ECSS Verification — Review-of-Design Report DRD (space-systems/ecss/e1002-rod-report)
Use when the verification method is review of design under
ECSS-E-ST-10-02 clause 5.3.2.3 and Annex D -- where the evidence is
documentary, and its worth depends entirely on who looked, at what
revision, against what checklist.
Domain quick reference
- Independence is the property that makes this method work. A designer
reviewing their own drawing reads what they meant rather than what
they drew, so the review returns the design's own assumptions.
- Independence is checked by identity against the design authors, never
by a declaration in the report. A report can describe a review as
independent while the reviewer signed the drawing.
- A partially conflicted panel and a wholly conflicted one are different
findings. One names the individual to swap out; the other says the
review has no independent view in it at all and must be redone.
- Every reviewed document is pinned to a revision. A review of an
unversioned document cannot be repeated, and says nothing at all
after the next change to that document.
- Each checklist item carries a result. An adverse item carries a
disposition, because an unsatisfactory finding with no decision
attached is an observation that closes nothing.
- A not-applicable item carries a justification. Without it,
"not applicable" is the cheapest way to make a checklist pass.
- The verdict turns on disposition, not on count: an item accepted or
waived closes, an item with an action still raised leaves the review
open. A review with an open action has not finished, however few they
are.
- A report that reviewed no documents at all is reported explicitly; an
empty document set otherwise passes every per-document check
vacuously.
Workflow
- Confirm reviewers are assigned, then check each against the design
author list; report conflicted individuals and a wholly conflicted
panel separately.
- Confirm every reviewed document carries a pinned revision, and that
at least one document was reviewed.
- For each checklist item, confirm a result; for an adverse result
confirm a valid disposition; for not-applicable confirm a
justification.
- Derive the verdict: open while any adverse item is neither accepted
nor waived, closed otherwise.
- The evidence is acceptable only when the review closed with no
finding standing.
Pitfalls
- Accepting a report's own statement that the review was independent.
The check is the reviewer roster against the author roster.
- Treating one independent reviewer on a conflicted panel as sufficient
without naming the conflicts; the conflicted members still shaped the
discussion.
- Listing reviewed documents by title only. At the next revision nobody
can say what was actually examined.
- Closing a review with actions still raised, on the grounds that they
are tracked elsewhere. Tracked is not dispositioned.
- Marking items not applicable to clear a checklist, with no
justification recorded for any of them.
- Running every per-document check over an empty document set and
reporting a clean review that examined nothing.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The independence, reviewer-panel, document-revision, checklist-result,
disposition and verdict logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:
scripts/test_e1002_rod_report.py against
scripts/e1002_rod_report_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_e1002_rod_report.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and
paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: e1002-rod-report3description: "Use when produce or audit a review-of-design report against the ECSS-E-ST-10-02 clause 5.3.2.3 and Annex D Document Requirements Definition: confirm the review panel exists and is independent of the design authors by identity rather than by declaration, confirm every reviewed document is pinned to a revision, confirm each checklist item carries a result with an adverse item dispositioned and a not-applicable item justified, and close the review only when nothing adverse remains open. Trigger: ecss, e-st-10-02c, review-of-design, annex-d-drd, reviewer-independence, checklist-disposition, document-revision, design-evidence."4license: Apache-2.05compliance: STANDARDS-REF6standards:7 - id: ecss8 reference-only: true9gated: false10domain: space-systems11pack: space-systems12compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/e1002-rod-report15 domain: space-systems16 subdomain: ecss17 tags: [ecss, e-st-10-02c, review-of-design, annex-d-drd, reviewer-independence, checklist-disposition, document-revision]18 version: 0.1.019 author: Aero Agent Skills20---2122# ECSS Verification — Review-of-Design Report DRD (space-systems/ecss/e1002-rod-report)2324Use when the verification method is review of design under25ECSS-E-ST-10-02 clause 5.3.2.3 and Annex D -- where the evidence is26documentary, and its worth depends entirely on who looked, at what27revision, against what checklist.2829## Domain quick reference3031- Independence is the property that makes this method work. A designer32 reviewing their own drawing reads what they meant rather than what33 they drew, so the review returns the design's own assumptions.34- Independence is checked by identity against the design authors, never35 by a declaration in the report. A report can describe a review as36 independent while the reviewer signed the drawing.37- A partially conflicted panel and a wholly conflicted one are different38 findings. One names the individual to swap out; the other says the39 review has no independent view in it at all and must be redone.40- Every reviewed document is pinned to a revision. A review of an41 unversioned document cannot be repeated, and says nothing at all42 after the next change to that document.43- Each checklist item carries a result. An adverse item carries a44 disposition, because an unsatisfactory finding with no decision45 attached is an observation that closes nothing.46- A not-applicable item carries a justification. Without it,47 "not applicable" is the cheapest way to make a checklist pass.48- The verdict turns on disposition, not on count: an item accepted or49 waived closes, an item with an action still raised leaves the review50 open. A review with an open action has not finished, however few they51 are.52- A report that reviewed no documents at all is reported explicitly; an53 empty document set otherwise passes every per-document check54 vacuously.5556## Workflow57581. Confirm reviewers are assigned, then check each against the design59 author list; report conflicted individuals and a wholly conflicted60 panel separately.612. Confirm every reviewed document carries a pinned revision, and that62 at least one document was reviewed.633. For each checklist item, confirm a result; for an adverse result64 confirm a valid disposition; for not-applicable confirm a65 justification.664. Derive the verdict: open while any adverse item is neither accepted67 nor waived, closed otherwise.685. The evidence is acceptable only when the review closed with no69 finding standing.7071## Pitfalls7273- Accepting a report's own statement that the review was independent.74 The check is the reviewer roster against the author roster.75- Treating one independent reviewer on a conflicted panel as sufficient76 without naming the conflicts; the conflicted members still shaped the77 discussion.78- Listing reviewed documents by title only. At the next revision nobody79 can say what was actually examined.80- Closing a review with actions still raised, on the grounds that they81 are tracked elsewhere. Tracked is not dispositioned.82- Marking items not applicable to clear a checklist, with no83 justification recorded for any of them.84- Running every per-document check over an empty document set and85 reporting a clean review that examined nothing.8687## Behavior contract (gate 3)8889The independence, reviewer-panel, document-revision, checklist-result,90disposition and verdict logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:91scripts/test_e1002_rod_report.py against92scripts/e1002_rod_report_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:93python3 scripts/test_e1002_rod_report.py9495## Compliance9697- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and98 paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.99- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.