ECSS Structures — COPC with Metallic Liner (space-systems/ecss/copc-metallic-liner)
Use when the task is the structural verification of a Composite Overwrapped
Pressure Container (COPC) with a metallic liner under ECSS-E-ST-32 clause
4.5.2 — confirming that the liner material is recognized, the proof and burst
pressure factors meet the required minimums, the liner remains elastic at
proof pressure, the fatigue cycle budget is covered by a scatter factor of at
least four, and leak-before-burst is demonstrated by fracture mechanics before
pressurised qualification is declared.
Domain quick reference
- A COPC consists of a metallic liner that provides the gas-tight barrier and
a composite overwrap that carries the primary structural load. The liner and
overwrap interact through hoop load-sharing; for verification purposes the
liner hoop stress is computed via the thin-wall formula (σ = P × r / t) using
the liner's own geometry, valid only when t/r < 0.1.
- The metallic liner must remain elastic — hoop stress strictly below yield
stress — at proof pressure. Proof pressure = MEOP × proof factor (minimum
1.1 per clause 4.5.2). A liner that yields at proof is no longer a reliable
leak-tight barrier and the vessel fails this gate before any further check is
applied.
- Burst pressure = MEOP × burst factor (minimum 1.5). The complete vessel
(liner and overwrap combined) must withstand the required burst pressure
without rupture. Demonstrated burst capacity is compared against the required
value and a finding is raised on any shortfall.
- Leak-before-burst (LBB) is verified via fracture mechanics: for a
semi-elliptical surface crack on the liner inner wall, the critical flaw
half-depth a_c = (K_Ic / (Y × σ_MEOP))² / π. LBB is demonstrated when
a_c exceeds the liner wall thickness, meaning a crack propagates through-wall
and produces a detectable leak before reaching fracture-critical size.
- Fatigue cycle life is verified by checking that the demonstrated or analyzed
allowable cycle count, divided by a scatter factor of at least four (per
ECSS-E-ST-32 clause 4.5.2), covers the mission design cycle count.
- Recognized metallic liner materials include aluminium alloys (2014, 2219,
6061), titanium alloys (Ti-6Al-4V, CP-4), stainless steels (316L, 321), and
nickel superalloys (Inconel 718). Unrecognized materials require separate
material qualification before entry into this assessment.
Workflow
- Confirm the liner material is in the recognized set. Reject any
unrecognized material with a clear finding; do not proceed with fabricated
material properties.
- Verify the proof pressure factor (proof pressure / MEOP) meets the
minimum of 1.1. Record the shortfall if it does not.
- Verify the burst pressure factor (required burst pressure / MEOP) meets
the minimum of 1.5. Record the shortfall if it does not.
- Compute the liner hoop stress at proof pressure using the thin-wall
formula (σ = P × r / t). First check that t/r < 0.1; if not, flag the
thin-wall assumption as violated and require thick-wall analysis before
continuing.
- Compare the liner hoop stress at proof pressure against the liner yield
stress. The liner must be strictly elastic (stress < yield). A yield margin
at or below zero is a blocking finding that must be resolved before the
vessel enters qualification.
- Compute the liner hoop stress at MEOP and check the margin of safety
(yield / hoop − 1) is positive. A negative margin at MEOP is a finding
even when the liner remains elastic at proof, because MEOP represents the
sustained operating condition.
- Demonstrate leak-before-burst: compute a_c using the liner's fracture
toughness K_Ic and hoop stress at MEOP. Confirm a_c exceeds the liner wall
thickness. If not, flag LBB as undemonstrated; the vessel requires either a
liner material change or geometry modification before qualification.
- Check the fatigue cycle budget: divide the demonstrated or analyzed
allowable cycle count by the scatter factor (minimum 4.0) and confirm the
result is at or above the mission design cycle count. Flag any deficit.
- Confirm the vessel's demonstrated or computed burst pressure meets or
exceeds the required burst pressure (MEOP × burst factor).
- Aggregate all findings. The COPC metallic liner verification is closed
only when the findings list is empty across all nine checks above.
