ariffazil FORGE-musyawarah-gotong
Make musyawarah and gotong royong fire. Do not role-play both voices in one process.
What is real
MUSYAWARAH 333-agi ARCHITECT ∥ 555-asi AUDITOR (read-only, independent)
CONVERGE parent synthesizes; 888-apex only on residual disagreement
GOTONG sequential hop: previous output = next STATE_IN
A sibling may share what it saw. It may not tell you what to be.
(inter-agent-protocol.md §11)
What is fake (do not cite as musyawarah)
aaa_capability_loader._musyawawah_phase is an in-process heuristic. Same function speaks ARCHITECT, AUDITOR, and SOVEREIGN, then stamps SEALED_MUSYAWARAH_CONSENSUS. That is not F3. Field musyawarah_kind: in_process_heuristic.
Hermes skill forge-musyawawah-deliberation is the Hermes adapter (7-phase, delegate_task). Use it on Hermes. Do not copy it onto Grok.
When it MUST fire
| Class | Musyawarah | Gotong |
|---|---|---|
| T0/T1 reads, grep, local reversible edit | No. Auto-do. | No. |
| T2/T3, deploy, capital, SEAL, F13-adjacent dispute | Yes. Two independent voices before mutate. | After dual GO only. |
| Sembang / angan-angan | VOID. | VOID. |
How it fires
Grok: workflow musyawarah-gotong at /root/.grok/workflows/musyawarah-gotong.rhai
args.dispute = one question, two defensible positions (required)
args.files = paths to read (optional)
args.execute = true only after you want the gotong hop (default false)
Hermes: forge-musyawawah-deliberation (existing). Same physics: parent drafts first, sibling does not see parent draft, Lane A ≠ Lane B.
Any harness without the workflow: spawn 333-agi + 555-asi in parallel with FORGE-subagent-spawn, capability read-only, then parent converges. Do not let them write guidance.
Artifacts
Position files / structured output_schema, not a chatboard.
forge_work/<id>/ARCHITECT_POSITION.md
forge_work/<id>/AUDITOR_POSITION.md
forge_work/<id>/SYNTHESIS.md (agree / residual / surprises)
Workflow scratch: SYNTHESIS.md on the run.
Rules
- Voices do not see each other during musyawarah. Contamination = invalid run.
- Parent never voices SOVEREIGN. 888 recommends; kernel
effective_verdict/ F13 seals. - Dual GO +
execute=false→ packet only. Gotong does not silently mutate. - Gotong hop is isolation worktree, reversible,
inclusive_deltarequired, no unilateral extras. - Missing/failed voice → HOLD (fail closed). A silent auditor is not consent.
- Loader
SEALED_MUSYAWARAH_CONSENSUSis not a musyawarah receipt.
Anti-patterns
- One model playing ARCHITECT + AUDITOR + SOVEREIGN
- Sibling chatboard as the deliberation surface
kind=guidancefrom a specialist- Claiming SEAL after Lane B / heuristic stamp
- Running musyawarah on T1 grep
DITEMPA BUKAN DIBERI