ECSS Structures — Fracture Control Analysis DRD (space-systems/ecss/drd-fracture-control-analysis)
Use when the task is producing a fracture control analysis (FCA) report
whose content satisfies the data requirements of ECSS-E-ST-32 Annex E
(Fracture Control Analysis report) and the damage-tolerance verification
requirements of ECSS-E-ST-32-01. The report must demonstrate that every
fracture-critical structural item carries adequate residual strength after
the assumed initial flaw, grows that flaw slowly enough to meet a damage-tolerance
life with scatter factor, and — for pressurised items — leaks before it bursts.
Domain quick reference
- Fracture criticality: each structural item is categorized as
fracture-critical (FC) if its failure mode under the assumed flaw could
be catastrophic (loss of mission, crew hazard, or uncontained rupture),
or as non-fracture-critical (NFC) otherwise. Only FC items require the
full FCA calculation chain; NFC items are documented and closed out.
- Stress intensity factor: the applied stress intensity factor
K = Y × σ × √(π a), where Y is a geometry correction factor,
σ is the net-section applied stress in MPa, and a is the assumed
half-flaw length in metres. K is compared against the material's
plane-strain fracture toughness K_IC (or K_c for thin sections)
after dividing by the required safety factor to obtain the allowable.
- Critical flaw size: the half-flaw length a_c at which K equals K_IC
under the design stress, derived by inverting the K equation.
a_c = (1/π) × (K_IC / (Y × σ))². A_c must exceed the minimum
detectable flaw of the selected NDI method; if it does not, the design
or material choice must be revised before the report can close.
- Crack-growth life: Paris-law integration (da/dN = C × ΔK^m) from
the assumed initial flaw a_i to the critical flaw a_c gives a crack-growth
life N_g. The computed life must satisfy N_g ≥ N_req × DTF, where
N_req is the required structural life and DTF is the damage-tolerance
scatter factor (commonly 4 for metallic structure per ECSS-E-ST-32-01).
- Leak-before-burst (LBB): for pressurised components, the critical
flaw half-length must equal or exceed the wall thickness, confirming that
a through-wall crack (detectable by leak) forms before the flaw reaches
fracture instability at the design pressure. Failure of the LBB check
requires a proof-pressure programme or design change.
- NDI detectability: the assumed initial flaw a_i must be at or above
the minimum detectable flaw size of the NDI method applied during
manufacture and in-service inspection. If the NDI method cannot reliably
detect flaws as small as a_i, the assumed a_i is non-conservative and
must be revised upward (or a more capable NDI method adopted).
Workflow
- List every load-carrying structural item in scope and categorize each one
as FC or NFC based on failure consequence (catastrophic → FC). Items
with an unrecognised consequence classification must be rejected before
the analysis proceeds.
- For each FC item, obtain (a) the design net-section stress σ, (b) the
assumed initial half-flaw length a_i (set at the NDI detection threshold),
(c) the material fracture toughness K_IC, (d) the Paris-law constants
C and m for the material and environment, and (e) the geometry correction
factor Y.
- Compute K_applied = Y × σ × √(π × a_i / 1000) (converting a_i from mm
to metres). Compare K_applied against K_IC / SF, where SF is the required
safety factor; flag an exceedance as a finding.
- Derive the critical flaw size a_c = (1/π) × (K_IC / (Y × σ))² × 1000 mm.
Confirm a_c > a_i; if a_c ≤ a_i the item fails immediately at the initial
flaw and the design must change.
- Integrate Paris-law crack growth from a_i to a_c numerically to obtain
N_g cycles. Apply the damage-tolerance scatter factor: if N_g < N_req × DTF,
flag a damage-tolerance shortfall.
- For every pressurised FC item, run the LBB check: confirm
a_c ≥ wall thickness. Flag a failure.
- Verify that the NDI method's minimum detectable flaw ≤ a_i; flag a
mismatch as a non-conservatism finding.
- Aggregate all findings. The FCA report is closed only when no open findings
remain for any FC item.
Pitfalls
- Assuming a zero initial flaw — the fracture control analysis must always
start from a finite, NDI-capability-bounded initial flaw size. A zero
initial flaw produces infinite computed life, which is non-physical and
non-compliant.
