ECSS Human Factors — Workstation Design (space-systems/ecss/e1011-workstations)
Use when the task is verifying that a crewed spacecraft workstation meets
the layout, viewing, reach, and ingress/egress requirements of
ECSS-E-ST-10-11C §4.7.6. Each workstation element (display, control, access
path) is categorized by its access-frequency zone and checked against the
dimensional limits for that zone.
Domain quick reference
- §4.7.6 requires that every display and control be categorized into an
access-frequency zone before its placement is assessed. A primary zone
element is accessed frequently during normal operations and must lie within
the preferred field of view and functional reach. A secondary zone
element is accessed occasionally and may extend to the acceptable field of
view and maximum reach. A tertiary zone element is for reference or
emergency use only and is expected to require crew repositioning to access.
- Viewing is assessed from the crew Eye Reference Point (ERP) — the
design eye position at the 95th-percentile seated or restraint eye height.
Both horizontal and vertical angles from the ERP to each display centre are
checked independently against the zone limits. Viewing distance is also
bounded: too short causes eye strain, too long degrades readability. Primary
zone limits are tighter than secondary zone limits to ensure critical
displays are readable without head rotation.
- Reach is assessed from the Shoulder Reference Point (SRP). Each zone
has a maximum reach radius: primary zone controls must lie within functional
reach (achievable without body lean), secondary zone controls within maximum
reach (allowing a lean but not repositioning). Tertiary zone elements carry
no fixed radius because repositioning is already expected and accepted for
that zone.
- Ingress/egress clearances (clear width and clear height of the access
path to the workstation) are checked against three access modes: normal
operational, maintenance, and emergency egress. Emergency egress has the
smallest minimum width to accommodate suited crew in a time-critical
scenario; normal operational has the tallest minimum height for unrestricted
upright passage.
Workflow
- Record the workstation identifier and the design-anthropometry Eye
Reference Point (ERP) and Shoulder Reference Point (SRP) positions.
- Categorize each display and control by access-frequency zone: primary,
secondary, or tertiary. Reject any element with an unrecognized zone label
before proceeding to placement assessment.
- For each display, compute the horizontal angle (deviation from the
straight-ahead sightline) and the vertical angle (deviation from
horizontal, negative = below) from the ERP to the display centre, and
measure the viewing distance from ERP to display surface. Compare each
value against the zone's viewing limits; record a finding for every
exceedance.
- For each control, compute the reach distance from the SRP to the control
actuation point. Compare it against the zone's maximum reach radius; record
a finding if the control exceeds its zone's limit. Tertiary zone controls
require no reach check — they are already accepted as needing repositioning.
- For each ingress/egress access path to the workstation, record the clear
width, clear height, and access mode (normal operational, maintenance, or
emergency egress). Compare width and height against the minimums for that
mode; record a finding for each shortfall.
- Aggregate display, reach, and access-path findings for the workstation; the
workstation design satisfies §4.7.6 only when all three finding lists are
empty.
Pitfalls
- Skipping the zone categorization step and applying primary zone limits
uniformly overstates non-compliance for secondary elements placed at the
wider secondary limits and may miss primary elements placed too far away.
- Using the 50th-percentile body dimensions instead of the anthropometric
design drivers: 5th-percentile female drives reach limits (smallest reach
must still reach the control), 95th-percentile male drives clearance limits
(largest body must still clear the passage).
- Checking only horizontal viewing angle and ignoring vertical angle — a
display located far below the ERP sightline can pass the horizontal check
but require excessive neck flexion, which §4.7.6 prevents via the vertical
limit.
- Applying the emergency-egress minimum width to all access-path checks — the
normal-operational minimum is wider and applies to all non-emergency checks.
