ECSS Structures — Low-Risk Fracture Item Compliance (space-systems/ecss/low-risk-fracture-compliance)
Use when the task is to determine whether a metal structural item qualifies for the
low-risk fracture compliance path under ECSS E-ST-32C clause 6.3.5 — verifying either
the load-limited stress criterion or the non-fracture-critical consequence criterion,
and establishing which path forms the compliance basis.
Domain quick reference
- Clause 6.3.5 defines two routes by which an item avoids full fracture control
analysis: the load-limited criterion (maximum gross-section stress at limit load
is at most 60 % of material yield strength, making crack growth a non-credible
driver) and the non-fracture-critical criterion (even total fracture would carry
only contained or non-critical consequences).
- An item is categorized as load-limited when its stress ratio
(max stress / yield strength) is ≤ 0.60. This threshold excludes items where
fatigue or stress corrosion cracking could drive life-limiting crack growth.
- An item is categorized as non-fracture-critical when its failure consequence
falls into an accepted group: contained failure, redundant load path,
non-structural function, cosmetic role, or mission-non-critical function.
- A fracture-critical consequence (loss of crew safety, loss of mission, primary
structure in a single-load-path, pressure vessel failure, life support failure)
is an absolute disqualifier: the item must follow the full fracture control
procedure regardless of stress level.
- Once low-risk qualification is established on either path, no damage-tolerance
analysis, no crack growth calculation, and no NDE fracture screening are required.
The compliance record documents the qualifying path and the supporting data.
Workflow
- Collect the item data: name, material yield strength, maximum gross-section stress
at limit load (for load-limited assessment) and/or the identified failure consequence
category (for the non-fracture-critical assessment).
- If a failure consequence is provided, evaluate it first. If the consequence is
fracture-critical, stop — the item is disqualified from the low-risk path and
the full fracture control procedure applies.
- If stress data are available, compute the stress ratio (max stress / yield strength)
and compare against the threshold (default 0.60). A ratio ≤ threshold means the
load-limited criterion is met.
- Determine the compliance path: load-limited if the stress criterion passes;
non-fracture-critical if the consequence criterion passes and the stress criterion
does not (or stress data are absent). If neither criterion passes, the item does
not qualify as low-risk.
- Document the qualifying path, supporting values (stress ratio and yield strength
for load-limited; consequence category for non-fracture-critical), and any
findings (threshold exceedance, missing data).
- For a set of items, aggregate the results and flag the assessment as fully compliant
only when every item qualifies on a documented path with no errors.
Pitfalls
- Applying a gross-section stress limit without verifying it is the maximum stress at
limit load — local stress concentrations are not the check here, but the limit-load
gross-section value must be the worst-case envelope, not a nominal service value.
- Treating an unrecognized failure consequence as acceptable by default — the procedure
raises an error on unrecognized categories rather than defaulting to non-fracture-critical,
because an undocumented consequence is a missing analysis, not a pass.
- Allowing a partial data set (stress data only, no consequence) to mask a fracture-critical
item — the workflow evaluates consequence first and short-circuits to disqualification;
if consequence data are missing and stress data alone are provided, the only available
path is load-limited.