- Applying a scalar safety factor to the stress σ rather than to K directly —
the ECSS-E-ST-32 safety factor convention is applied to the allowable K,
not to the input stress; applying it to stress double-counts the non-linearity
in the √a term.
- Skipping the LBB check for items that are "only lightly pressurised" —
the LBB criterion applies whenever internal pressure contributes to the
structural load path; pressure level does not exempt the item.
- Using a geometry factor Y = 1.0 for all geometries — Y = 1.0 is only
valid for a central through-crack in an infinite plate under uniform
tension. Surface flaws, corner cracks, and finite-width panels all require
appropriate Y corrections; using 1.0 for these cases unconservatively
underestimates K.
- Treating NFC documentation as optional — every item categorized as NFC
must appear in the FCA report with the consequence rationale recorded;
an undocumented NFC item is an open finding, not an implicit pass.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The item-categorization, stress-intensity, critical-flaw, crack-growth
integration, LBB, damage-tolerance, NDI-detectability, and report-aggregation
logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:
scripts/test_drd_fracture_control_analysis.py against
scripts/drd_fracture_control_analysis_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_drd_fracture_control_analysis.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite source and paraphrase
per standards-map.yaml.
- Anchor clauses: ECSS-E-ST-32 Annex E (FCA report content);
ECSS-E-ST-32-01 (damage-tolerance and fracture control requirements).
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: drd-fracture-control-analysis3description: "Use when determine the content of a fracture control analysis report4 for a space structure per ECSS-E-ST-32 Annex E: categorize each structural item as5 fracture-critical or non-fracture-critical, compute the applied stress intensity factor6 from net-section stress and assumed flaw geometry, verify it against material fracture7 toughness with a required safety factor, derive the critical flaw size, integrate8 Paris-law crack-growth to establish damage-tolerance life, verify the leak-before-burst9 condition for pressurized components, and confirm the selected non-destructive10 inspection method can detect the assumed initial flaw. Trigger: ecss,11 e-st-32-structures-scope, fracture-control, damage-tolerance, fracture-critical,12 stress-intensity, crack-propagation, leak-before-burst, flaw-assessment."13license: Apache-2.014compliance: STANDARDS-REF15standards:16 - id: ecss17 reference-only: true18gated: false19domain: space-systems20pack: space-systems21compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"22metadata:23 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/drd-fracture-control-analysis24 domain: space-systems25 subdomain: ecss26 tags: [ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, fracture-control, damage-tolerance, fracture-critical, stress-intensity, crack-propagation, leak-before-burst, flaw-assessment]27 version: 0.1.028 author: Aero Agent Skills29---3031# ECSS Structures — Fracture Control Analysis DRD (space-systems/ecss/drd-fracture-control-analysis)3233Use when the task is producing a fracture control analysis (FCA) report34whose content satisfies the data requirements of ECSS-E-ST-32 Annex E35(Fracture Control Analysis report) and the damage-tolerance verification36requirements of ECSS-E-ST-32-01. The report must demonstrate that every37fracture-critical structural item carries adequate residual strength after38the assumed initial flaw, grows that flaw slowly enough to meet a damage-tolerance39life with scatter factor, and — for pressurised items — leaks before it bursts.4041## Domain quick reference4243- **Fracture criticality**: each structural item is categorized as44 fracture-critical (FC) if its failure mode under the assumed flaw could45 be catastrophic (loss of mission, crew hazard, or uncontained rupture),46 or as non-fracture-critical (NFC) otherwise. Only FC items require the47 full FCA calculation chain; NFC items are documented and closed out.48- **Stress intensity factor**: the applied stress intensity factor49 K = Y × σ × √(π a), where Y is a geometry correction factor,50 σ is the net-section applied stress in MPa, and a is the assumed51 half-flaw length in metres. K is compared against the material's52 plane-strain fracture toughness K_IC (or K_c for thin sections)53 after dividing by the required safety factor to obtain the allowable.54- **Critical flaw size**: the half-flaw length a_c at which K equals K_IC55 under the design stress, derived by inverting the K equation.56 a_c = (1/π) × (K_IC / (Y × σ))². A_c must