ECSS Structures — Fracture-Critical Item (FCI) Determination (space-systems/ecss/fci-classification)
Use when the task is to determine whether individual structural items on a space hardware assembly are fracture-critical items (FCIs) under ECSS-E-ST-32-01C §6.2.2, and to assign each item to its applicable FCI category so that the correct fracture-control obligations follow.
Domain quick reference
- ECSS-E-ST-32-01C §6.2.2 defines an FCI as any structural item whose fracture or separation could directly cause a catastrophic or critical failure consequence. Four distinct criteria trigger FCI status; an item satisfying any one of them is an FCI.
- Pressurized system criterion: a pressure vessel, pressurized line, or pressurized fitting whose burst or leak leads to a catastrophic or critical consequence. The pressure boundary itself is the item under evaluation, not the surrounding structure.
- Fracture-limited life item (FLLI) criterion: an item whose service life is bounded by the crack-growth life rather than conventional fatigue life, and whose fracture leads to a catastrophic or critical consequence. FLLI items require an explicit fracture-mechanics life calculation; a stress-life or strain-life analysis alone does not satisfy the FLLI obligation.
- NDT-limited criterion: an item that cannot be effectively inspected by conventional non-destructive testing methods (geometry, material, or access prevents reliable flaw detection), and whose fracture leads to a catastrophic or critical consequence. Because flaws cannot be bounded by inspection, an assumed initial flaw per §6.3.2 is mandatory.
- Composite primary-structure criterion: a load-carrying composite item in the primary structural load path whose fracture leads to a catastrophic or critical consequence. Secondary composite structures (fairings, covers, non-load-path panels) do not meet this criterion unless they independently satisfy another criterion.
- Failure consequence categories:
- catastrophic — loss of crew, vehicle, or range-safety impact.
- critical — loss of mission or major mission system.
- non-critical — tolerable degradation; no FCI criteria are triggered for non-critical items even when other properties apply.
- An item may satisfy multiple criteria simultaneously; all applicable categories are recorded and each imposes its own fracture-control obligations.
Workflow
- Inventory every structural item at the assembly level and record: item identifier, item type (pressure vessel, pressurized line, pressurized fitting, composite primary, composite secondary, metallic primary, metallic secondary, weld, fastener, other), failure consequence (catastrophic / critical / non-critical), NDT accessibility (can conventional NDT bound flaw size?), and whether the design life is controlled by crack growth (FLLI flag).
- Apply the pressurized-system criterion: for each item typed as a pressure vessel, pressurized line, or pressurized fitting, check whether the failure consequence is catastrophic or critical. If yes, assign category PRESSURE_VESSEL_OR_LINE.
- Apply the FLLI criterion: for each item with the life-limited-by-fracture flag set, check whether the consequence is catastrophic or critical. If yes, assign category FLLI and require a crack-growth life analysis per §6.4.
- Apply the NDT-limited criterion: for each item where conventional NDT cannot reliably bound the flaw size, check whether the consequence is catastrophic or critical. If yes, assign category NDT_LIMITED and require an assumed initial flaw per §6.3.2.
- Apply the composite primary-structure criterion: for each item typed as composite_primary, check whether the consequence is catastrophic or critical. If yes, assign category COMPOSITE_PRIMARY.
- Collect all assigned categories per item. An item with at least one category is an FCI; an item with no categories is not fracture-critical at this consequence level.
- For each FCI, record the determination rationale referencing which criterion was met and the consequence level so that the fracture-control plan can be traced to the input data.
Pitfalls
- Applying fracture-control obligations to non-critical items because they are pressurized or NDT-limited — consequence level is a gate condition; a non-critical item does not become an FCI regardless of its other properties.
- Treating composite secondary structures (non-load-path panels, covers) as meeting the composite primary-structure criterion — only items in the primary structural load path satisfy that criterion; secondary composite items must independently meet another criterion to be FCIs.
- Omitting the FLLI flag because a fatigue analysis already exists — a fatigue analysis does not bound crack growth; an item is an FLLI whenever fracture mechanics controls its life, even if a fatigue analysis is also present.
- Assuming NDT accessibility without verification — if inspection access or material properties have not been confirmed to allow reliable flaw-size bounding, the item must be treated as NDT-limited.
- Recording only the first triggered criterion and stopping — all applicable criteria must be checked because each may impose distinct fracture-control obligations.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The pressurized-system, FLLI, NDT-limited, and composite primary-structure criterion logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_fci_classification.py against scripts/fci_classification_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run: python3 scripts/test_fci_classification.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