- Confusing low-risk qualification with full fracture control programme compliance —
this procedure establishes that a specific item is exempt from fracture mechanics
analysis, not that the overall fracture control programme is complete.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The load-limited criterion, non-fracture-critical consequence check, item qualification,
and multi-item compliance assessment are exercised by the gate 3 contract test:
scripts/test_low_risk_fracture_compliance.py against
scripts/low_risk_fracture_compliance_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_low_risk_fracture_compliance.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase per
standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: low-risk-fracture-compliance3description: "Use when determine low-risk fracture compliance for a metal structural item under ECSS E-ST-32C clause 6.3.5: check whether the item satisfies the load-limited criterion (maximum gross-section stress at limit load ≤ 60 % of material yield strength) or the non-fracture-critical criterion (item failure results only in contained or non-critical consequences), establish the qualifying compliance path, and confirm no full fracture mechanics analysis is needed. Items whose failure consequence is fracture-critical, or whose gross-section stress exceeds the load-limited threshold, are excluded from the low-risk path and must follow the full fracture control procedure. Trigger: ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, fracture-control, low-risk-fracture, load-limited, non-fracture-critical, structural-metals, compliance-path, damage-tolerance."4license: Apache-2.05compliance: STANDARDS-REF6standards:7 - id: ecss8 reference-only: true9gated: false10domain: space-systems11pack: space-systems12compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/low-risk-fracture-compliance15 domain: space-systems16 subdomain: ecss17 tags: [ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, fracture-control, low-risk-fracture, load-limited, non-fracture-critical, structural-metals, compliance-path]18 version: 0.1.019 author: Aero Agent Skills20---2122# ECSS Structures — Low-Risk Fracture Item Compliance (space-systems/ecss/low-risk-fracture-compliance)2324Use when the task is to determine whether a metal structural item qualifies for the25low-risk fracture compliance path under ECSS E-ST-32C clause 6.3.5 — verifying either26the load-limited stress criterion or the non-fracture-critical consequence criterion,27and establishing which path forms the compliance basis.2829## Domain quick reference3031- Clause 6.3.5 defines two routes by which an item avoids full fracture control32 analysis: the load-limited criterion (maximum gross-section stress at limit load33 is at most 60 % of material yield strength, making crack growth a non-credible34 driver) and the non-fracture-critical criterion (even total fracture would carry35 only contained or non-critical consequences).36- An item is categorized as load-limited when its stress ratio37 (max stress / yield strength) is ≤ 0.60. This threshold excludes items where38 fatigue or stress corrosion cracking could drive life-limiting crack growth.39- An item is categorized as non-fracture-critical when its failure consequence40 falls into an accepted group: contained failure, redundant load path,41 non-structural function, cosmetic role, or mission-non-critical function.42- A fracture-critical consequence (loss of crew safety, loss of mission, primary43 structure in a single-load-path, pressure vessel failure, life support failure)44 is an absolute disqualifier: the item must follow the full fracture control45 procedure regardless of stress level.46- Once low-risk qualification is established on either path, no damage-tolerance47 analysis, no crack growth calculation, and no NDE fracture screening are required.48 The compliance record documents the qualifying path and the supporting data.4950## Workflow51521. Collect the item data: name, material yield strength, maximum gross-section stress53 at limit load (for load-limited assessment) and/or the identified failure consequence54 category (for the non-fracture-critical assessment).552. If a failure consequence is provided, evaluate it first. If the consequence is56 fracture-critical, stop — the item is disqualified from the low-risk path and57 the full fracture control procedure applies.583. If stress data are available, compute the stress ratio (max stress / yield strength)59 and compare against the threshold (default 0.60). A ratio ≤ threshold means the60 load-limited criterion is met.614. Determine the compliance path: load-limited if the stress criterion passes;62 non-fracture-critical if the consequence criterion passes and the stress criterion63 does not (or stress data are absent). If neither criterion passes, the item does64 not qualify as low-risk.655. Document the qualifying path, supporting values (stress ratio and yield strength66 for load-limited; consequence category for non-fracture-critical), and any67 findings (threshold exceedance, missing data).686. For a set of items, aggregate the results and flag the assessment as fully compliant69 only when every item qualifies on a documented path with no errors.7071## Pitfalls7273- Applying a gross-section stress limit without verifying it is the maximum stress at74 limit load — local stress concentrations are not the check here, but the limit-load75 gross-section value must be the worst-case envelope, not a nominal service value.76- Treating an unrecognized failure consequence as acceptable by default — the procedure77 raises an error on unrecognized categories rather than defaulting to non-fracture-critical,78 because an undocumented consequence is a missing analysis, not a pass.79- Allowing a partial data set (stress data only, no consequence) to mask a fracture-critical80 item — the workflow evaluates consequence first and short-circuits to disqualification;81 if consequence data are missing and stress data alone are provided, the only available82 path is load-limited.83- Confusing low-risk qualification with full fracture control programme compliance —84 this procedure establishes that a specific item is exempt from fracture mechanics85 analysis, not that the overall fracture control programme is complete.8687## Behavior contract (gate 3)8889The load-limited criterion, non-fracture-critical consequence check, item qualification,90and multi-item compliance assessment are exercised by the gate 3 contract test:91scripts/test_low_risk_fracture_compliance.py against92scripts/low_risk_fracture_compliance_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:9394 python3 scripts/test_low_risk_fracture_compliance.py9596## Compliance9798- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase per99 standards-map.yaml.100- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.