ECSS Structures — Initial Flaw Size Assumption (space-systems/ecss/initial-flaw-size-assumption)
Use when the task is to determine the initial crack size and shape to be
assumed in a fracture mechanics life or residual-strength calculation,
following ECSS-E-ST-32C clause 7.2.6. The assumed flaw dimensions are
taken from the detection limits of the NDT method applied to the part,
or from the standard uninspected-part default when no inspection is
performed.
Domain quick reference
- Clause 7.2.6 ties the initial flaw assumption to the NDT programme:
the assumed crack cannot be smaller than the largest flaw the NDT method
might miss at the required confidence level (typically 95 % probability
of detection at 90 % confidence). Where no inspection is performed, a
standard default flaw governs — a conservative size representative of a
flaw that could plausibly escape all manufacturing controls.
- Flaw shape depends on component geometry and loading direction. Surface
cracks at a free surface are represented as semi-elliptical (depth a,
half-surface-length c). Edge and fastener-hole cracks are represented as
quarter-circle corner cracks (radius r = a = c). Through-thickness flaws
in thin sections are represented as through-cracks (half-length b). The
shape selection must be documented and justified.
- Aspect ratio a/c defines the flaw eccentricity. A ratio of 1.0 gives a
semi-circular surface crack (a = c); ratios below 1.0 give a wider,
shallower crack. NDT capability limits typically define both a and c
independently; their ratio is an output, not an input.
- Figures 7-1 through 7-3 of ECSS-E-ST-32C §7.2.6 map NDT method to
minimum detectable flaw size as a function of material thickness and
inspection frequency. This leaf encodes those relationships as a
capability table indexed by method name, used for flaw selection.
Workflow
- Confirm whether the part is subject to an NDT inspection. If no
inspection is specified, apply the uninspected-part default flaw size
(standard a = 1.27 mm, c = 1.905 mm surface semi-elliptical). Record
"UNINSPECTED" as the governing method.
- For each applicable NDT method, retrieve the minimum detectable flaw
dimensions (depth a_min, half-length c_min) from the NDT capability
table. Reject any method not in the approved table with an explicit
error — do not guess or interpolate.
- When more than one method is applied to the same region, select the
most detection-capable method (smallest a_min) as the governing method.
Document the selection and the methods that were superseded.
- Assign the flaw shape based on the component geometry: surface geometry
maps to a surface semi-elliptical crack; edge or fastener-hole geometry
maps to a corner quarter-circle crack; thin sections where the flaw
spans the full thickness map to a through-crack. Reject unrecognized
geometry designations.
- Compute the aspect ratio a/c from the selected flaw dimensions. For
corner cracks (a = c = r), the aspect ratio is 1.0 by definition. For
through-cracks, the aspect ratio is not applicable.
- Verify that the assumed flaw depth a is less than the component's
material-specific critical flaw size a_c for the design stress level.
Flag the assumption as non-compliant if a >= a_c; this means the part
may already be critical at initial flaw size and requires redesign or
tighter inspection.
- Record the result — method, flaw dimensions, shape, aspect ratio, and
compliance verdict — as the initial flaw assumption entry in the
fracture control analysis.
Pitfalls
- Using the same NDT method's flaw size for a geometry it cannot inspect:
a volumetric method (RT, UT) does not characterise surface-crack depth
and half-length the same way a surface method (PT, MT, ET) does.
Assign the correct shape for the method; a through-crack from RT is not
interchangeable with a surface semi-elliptical from PT.
- Assuming aspect ratio a/c = 1.0 for all surface cracks: the NDT
capability table defines a and c independently; forcing a circular shape
when c > a understates the stress-intensity factor at the deepest point
and can be unconservative for shallow wide cracks.
- Treating a missing NDT record as equivalent to "uninspected default":
the uninspected default is a deliberate assumption, not a fallback for
administrative gaps. A missing inspection record is a non-conformance
and must be resolved before applying the default.
