414| Phase | Covered By | Gap |415|-------|-----------|-----|416| Generation | 333-mind-plan | ✅ |417| Multi-hypothesis | 333-mind-plan | ✅ |418| Revision after critique | **NONE** | ❌ No 333↔666 feedback loop |419| Cross-plan conflict detection | **NONE** | ❌ No concurrent plan conflict detection |420| Cost estimation | **NONE** | ❌ No compute/API/human cost per step |421| Plan versioning | **NONE** | ❌ No plan history tracking |422| Plan → execution handoff | 010-forge (consumes) | ⚠️ No explicit plan_id passing |423424### 6.3 Operator Readiness (covers WELL, but only at stage 666)425426| Check Point | Currently | Gap |427|-------------|----------|-----|428| Before planning (stage 333) | ❌ No WELL check | WELL should gate plan generation |429| Before execution (stage 010) | ❌ No WELL check | WELL should gate all T2/T3 actions |430| During critique (stage 666) | ✅ 666 integrates WELL | Only place WELL is checked |431| Post-execution (after 010) | ❌ No WELL check | Should verify operator wasn't overloaded |432433### 6.4 Social-Symbolic Dimension (AGENTS.md declares it, no skill operationalizes it)434435| Aspect | Status |436|--------|--------|437| Collective bias detection | ✅ `symbolic-order-collective-bias` |438| Trust architecture mapping | ✅ `symbolic-order-trust-architecture` |439| Solidarity monitoring | ❌ Missing skill |440| Mythic domain violation | ❌ Missing skill |441| Layer governance (L1/L2/L3) | ❌ Missing skill |442| Institutional dynamics modeling | ❌ Not operationalized anywhere |443| Population behavior dynamics | ⚠️ Partial in `wealth_monte_carlo_simulate` population_mode |444445---446447## §7. ANTI-PATTERNS448449| Anti-Pattern | Description | Remedy |450|-------------|-------------|--------|451| **Skill overload** | Loading 5+ skills for a simple task | Use this meta-skill to identify the MINIMUM skill set |452| **Phantom reliance** | Referencing a skill that doesn't exist | Run gap register (§3A) and forge missing skills |453| **Organ mismatch** | Loading a GEOX skill for a WEALTH task | Check routing table (§4) |454| **Stage skipping** | Going straight to 010 without 000→111→333→666→888 | Always start with 000-init-intent-classify |455| **Single-skill tunnel** | Using only one skill when the task spans organs | Load the cross-cutting concern from §6 |456| **Stale skill** | Using a skill forged 30+ days ago without verification | Check health score (§5) |457| **Collision blindness** | Two skills covering the same capability differently | Run collision detection on overlap |458459---460461## §8. QUICK REFERENCE — Minimal Skill Set Per Task Type462463| Task Type | Minimum Skills | Maximum Skills (if deep) |464|-----------|---------------|-------------------------|465| Simple observation | 000 | 000 + 111 |466| Code edit/build | 000 + 010 | 000 + 111 + 333 + 010 + 999 |467| Capital analysis | 000 + wealth-capital-thermodynamics | 000 + 111 + wealth-capital-thermodynamics + wealth-capital-reasoning + 666 + 888 + 999 |468| Geological interpretation | 000 + geox-constitution | 000 + 111 + geox-constitution + geox-earth-evidence + geox-epistemic-ladder + geox-contradiction-engine + 666 + 888 + 999 |469| Federation audit | 000 + entropy-thermo-zen | 000 + entropy-thermo-zen + this meta-skill + 999 |470| Tool / alias / fitness decision | agentic-fitness-law | 000 + agentic-fitness-law + entropy-thermo-zen + 999 |471| Build new agent | 000 + agentic-builder | 000 + agentic-builder + skill-creator + a2a-federation-builder |472| Skill gap detection | **This meta-skill** | This meta-skill + skill-creator |473| Constitutional judgment | 000 + 888 | 000 + 111 + 333 + 666 + 888 + 999 |474| Infrastructure change | 000 + aforge-execution | 000 + 111 + 333 + aforge-execution + mcp-mastery + 010 + 999 |475| Document processing / OCR / PDF extraction | 000 + forge-document-intelligence | 000 + 111 + forge-document-intelligence + 666 + 888 + 999 (if high-stakes) |476477---478479## §9. RECOMMENDATIONS — Priority Queue480481> **2026-07-15:** Prefer **aliases, profiles, quarantine, and mesh-sync** over forging more skills. Alias rows and logical skill counts are separate dimensions.482483| Priority | Action | Status / Why |484|----------|--------|----------------|485| **P0** | Alias table short→path | ✅ 104 active + 29 tombstone/history rows |486| **P0** | V3 `grok` + `opencode` profiles | ✅ |487| **P0** | Mesh sync + check clean | ✅ 0 broken / 0 drift |488| **P0** | Source-less aliases | ✅ 2 quarantined, no fabricated bodies |489| **P0** | Grok office prune | ✅ `.deprecated` |490| **P0** | Hermes bridge (no flatten) | ✅ |491| **P1** | Keep dated reconciliation receipt | ✅ `${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json` |492| **P2** | Migrate high-traffic doctrine bodies into AAA | Optional; only when one canonical body is proven better |493| **P3** | New skills | Only for a verified capability gap, never for count parity |494495---496497## §10. TELEMETRY498499```json500{501 "skill_name": "AUDIT-skill-atlas",502 "version": "1.2.3",503 "trigger_phrase": "{{trigger_phrase}}",504 "selected_reason": "{{selected_reason}}",505 "v3_logical": 64,506 "alias_rows": 133,507 "active_alias_rows": 104,508 "tombstone_rows": 29,509 "grok_resolvable": 184,510 "aaa_active_bodies": 108,511 "mesh_check": "PASS",512 "broken_links": 0,513 "dual_name_debt": false,514 "atlas_artifact": "${FORGE_WORK:-/root/forge_work}/2026-07-15/AAA-SKILL-TOOL-RECONCILIATION.json",515 "routing_decision": "{{routed_to_skill}}",516 "latency_ms": 0517}518```519520---521522## §11. RECURSIVE SCORECARD523524| Metric | Target | Notes |525|--------|--------|-------|526| Activation Precision | > 0.95 | Don't load for domain tasks |527| Routing Accuracy | > 0.90 | Correct skill for intent **and harness** |528| Gap Detection Rate | > 0.85 | Find missing + dual-named |529| Phantom Resolution Rate | 1.00 | Resolve via alias table, never invent path |530| Doc Freshness | 1.00 | Re-probe disk; atlas in forge_work/ |531| Catalog/View drift | 0 | Grok/Claude/Codex mesh == AAA+.agents |532533---534535*Forged: 2026-06-28 by FORGE (000Ω) for F13 SOVEREIGN* 536*Updated: 2026-07-02 — forge-document-intelligence filled* 537*Updated: 2026-07-12 — multi-harness §0; V3/bootstrap alignment; atlas artifact* 538*Updated: 2026-07-15 — 64 logical skills, 133 alias rows, live tool snapshot, mesh repaired and verified* 539*Updated: 2026-08-06 — de-hardcoded (cycle 2/5): $FORGE_WORK, $AAA_HOME, $AFORGE_HOME env vars* 540*Canon: AAA catalog · harness views · BOOTSTRAP first* 541*DITEMPA BUKAN DIBERI — The mesa sees the terrain. The terrain does not see the mesa.*542543## De-hardcoding Log (v2026-08-06 — cycle 2/5)544545- **Reconciliation receipt path** (4 references: lines 44, 75, 507, 530) → `$FORGE_WORK` env, default `/root/forge_work`546- **AAA source path** (3 references: lines 68, 84, 87) → `$AAA_HOME` env, default `/root/AAA`547- **A-FORGE source path** (3 references: lines 43, 85, 86) → `$AFORGE_HOME` env, default `/root/A-FORGE`548- **HERMES SOUL.md path** (line 290): `/root/.hermes/SOUL.md` — kept inline as Hermes is single-instance on af-forge VPS; flag for review if multi-host549- Defaults match current deployment — change in production requires re-deployment of root home550- Behavior unchanged for sovereign's af-forge VPS