ECSS Solar Cell Assemblies — Flatness Acceptance Criteria (space-systems/ecss/e2008-sca-flatness-criteria)
Use when the task is to disposition a measured cell assembly deflection under ECSS-E-ST-20-08C clause 6.4.3.17.3 — establishing the limiting value the geometry of the assembly defines, deciding which limit actually governs, and sentencing the samples and the lot against it.
Domain quick reference
- The limit is a function of the part, not a single number for the line. The same radius of curvature spends more standoff over a longer span, so a long assembly is allowed more deflection than a short one.
- A span term alone is not enough at either end. Below some standoff nothing is being measured except the tooling, so the limit needs a floor; and no assembly is allowed an unbounded standoff however long it is, because the panel stack height and the bond line run out, so the limit needs a ceiling.
- Which of the three terms binds is part of the answer. A limit held up by the floor and a limit set by the span behave differently when the geometry changes, and a reviewer needs to know which one is in force.
- A control drawing outranks the derived envelope. Where the drawing states a limit for the part, that limit governs and the derived value becomes a cross check rather than a competing answer.
- A drawing limit above the derived envelope is a decision, not an error. It is reported so somebody owns it, and it is never silently tightened back to the derived number.
- A measurement arrives with an uncertainty, so there are three outcomes and not two. A deflection whose whole guard band stays inside the limit is clear; one that is inside only if the instrument is believed exactly is marginal; one already over the limit is rejected.
- The boundary belongs to the passing side. A deflection landing exactly on its limit, or a guard band reaching exactly to it, is accepted; the comparison tolerance absorbs representation error rather than moving the limit.
- A subgroup is a sampling device. Too few samples read leaves the record unable to speak for the lot whatever it measured, which is a different outcome from a subgroup that was read and found wanting.
Workflow
- Validate the declared policy first: the span slope, the floor, the ceiling and the subgroup sample floor. A ceiling below the floor is refused rather than reordered, and an unrecognised key is refused rather than ignored.
- Validate the assembly geometry: a positive length and width in millimetres.
- Take the diagonal as the characteristic span, apply the slope, then hold the result between the floor and the ceiling and record which term bound it.
- Resolve the governing limit: a drawing-stated value if there is one, otherwise the derived envelope. Raise a finding when the drawing-stated value sits above the derived envelope, and none when it sits on or below it.
- Sentence each sample against the governing limit in order — rejected when the bare deflection is already over, accepted when the whole guard band stays at or under, marginal otherwise — and report the margin with it.
- Sentence the lot: undersized outranks rejected, rejected outranks referred, and accepted is what is left.
- Close with the governing limit, its provenance, the binding term, the worst guard-banded sample and every finding attached.
Pitfalls
- Applying one flatness number to every assembly on the line. A short part and a long part do not carry the same allowance, and a single number is either unbuildable at one end or meaningless at the other.
- Deriving the limit from the span with no floor. A small assembly then gets a limit finer than the measurement itself, and the record reports the fixture.
- Deriving the limit from the span with no ceiling. A long assembly is then allowed a standoff the bond line and the stack height envelope cannot take.
- Letting the derived envelope override a control drawing. The drawing governs; the derived number is the cross check that makes a permissive drawing limit visible instead of invisible.
- Quietly tightening a drawing limit back to the derived envelope. That is a change to the acceptance criteria made by the reviewer rather than by the authority that owns the drawing.
- Sentencing on the bare deflection and dropping the uncertainty. A part that passes only if the instrument is believed exactly is a different disposition from one that passes whatever the instrument did.
- Treating a deflection landing exactly on the limit as a failure. The boundary belongs to the passing side and the tolerance belongs inside the comparison.
- Accepting a lot on a couple of samples. The sampling floor is its own condition and it outranks a good result.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The policy and geometry validation, the characteristic span, the derived limit with its binding term, the governing-limit resolution and its provenance finding, the three-way sample disposition and the lot verdict are exercised by the gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_e2008_sca_flatness_criteria.py against scripts/e2008_sca_flatness_criteria_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run: python3 scripts/test_e2008_sca_flatness_criteria.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