- Applying the NDT minimum flaw size without accounting for material
thickness: some NDT methods lose sensitivity in thin sections; the
governing flaw size may be larger than the table value when thickness
falls below the method's reliable range.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The NDT capability lookup, flaw shape selection, aspect ratio computation,
multi-method ranking, and compliance check logic are exercised by the
gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_initial_flaw_size_assumption.py against
scripts/initial_flaw_size_assumption_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_initial_flaw_size_assumption.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and
paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: initial-flaw-size-assumption3description: "Use when determine initial crack size and shape assumptions for fracture4 mechanics analysis under ECSS-E-ST-32C clause 7.2.6: select the governing NDT5 method from the applicable inspection programme, look up the corresponding minimum6 detectable flaw dimensions (depth and half-surface-length) from the NDT capability7 reference, assign the correct flaw shape (surface semi-elliptical, corner quarter-circle,8 or through-thickness) based on component geometry, confirm the assumed flaw is9 below the material critical flaw size for the applied stress, and record the10 assumption with its NDT-method anchor for the fracture control report.11 Trigger: ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, fracture-control, initial-flaw-size,12 ndt-capability, crack-shape, fracture-mechanics, semi-elliptical-crack."13license: Apache-2.014compliance: STANDARDS-REF15standards:16 - id: ecss17 reference-only: true18gated: false19domain: space-systems20pack: space-systems21compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"22metadata:23 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/initial-flaw-size-assumption24 domain: space-systems25 subdomain: ecss26 tags: [ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, fracture-control, initial-flaw-size, ndt-capability, crack-shape, fracture-mechanics, semi-elliptical-crack]27 version: 0.1.028 author: Aero Agent Skills29---3031# ECSS Structures — Initial Flaw Size Assumption (space-systems/ecss/initial-flaw-size-assumption)3233Use when the task is to determine the initial crack size and shape to be34assumed in a fracture mechanics life or residual-strength calculation,35following ECSS-E-ST-32C clause 7.2.6. The assumed flaw dimensions are36taken from the detection limits of the NDT method applied to the part,37or from the standard uninspected-part default when no inspection is38performed.3940## Domain quick reference4142- Clause 7.2.6 ties the initial flaw assumption to the NDT programme:43 the assumed crack cannot be smaller than the largest flaw the NDT method44 might miss at the required confidence level (typically 95 % probability45 of detection at 90 % confidence). Where no inspection is performed, a46 standard default flaw governs — a conservative size representative of a47 flaw that could plausibly escape all manufacturing controls.48- Flaw shape depends on component geometry and loading direction. Surface49 cracks at a free surface are represented as semi-elliptical (depth a,50 half-surface-length c). Edge and fastener-hole cracks are represented as51 quarter-circle corner cracks (radius r = a = c). Through-thickness flaws52 in thin sections are represented as through-cracks (half-length b). The53 shape selection must be documented and justified.54- Aspect ratio a/c defines the flaw eccentricity. A ratio of 1.0 gives a55 semi-circular surface crack (a = c); ratios below 1.0 give a wider,56 shallower crack. NDT capability limits typically define both a and c57 independently; their ratio is an output, not an input.58- Figures 7-1 through 7-3 of ECSS-E-ST-32C §7.2.6 map NDT method to59 minimum detectable flaw size as a function of material thickness and60 inspection frequency. This leaf encodes those relationships as a61 capability table indexed by method name, used for flaw selection.6263## Workflow64651. Confirm whether the part is subject to an NDT inspection. If no66 inspection is specified, apply the uninspected-part default flaw size67 (standard a = 1.27 mm, c = 1.905 mm surface semi-elliptical). Record68 "UNINSPECTED" as the governing method.692. For each applicable NDT method, retrieve the minimum detectable flaw70 dimensions (depth a_min, half-length c_min) from the NDT capability71 table. Reject any method not in the approved table with an explicit72 error — do not guess or interpolate.733. When more than one method is applied to the same region, select the74 most detection-capable method (smallest a_min) as the governing method.75 Document the selection and the methods that were superseded.764. Assign the flaw shape based on the component geometry: surface geometry77 maps to a surface semi-elliptical crack; edge or fastener-hole geometry78 maps to a corner quarter-circle crack; thin sections where the flaw79 spans the full thickness map to a through-crack. Reject unrecognized80 geometry designations.815. Compute the aspect ratio a/c from the selected flaw dimensions. For82 corner cracks (a = c = r), the aspect ratio is 1.0 by definition. For83 through-cracks, the aspect ratio is not applicable.846. Verify that the assumed flaw depth a is less than the component's85 material-specific critical flaw size a_c for the design stress level.86 Flag the assumption as non-compliant if a >= a_c; this means the part87 may already be critical at initial flaw size and requires redesign or88 tighter inspection.897. Record the result — method, flaw dimensions, shape, aspect ratio, and90 compliance verdict — as the initial flaw assumption entry in the91 fracture control analysis.9293## Pitfalls9495- Using the same NDT method's flaw size for a geometry it cannot inspect:96 a volumetric method (RT, UT) does not characterise surface-crack depth97 and half-length the same way a surface method (PT, MT, ET) does.98 Assign the correct shape for the method; a through-crack from RT is not99 interchangeable with a surface semi-elliptical from PT.100- Assuming aspect ratio a/c = 1.0 for all surface cracks: the NDT101 capability table defines a and c independently; forcing a circular shape102 when c > a understates the stress-intensity factor at the deepest point103 and can be unconservative for shallow wide cracks.104- Treating a missing NDT record as equivalent to "uninspected default":105 the uninspected default is a deliberate assumption, not a fallback for106 administrative gaps. A missing inspection record is a non-conformance107 and must be resolved before applying the default.108- Applying the NDT minimum flaw size without accounting for material109 thickness: some NDT methods lose sensitivity in thin sections; the110 governing flaw size may be larger than the table value when thickness111 falls below the method's reliable range.112113## Behavior contract (gate 3)114115The NDT capability lookup, flaw shape selection, aspect ratio computation,116multi-method ranking, and compliance check logic are exercised by the117gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_initial_flaw_size_assumption.py against118scripts/initial_flaw_size_assumption_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:119python3 scripts/test_initial_flaw_size_assumption.py120121## Compliance122123- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and124 paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.125- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.