exceed the minimum57 detectable flaw of the selected NDI method; if it does not, the design58 or material choice must be revised before the report can close.59- **Crack-growth life**: Paris-law integration (da/dN = C × ΔK^m) from60 the assumed initial flaw a_i to the critical flaw a_c gives a crack-growth61 life N_g. The computed life must satisfy N_g ≥ N_req × DTF, where62 N_req is the required structural life and DTF is the damage-tolerance63 scatter factor (commonly 4 for metallic structure per ECSS-E-ST-32-01).64- **Leak-before-burst (LBB)**: for pressurised components, the critical65 flaw half-length must equal or exceed the wall thickness, confirming that66 a through-wall crack (detectable by leak) forms before the flaw reaches67 fracture instability at the design pressure. Failure of the LBB check68 requires a proof-pressure programme or design change.69- **NDI detectability**: the assumed initial flaw a_i must be at or above70 the minimum detectable flaw size of the NDI method applied during71 manufacture and in-service inspection. If the NDI method cannot reliably72 detect flaws as small as a_i, the assumed a_i is non-conservative and73 must be revised upward (or a more capable NDI method adopted).7475## Workflow76771. List every load-carrying structural item in scope and categorize each one78 as FC or NFC based on failure consequence (catastrophic → FC). Items79 with an unrecognised consequence classification must be rejected before80 the analysis proceeds.812. For each FC item, obtain (a) the design net-section stress σ, (b) the82 assumed initial half-flaw length a_i (set at the NDI detection threshold),83 (c) the material fracture toughness K_IC, (d) the Paris-law constants84 C and m for the material and environment, and (e) the geometry correction85 factor Y.863. Compute K_applied = Y × σ × √(π × a_i / 1000) (converting a_i from mm87 to metres). Compare K_applied against K_IC / SF, where SF is the required88 safety factor; flag an exceedance as a finding.894. Derive the critical flaw size a_c = (1/π) × (K_IC / (Y × σ))² × 1000 mm.90 Confirm a_c > a_i; if a_c ≤ a_i the item fails immediately at the initial91 flaw and the design must change.925. Integrate Paris-law crack growth from a_i to a_c numerically to obtain93 N_g cycles. Apply the damage-tolerance scatter factor: if N_g < N_req × DTF,94 flag a damage-tolerance shortfall.956. For every pressurised FC item, run the LBB check: confirm96 a_c ≥ wall thickness. Flag a failure.977. Verify that the NDI method's minimum detectable flaw ≤ a_i; flag a98 mismatch as a non-conservatism finding.998. Aggregate all findings. The FCA report is closed only when no open findings100 remain for any FC item.101102## Pitfalls103104- Assuming a zero initial flaw — the fracture control analysis must always105 start from a finite, NDI-capability-bounded initial flaw size. A zero106 initial flaw produces infinite computed life, which is non-physical and107 non-compliant.108- Applying a scalar safety factor to the stress σ rather than to K directly —109 the ECSS-E-ST-32 safety factor convention is applied to the allowable K,110 not to the input stress; applying it to stress double-counts the non-linearity111 in the √a term.112- Skipping the LBB check for items that are "only lightly pressurised" —113 the LBB criterion applies whenever internal pressure contributes to the114 structural load path; pressure level does not exempt the item.115- Using a geometry factor Y = 1.0 for all geometries — Y = 1.0 is only116 valid for a central through-crack in an infinite plate under uniform117 tension. Surface flaws, corner cracks, and finite-width panels all require118 appropriate Y corrections; using 1.0 for these cases unconservatively119 underestimates K.120- Treating NFC documentation as optional — every item categorized as NFC121 must appear in the FCA report with the consequence rationale recorded;122 an undocumented NFC item is an open finding, not an implicit pass.123124## Behavior contract (gate 3)125126The item-categorization, stress-intensity, critical-flaw, crack-growth127integration, LBB, damage-tolerance, NDI-detectability, and report-aggregation128logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:129scripts/test_drd_fracture_control_analysis.py against130scripts/drd_fracture_control_analysis_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:131132 python3 scripts/test_drd_fracture_control_analysis.py133134## Compliance135136- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite source and paraphrase137 per standards-map.yaml.138- Anchor clauses: ECSS-E-ST-32 Annex E (FCA report content);139 ECSS-E-ST-32-01 (damage-tolerance and fracture control requirements).140- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.