ECSS Emission of Solar Protons (ESP) Fluence Spectra (space-systems/ecss/e1004-b6-esp)
Use when the task is generating the Annex B.6 Emission of Solar Protons
(ESP) worst-case fluence spectra under ECSS-E-ST-10-04C, to obtain a
design integral fluence-above-energy spectrum for a solar-proton
radiation-design case.
Domain quick reference
- The ESP model is probabilistic, not deterministic: instead of a
single fixed event spectrum, it returns a design fluence keyed to two
case parameters -- the mission's exposure duration and a design
confidence level (the probability that the true mission fluence will
not exceed the returned value).
- Longer exposure duration raises the design fluence: a longer mission
has more opportunity to encounter a large solar-proton event, so its
worst-case fluence grows with duration, though not in direct
proportion to it.
- A higher confidence level raises the design fluence: bounding a
larger fraction of the event-size probability distribution requires
reaching further into the rare, large-event tail, so fluence grows
as the confidence level approaches its upper limit.
- The model reports fluence at a fixed set of proton energy thresholds
(an integral spectrum: fluence of protons at or above each threshold
energy), not a continuous differential spectrum and not a peak
(instantaneous) flux -- confusing the ESP integral design fluence
with a peak flux figure understates or overstates dose/SEE-rate
estimates depending on which quantity the downstream calculation
actually needs.
- Most radiation-design guidance treats a confidence level below about
90% as insufficient for a worst-case design fluence; lower confidence
levels are appropriate only for trade studies or non-worst-case
sensitivity analysis, not for the design case itself.
- This leaf scopes ESP fluence-spectrum generation and the worst-case
confidence-level check only. Rolling the ESP result into the mission
radiation environment specification alongside GCR (sibling e1004-gcr
leaf) and trapped-radiation environments is the sibling
e1004-rad-env-spec leaf (clause 9.3).
Workflow
- For each solar-proton radiation-design case, record its mission
exposure duration (years), the design confidence level (percent)
the case requires, and the energy thresholds the downstream
shielding/dose/SEE-rate calculation needs.
- Build the reference 1-year, 50%-confidence annual integral fluence
spectrum across the model's supported energy thresholds.
- Compute the confidence-level scale factor for the case's design
confidence level; verify the requested level falls within the
model's supported range before scaling.
- Compute the mission-duration scale factor for the case's exposure
duration.
- Apply both scale factors to the reference spectrum to assemble the
case's design fluence-above-energy spectrum at each requested
threshold energy.
- Check that the assembled spectrum still decreases monotonically
with increasing energy threshold -- the expected shape of an
integral fluence spectrum -- flagging any deviation before the
result is used downstream.
- Mark the case compliant only when its design confidence level meets
the mission's worst-case threshold and its spectrum passes the
monotonicity check; roll every case's compliance into the
assessment record and do not close the radiation environment
specification while any case remains non-compliant.
Pitfalls
- Selecting a design confidence level below the mission's worst-case
threshold (e.g. using a trade-study confidence level for the actual
design case), understating the design fluence and the resulting
shielding, dose, or SEE-rate margin.
- Treating the ESP integral fluence-above-energy spectrum as a
continuous differential spectrum or as a peak (instantaneous) flux,
which produces the wrong input to a downstream shielding, total-dose,
or SEE-rate calculation expecting a different quantity.
- Reusing a design fluence computed for one mission duration on a
mission with a different exposure duration instead of recomputing
the duration scale factor, understating fluence for a longer mission
or over-designing for a shorter one.
