ECSS Structures — NDT/NDI Verification (space-systems/ecss/ndt-verification)
Use when the task is the NDT/NDI verification of structural elements under ECSS-E-ST-32C clause 4.6.3.13 — selecting applicable inspection methods, confirming coverage fractions meet criticality-based minimums, and evaluating each indication against its acceptance limit.
Domain quick reference
- Clause 4.6.3.13 requires that every structural element subject to NDT evidence be assessed against three criteria: method applicability, inspection coverage, and indication acceptance. All three must pass before the element is considered NDT-verified.
- Method applicability depends on the material family (metallic, composite, bond, weld) and the defect family targeted (surface, subsurface, volumetric, delamination). Not every method is effective for every combination — penetrant testing (PT) and magnetic particle testing (MT) address surface-only flaws; MT further requires a ferromagnetic material, so composites are excluded. Ultrasonic testing (UT) and radiographic testing (RT) reach subsurface and volumetric defects. Eddy current testing (ET) is applicable to conductive materials for surface and near-surface flaws. Visual testing (VT) is a baseline for all accessible surfaces.
- Inspection coverage is the fraction of the element's inspectable area that is actually examined. The minimum fraction is set by criticality: primary load-carrying structure requires 100%, secondary structure 50%, and tertiary structure 20%. A shortfall is a finding regardless of indication results.
- Indication acceptance compares the recorded size of each relevant indication against the method-specific acceptance limit. An indication below the limit is acceptable; one equal to the limit is marginal (does not pass); one above the limit is rejectable. Both marginal and rejectable indications block NDT acceptance.
Workflow
- For each structural element in the verification matrix that requires NDT evidence, record its material family, defect families targeted, criticality level, and the NDT method applied.
- Look up the applicable methods for each (material family, defect family) pair. Confirm the method actually used appears in the applicable set; if it does not, flag an inapplicable-method finding before proceeding.
- Retrieve the inspected coverage fraction and the criticality level. Check whether the fraction meets the criticality-based minimum. Record any shortfall as a coverage finding.
- For each NDT indication recorded during inspection, compare its size to the acceptance limit. Categorize the outcome as acceptable, marginal, or rejectable. Any non-acceptable indication becomes an indication finding.
- Aggregate all findings per element. The element achieves NDT verification only when the applicable-method check passes, coverage is adequate, and no indication findings remain.
- Document the method, coverage fraction, indication summary, and pass/fail verdict in the structural verification data package per the project data requirements.
Pitfalls
- Applying a method outside its applicable range (e.g., MT on a composite) and recording no indications as a passing result — the absence of indications from an inapplicable method carries no evidentiary weight.
- Treating a coverage fraction below the criticality minimum as acceptable because no rejectable indications were found in the inspected portion — the missed area is uninspected, not defect-free.
- Accepting a marginal indication on the grounds that it is "at" the limit — the acceptance criterion is strictly below the limit; equal-to is a finding.
- Omitting the defect family from the method-selection step and applying a surface-only method to a subsurface-sensitive joint — the target defect may be invisible to the chosen method even if the method is valid for other defect types in the same material.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The method-applicability, coverage-check, indication-evaluation, and full component-assessment logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_ndt_verification.py against scripts/ndt_verification_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_ndt_verification.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