Pitfalls
- Applying the thin-wall formula without checking the t/r ratio first. When
t/r ≥ 0.1, the thin-wall stress is unconservative and must be replaced by a
thick-wall or finite-element result before any elasticity check is valid.
- Confusing proof-pressure elasticity with MEOP margin. ECSS-E-ST-32 clause
4.5.2 requires the liner to remain elastic at proof pressure; a separate
margin of safety check at MEOP is also required because MEOP represents the
sustained operating condition.
- Reversing the LBB condition. LBB is satisfied when a_c is larger than the
wall thickness, not smaller. A larger critical flaw depth means the crack
must grow further before becoming unstable — and since it goes through-wall
first, it leaks rather than bursting.
- Using a fatigue scatter factor below four. ECSS-E-ST-32 clause 4.5.2 sets a
minimum scatter factor of four for metallic liner fatigue life; a scatter
factor of two or three is not compliant even if derived from test data.
- Treating burst capability as demonstrated by analysis alone when a physical
burst test is required by the project acceptance plan. Confirm whether the
acceptance plan requires a physical burst test or accepts a certified burst
analysis before closing this finding.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
All eight individual checks and the top-level assessment are exercised by the
gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_copc_metallic_liner.py against
scripts/copc_metallic_liner_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_copc_metallic_liner.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase
per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: copc-metallic-liner3description: "Use when verify a composite overwrapped pressure container (COPC) with metallic liner per ECSS-E-ST-32 clause 4.5.2: confirm the liner remains elastic at proof pressure, compute the margin-of-safety on liner hoop stress at maximum expected operating pressure, validate proof and burst pressure factors against required minimums, demonstrate leak-before-burst by confirming the fracture-mechanics critical flaw depth exceeds the liner wall thickness, and check the fatigue-cycle budget against a cycle-life scatter factor of at least four before pressurised qualification is declared. Trigger: ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, copc, metallic-liner, pressure-vessel, leak-before-burst, fatigue-cycle-budget, fracture-mechanics, proof-pressure, burst-factor."4license: Apache-2.05compliance: STANDARDS-REF6standards:7 - id: ecss8 reference-only: true9gated: false10domain: space-systems11pack: space-systems12compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/copc-metallic-liner15 domain: space-systems16 subdomain: ecss17 tags: [ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, copc, metallic-liner, pressure-vessel, leak-before-burst, pressure-cycle-fatigue]18 version: 0.1.019 author: Aero Agent Skills20---2122# ECSS Structures — COPC with Metallic Liner (space-systems/ecss/copc-metallic-liner)2324Use when the task is the structural verification of a Composite Overwrapped25Pressure Container (COPC) with a metallic liner under ECSS-E-ST-32 clause264.5.2 — confirming that the liner material is recognized, the proof and burst27pressure factors meet the required minimums, the liner remains elastic at28proof pressure, the fatigue cycle budget is covered by a scatter factor of at29least four, and leak-before-burst is demonstrated by fracture mechanics before30pressurised qualification is declared.3132## Domain quick reference3334- A COPC consists of a metallic liner that provides the gas-tight barrier and35 a composite overwrap that carries the primary structural load. The liner and36 overwrap interact through hoop load-sharing; for verification purposes the37 liner hoop stress is computed via the thin-wall formula (σ = P × r / t) using38 the liner's own geometry, valid only when t/r < 0.1.39- The metallic liner must remain elastic — hoop stress strictly below yield40 stress — at proof pressure. Proof pressure = MEOP × proof factor (minimum41 1.1 per clause 4.5.2). A liner that yields at proof is no longer a reliable42 leak-tight barrier and the vessel fails this gate before any further check is43 applied.44- Burst pressure = MEOP × burst factor (minimum 1.5). The complete vessel45 (liner and overwrap combined) must withstand the required burst pressure46 without rupture. Demonstrated burst capacity is compared against the required47 value and a finding is raised on any shortfall.48- Leak-before-burst (LBB) is verified via fracture mechanics: for a49 semi-elliptical surface crack on the liner inner wall, the critical flaw50 half-depth a_c = (K_Ic / (Y × σ_MEOP))² / π. LBB is demonstrated when51 a_c exceeds the liner wall thickness, meaning a crack propagates through-wall52 and produces a detectable leak before reaching fracture-critical size.53- Fatigue cycle life is verified by checking that the demonstrated or analyzed54 allowable cycle count, divided by a scatter factor of at least four (per55 ECSS-E-ST-32 clause 4.5.2), covers the mission design cycle count.56- Recognized metallic liner materials include aluminium alloys (2014, 2219,57 6061), titanium alloys (Ti-6Al-4V, CP-4), stainless steels (316L, 321), and58 nickel superalloys (Inconel 718). Unrecognized materials require separate59 material qualification before entry into this assessment.6061## Workflow62631. Confirm the liner material is in the recognized set. Reject any64 unrecognized material with a clear finding; do not proceed with fabricated65 material properties.662. Verify the proof pressure factor (proof pressure / MEOP) meets the67 minimum of 1.1. Record the shortfall if it does not.683. Verify the burst pressure factor (required burst pressure / MEOP) meets69 the minimum of 1.5. Record the shortfall if it does not.704. Compute the liner hoop stress at proof pressure using the thin-wall71 formula (σ = P × r / t). First check that t/r < 0.1; if not, flag the72 thin-wall assumption as violated and require thick-wall analysis before73 continuing.745. Compare the liner hoop stress at proof pressure against the liner yield75 stress. The liner must be strictly elastic (stress < yield). A yield margin76 at or below zero is a blocking finding that must be resolved before the77 vessel enters qualification.786. Compute the liner hoop stress at MEOP and check the margin of safety79 (yield / hoop − 1) is positive. A negative margin at MEOP is a finding80 even when the liner remains elastic at proof, because MEOP represents the81 sustained operating condition.827. Demonstrate leak-before-burst: compute a_c using the liner's fracture83 toughness K_Ic and hoop stress at MEOP. Confirm a_c exceeds the liner wall84 thickness. If not, flag LBB as undemonstrated; the vessel requires either a85 liner material change or geometry modification before qualification.868. Check the fatigue cycle budget: divide the demonstrated or analyzed87 allowable cycle count by the scatter factor (minimum 4.0) and confirm the88 result is at or above the mission design cycle count. Flag any deficit.899. Confirm the vessel's demonstrated or computed burst pressure meets or90 exceeds the required burst pressure (MEOP × burst factor).9110. Aggregate all findings. The COPC metallic liner verification is closed92 only when the findings list is empty across all nine checks above.9394## Pitfalls9596- Applying the thin-wall formula without checking the t/r ratio first. When97 t/r ≥ 0.1, the thin-wall stress is unconservative and must be replaced by a98 thick-wall or finite-element result before any elasticity check is valid.99- Confusing proof-pressure elasticity with MEOP margin. ECSS-E-ST-32 clause100 4.5.2 requires the liner to remain elastic at proof pressure; a separate101 margin of safety check at MEOP is also required because MEOP represents the102 sustained operating condition.103- Reversing the LBB condition. LBB is satisfied when a_c is larger than the104 wall thickness, not smaller. A larger critical flaw depth means the crack105 must grow further before becoming unstable — and since it goes through-wall106 first, it leaks rather than bursting.107- Using a fatigue scatter factor below four. ECSS-E-ST-32 clause 4.5.2 sets a108 minimum scatter factor of four for metallic liner fatigue life; a scatter109 factor of two or three is not compliant even if derived from test data.110- Treating burst capability as demonstrated by analysis alone when a physical111 burst test is required by the project acceptance plan. Confirm whether the112 acceptance plan requires a physical burst test or accepts a certified burst113 analysis before closing this finding.114115## Behavior contract (gate 3)116117All eight individual checks and the top-level assessment are exercised by the118gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_copc_metallic_liner.py against119scripts/copc_metallic_liner_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:120python3 scripts/test_copc_metallic_liner.py121122## Compliance123124- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase125 per standards-map.yaml.126- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.