- Querying the spectrum at an energy threshold the model does not
support instead of at one of its defined thresholds, or silently
substituting a nearby threshold's fluence without accounting for the
spectrum's shape between thresholds.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The confidence-level scaling, duration scaling, spectrum assembly,
monotonicity check, and worst-case compliance logic is exercised by
the gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_e1004_b6_esp.py against
scripts/e1004_b6_esp_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_e1004_b6_esp.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and
paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: e1004-b6-esp3description: "Use when generating the Annex B.6 Emission of Solar Protons (ESP) worst-case fluence spectra for a mission under ECSS-E-ST-10-04C: build the reference annual integral fluence spectrum, apply the confidence-level scale factor for the required design percentile, apply the mission-duration scale factor for the exposure period, assemble the resulting fluence-above-energy spectrum, and verify the selected confidence level meets the mission's worst-case design threshold. Trigger: ESP, emission of solar protons, solar proton fluence, solar particle event, worst-case fluence, confidence level, JPL model, Annex B.6, e-st-10-04, ecss, space environment, radiation environment."4license: Apache-2.05compliance: STANDARDS-REF6standards:7 - id: ecss8 reference-only: true9gated: false10domain: space-systems11pack: space-systems12compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/e1004-b6-esp15 domain: space-systems16 subdomain: ecss17 tags: [ecss, e-st-10-04c, esp, solar-proton, fluence, confidence-level, annex-b, radiation-environment]18 version: 0.1.019 author: Aero Agent Skills20---2122# ECSS Emission of Solar Protons (ESP) Fluence Spectra (space-systems/ecss/e1004-b6-esp)2324Use when the task is generating the Annex B.6 Emission of Solar Protons25(ESP) worst-case fluence spectra under ECSS-E-ST-10-04C, to obtain a26design integral fluence-above-energy spectrum for a solar-proton27radiation-design case.2829## Domain quick reference3031- The ESP model is probabilistic, not deterministic: instead of a32 single fixed event spectrum, it returns a design fluence keyed to two33 case parameters -- the mission's exposure duration and a design34 confidence level (the probability that the true mission fluence will35 not exceed the returned value).36- Longer exposure duration raises the design fluence: a longer mission37 has more opportunity to encounter a large solar-proton event, so its38 worst-case fluence grows with duration, though not in direct39 proportion to it.40- A higher confidence level raises the design fluence: bounding a41 larger fraction of the event-size probability distribution requires42 reaching further into the rare, large-event tail, so fluence grows43 as the confidence level approaches its upper limit.44- The model reports fluence at a fixed set of proton energy thresholds45 (an integral spectrum: fluence of protons at or above each threshold46 energy), not a continuous differential spectrum and not a peak47 (instantaneous) flux -- confusing the ESP integral design fluence48 with a peak flux figure understates or overstates dose/SEE-rate49 estimates depending on which quantity the downstream calculation50 actually needs.51- Most radiation-design guidance treats a confidence level below about52 90% as insufficient for a worst-case design fluence; lower confidence53 levels are appropriate only for trade studies or non-worst-case54 sensitivity analysis, not for the design case itself.55- This leaf scopes ESP fluence-spectrum generation and the worst-case56 confidence-level check only. Rolling the ESP result into the mission57 radiation environment specification alongside GCR (sibling e1004-gcr58 leaf) and trapped-radiation environments is the sibling59 e1004-rad-env-spec leaf (clause 9.3).6061## Workflow62631. For each solar-proton radiation-design case, record its mission64 exposure duration (years), the design confidence level (percent)65 the case requires, and the energy thresholds the downstream66 shielding/dose/SEE-rate calculation needs.672. Build the reference 1-year, 50%-confidence annual integral fluence68 spectrum across the model's supported energy thresholds.693. Compute the confidence-level scale factor for the case's design70 confidence level; verify the requested level falls within the71 model's supported range before scaling.724. Compute the mission-duration scale factor for the case's exposure73 duration.745. Apply both scale factors to the reference spectrum to assemble the75 case's design fluence-above-energy spectrum at each requested76 threshold energy.776. Check that the assembled spectrum still decreases monotonically78 with increasing energy threshold -- the expected shape of an79 integral fluence spectrum -- flagging any deviation before the80 result is used downstream.817. Mark the case compliant only when its design confidence level meets82 the mission's worst-case threshold and its spectrum passes the83 monotonicity check; roll every case's compliance into the84 assessment record and do not close the radiation environment85 specification while any case remains non-compliant.8687## Pitfalls8889- Selecting a design confidence level below the mission's worst-case90 threshold (e.g. using a trade-study confidence level for the actual91 design case), understating the design fluence and the resulting92 shielding, dose, or SEE-rate margin.93- Treating the ESP integral fluence-above-energy spectrum as a94 continuous differential spectrum or as a peak (instantaneous) flux,95 which produces the wrong input to a downstream shielding, total-dose,96 or SEE-rate calculation expecting a different quantity.97- Reusing a design fluence computed for one mission duration on a98 mission with a different exposure duration instead of recomputing99 the duration scale factor, understating fluence for a longer mission100 or over-designing for a shorter one.101- Querying the spectrum at an energy threshold the model does not102 support instead of at one of its defined thresholds, or silently103 substituting a nearby threshold's fluence without accounting for the104 spectrum's shape between thresholds.105106## Behavior contract (gate 3)107108The confidence-level scaling, duration scaling, spectrum assembly,109monotonicity check, and worst-case compliance logic is exercised by110the gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_e1004_b6_esp.py against111scripts/e1004_b6_esp_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:112python3 scripts/test_e1004_b6_esp.py113114## Compliance115116- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and117 paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.118- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.