ECSS Nonconformance Control — Internal Review Board Sitting (space-systems/ecss/q1009-internal-meeting)
Use when the task is the internal review-board step of ECSS-Q-ST-10-09 clause 5.2.2.1 — convening the supplier's own nonconformance review board, deciding which raised nonconformances that board may actually hear, and turning what it decides into a record that survives audit.
Domain quick reference
- The board is a standing body with appointed functions, not whoever is free that afternoon. Quality chairs it because the departure is a quality event; design engineering has to be there because only the design authority can say what the item was meant to do; production has to be there because only the builder knows what the item actually is. A sitting missing any of those three has no basis for a disposition.
- Attendance and voting are two different questions. An advisory member — configuration management, supply chain, safety — counts as sitting and can close an absent-function gap in expertise, but does not count toward the quorum fraction of the appointed voting membership. The two shortfalls are therefore reported separately: a missing function is repaired by a delegate with the same authority, a missing quorum only by reconvening.
- An agenda item is only heard once its review package is complete. The package is the nonconformance report itself, the identification of the affected item, the effectivity list saying which units carry the departure, the description, the cause analysis, the consequence assessment and the proposed disposition. An item short of any of these is deferred, because a board that decides without them is recording a preference rather than a disposition.
- Deferral is a normal outcome of a valid sitting, not a defect in it. A properly constituted board that defers three of five items has held a valid sitting with an uncleared agenda, and those are separate verdicts with separate repairs.
- The record is the deliverable. Each item heard leaves with a disposition, the rationale that supports it, a named accountable owner and a due day. A disposition without a rationale cannot be reviewed later; a disposition without an owner and a due day never closes.
Workflow
- Validate the roster: one appointed member per board function, each marked present or absent and voting or advisory. A duplicated function or a non-boolean attendance flag is an input error.
- Test the sitting twice — the mandatory board functions actually sitting, and the attending share of the appointed voting membership against the quorum fraction — and report both verdicts. Absorb the representation error of an exactly-at-fraction attendance with a named tolerance rather than lowering the appointed fraction.
- Walk the agenda in order and test each item's review package against the required contents. Name the gaps; an item with gaps is inadmissible and is deferred.
- Match decision records to the items actually heard. A record is complete only when disposition, rationale, owner and due day are all populated; a blank string is a gap, a due day of zero is a value.
- Report the open minutes — items heard with no record, and records missing fields — plus any record attached to a deferred or unknown item, which is a record with nothing to attach to.
- Declare the sitting valid only when quorum holds and the minutes are complete, and report the cleared-agenda verdict alongside it.
Pitfalls
- Counting advisory attendees toward the quorum. They are there for expertise, not authority; folding them into the fraction lets a board with two voting members present declare a quorum of five.
- Reading a full attendance count as a valid sitting. Five members in the room with design engineering absent is a quorum without the design authority, which is exactly the sitting that produces a use-as-is that the design authority never agreed to.
- Hearing an item whose cause analysis is still open. The board then disposes of a departure whose cause it does not know, and the disposition has to be reopened when the cause arrives.
- Treating a deferral as a failed meeting. The repair for a deferral is the missing package item, not a reconvened board, so merging the two verdicts sends the wrong repair.
- Minuting the disposition alone. Without the rationale the decision cannot be reviewed, and without an owner and a due day nobody is accountable for carrying it out.
- Leaving a decision record attached to an item that was never heard. It reads as a closed item in every later count while the underlying nonconformance is still open.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The roster validation, the mandatory-function and quorum tests, the review-package admissibility check, the decision-record completeness check, the minutes reconciliation and the overall sitting verdict are exercised by the gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_q1009_internal_meeting.py against scripts/q1009_internal_meeting_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run: python3 scripts/test_q1009_internal_meeting.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