Using the smaller emergency figure as a universal baseline allows
non-compliant designs to pass.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The zone-categorization, viewing-angle, reach-envelope, and access-path logic
is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:
scripts/test_e1011_workstations.py against scripts/e1011_workstations_logic.py
(stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_e1011_workstations.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase
per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: e1011-workstations3description: "Use when assess workstation layout and human-factors design for a crewed spacecraft under ECSS-E-ST-10-11C §4.7.6: verify display placement within acceptable viewing angles from the crew Eye Reference Point, verify controls fall within the reach envelope for their access-frequency zone (primary, secondary, or tertiary), and verify ingress/egress clearance dimensions meet minimum crew-access requirements. Categorize each workstation element by access-frequency zone, flag any element outside its zone's viewing or reach limits, and confirm every access path meets clearance minimums. Trigger: ecss, e-st-10-system-scope, e-st-10-11c, workstation, human-factors, viewing-angle, reach-envelope, ingress-egress, layout."4license: Apache-2.05compliance: STANDARDS-REF6standards:7 - id: ecss8 reference-only: true9gated: false10domain: space-systems11pack: space-systems12compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/e1011-workstations15 domain: space-systems16 subdomain: ecss17 tags: [ecss, e-st-10-system-scope, e-st-10-11c, workstation, human-factors, viewing-angle, reach-envelope, ingress-egress, layout]18 version: 0.1.019 author: Aero Agent Skills20---2122# ECSS Human Factors — Workstation Design (space-systems/ecss/e1011-workstations)2324Use when the task is verifying that a crewed spacecraft workstation meets25the layout, viewing, reach, and ingress/egress requirements of26ECSS-E-ST-10-11C §4.7.6. Each workstation element (display, control, access27path) is categorized by its access-frequency zone and checked against the28dimensional limits for that zone.2930## Domain quick reference3132- §4.7.6 requires that every display and control be categorized into an33 access-frequency zone before its placement is assessed. A **primary zone**34 element is accessed frequently during normal operations and must lie within35 the preferred field of view and functional reach. A **secondary zone**36 element is accessed occasionally and may extend to the acceptable field of37 view and maximum reach. A **tertiary zone** element is for reference or38 emergency use only and is expected to require crew repositioning to access.39- **Viewing** is assessed from the crew Eye Reference Point (ERP) — the40 design eye position at the 95th-percentile seated or restraint eye height.41 Both horizontal and vertical angles from the ERP to each display centre are42 checked independently against the zone limits. Viewing distance is also43 bounded: too short causes eye strain, too long degrades readability. Primary44 zone limits are tighter than secondary zone limits to ensure critical45 displays are readable without head rotation.46- **Reach** is assessed from the Shoulder Reference Point (SRP). Each zone47 has a maximum reach radius: primary zone controls must lie within functional48 reach (achievable without body lean), secondary zone controls within maximum49 reach (allowing a lean but not repositioning). Tertiary zone elements carry50 no fixed radius because repositioning is already expected and accepted for51 that zone.52- **Ingress/egress** clearances (clear width and clear height of the access53 path to the workstation) are checked against three access modes: normal54 operational, maintenance, and emergency egress. Emergency egress has the55 smallest minimum width to accommodate suited crew in a time-critical56 scenario; normal operational has the tallest minimum height for unrestricted57 upright passage.5859## Workflow60611. Record the workstation identifier and the design-anthropometry Eye62 Reference Point (ERP) and Shoulder Reference Point (SRP) positions.632. Categorize each display and control by access-frequency zone: primary,64 secondary, or tertiary. Reject any element with an unrecognized zone label65 before proceeding to placement assessment.663. For each display, compute the horizontal angle (deviation from the67 straight-ahead sightline) and the vertical angle (deviation from68 horizontal, negative = below) from the ERP to the display centre, and69 measure the viewing distance from ERP to display surface. Compare each70 value against the zone's viewing limits; record a finding for every71 exceedance.724. For each control, compute the reach distance from the SRP to the control73 actuation point. Compare it against the zone's maximum reach radius; record74 a finding if the control exceeds its zone's limit. Tertiary zone controls75 require no reach check — they are already accepted as needing repositioning.765. For each ingress/egress access path to the workstation, record the clear77 width, clear height, and access mode (normal operational, maintenance, or78 emergency egress). Compare width and height against the minimums for that79 mode; record a finding for each shortfall.806. Aggregate display, reach, and access-path findings for the workstation; the81 workstation design satisfies §4.7.6 only when all three finding lists are82 empty.8384## Pitfalls8586- Skipping the zone categorization step and applying primary zone limits87 uniformly overstates non-compliance for secondary elements placed at the88 wider secondary limits and may miss primary elements placed too far away.89- Using the 50th-percentile body dimensions instead of the anthropometric90 design drivers: 5th-percentile female drives reach limits (smallest reach91 must still reach the control), 95th-percentile male drives clearance limits92 (largest body must still clear the passage).93- Checking only horizontal viewing angle and ignoring vertical angle — a94 display located far below the ERP sightline can pass the horizontal check95 but require excessive neck flexion, which §4.7.6 prevents via the vertical96 limit.97- Applying the emergency-egress minimum width to all access-path checks — the98 normal-operational minimum is wider and applies to all non-emergency checks.99 Using the smaller emergency figure as a universal baseline allows100 non-compliant designs to pass.101102## Behavior contract (gate 3)103104The zone-categorization, viewing-angle, reach-envelope, and access-path logic105is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:106scripts/test_e1011_workstations.py against scripts/e1011_workstations_logic.py107(stdlib unittest, offline). Run:108python3 scripts/test_e1011_workstations.py109110## Compliance111112- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase113 per standards-map.yaml.114- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.