ECSS Commercial EEE Components -- Class 2 Baseline Selection Rules (space-systems/ecss/q6013-class-2-selection-rules)
Use when the task is clause 5.2.2.1 of ECSS-Q-ST-60-13C at the
intermediate assurance class: putting a named candidate commercial part
through the baseline rules that steer whether it may be chosen at all.
The framing clause says what the selection owes; this is the rule set a
real part is measured against, and it is the step where the intermediate
class stops being the highest class with softer numbers.
Domain quick reference
- Seven baseline rules are applied: authentic provenance, a certified
manufacturer quality system, a controlled procurement route, flight lot
homogeneity, a rated temperature range enveloping the mission range
with its declared margin, a change-notification agreement, and a
declared radiation capability.
- One rule is a hard bar and the rest are carried. Provenance that
cannot be established bars the part, because every other rule is a
statement about a part whose identity is assumed. The remaining six
admit a declared mitigation, which is the mechanism the highest class
does not offer at all.
- A mitigation is recognised per rule, not in general. Lot-by-lot
acceptance testing carries a lot homogeneity failure and nothing else;
a construction audit carries a missing change-notification agreement
and nothing else. Attaching the wrong measure to a rule is not a
partial credit, it is an unmitigated failure.
- The uprating route carries a temperature shortfall only so far. Past
the declared kelvin cap the assessment is no longer an assessment of
the same part, and the shortfall is reported in kelvin so the reviewer
can see how far past the cap the design actually sits.
- Residual risk stacks. Each carried rule leaves a declared share
behind, and a part held up by four individually valid mitigations is
refused on the total even though no single mitigation was wrong. The
ceiling is what stops the class becoming a way to admit anything with
enough paperwork.
- A mitigation attached to a rule the part already meets is reported,
not counted. It costs the programme money and it hides which rules the
part actually failed.
Workflow
- Validate the candidate: every rule fact declared true or false, a
recognised procurement route, and a temperature case whose rated and
mission ranges are both real ranges.
- Compute the temperature shortfall in kelvin from the mission range
extended by its declared margin, summing the hot and cold ends.
- Evaluate the seven baseline rules and collect the failures.
- Validate each mitigation record, refusing one attached to the hard
bar and refusing two records on one rule.
- For every failed rule, accept the mitigation only when it is the
measure recognised for that rule and inside the limit the measure
carries; the uprating route is compared with the kelvin cap, treating
an exactly-met cap as met through a named tolerance.
- Sum the residual shares of the carried rules and compare the total
with the declared ceiling under the same tolerance.
- Report mitigations attached to rules the part already meets.
- Return ranked findings, the shortfall in kelvin, the residual risk
and one verdict: admissible, admissible with mitigation, or not
admissible.
Pitfalls
- Letting a mitigation carry the provenance rule. A part of unknown
origin is not a part with a gap in its paperwork, and every other rule
is silently conditioned on the identity that rule establishes.
- Accepting any declared mitigation for any failed rule. The measure is
recognised per rule; a generic quality argument attached to a lot
homogeneity failure changes nothing about the lots that will fly.
- Uprating past the cap because the shortfall is only a few kelvin over.
The cap is the point the measure stops being evidence, and the
shortfall is reported in kelvin precisely so that decision is visible
rather than buried in a pass.
- Judging each mitigation alone. Individually valid measures stack into
a part nobody would have chosen on its merits, which is what the
residual ceiling exists to catch.
- Reading margin as optional. A rated range that just touches the
mission range fails, and dropping the margin turns a real shortfall
into a clean pass.
- Treating an undeclared rule fact as a met rule. Unknown is not true;
the candidate is refused until the fact is declared.
- Leaving mitigations attached to rules the part passes. They inflate
the apparent effort and obscure the failures the reviewer came for.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The candidate validation, temperature shortfall, baseline rule
evaluation, mitigation validation, per-rule recognition, uprating cap,
residual risk summation, ceiling comparison, unused mitigation report
and admissibility verdict are exercised by the gate 3 contract test:
scripts/test_q6013_class_2_selection_rules.py against
scripts/q6013_class_2_selection_rules_logic.py (stdlib unittest,
offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_q6013_class_2_selection_rules.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and
paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: q6013-class-2-selection-rules3description: "Use when a real part meets the rule set. Determine whether a candidate commercial EEE part may enter a design at the intermediate assurance class under ECSS-Q-ST-60-13C clause 5.2.2.1: run the baseline rules for provenance, manufacturer quality system, procurement route, flight lot homogeneity, temperature envelope with margin, change notification and declared radiation capability; bar the part outright on provenance; carry any other failure only on the measure recognised for that rule, an uprating assessment holding to a kelvin cap; then refuse a part whose stacked residual risk passes the ceiling. Returns the shortfall in kelvin and one verdict. Trigger: ecss, q-st-60-13c-clause-5-2-2-1, class-two-commercial-part-admissibility, baseline-rule-mitigation-measure, part-uprating-assessment-kelvin-cap, open-market-procurement-mitigation, class-two-stacked-residual-risk-ceiling, authentic-provenance-hard-bar."4license: Apache-2.05compliance: STANDARDS-REF6standards:7 - id: ecss8 reference-only: true9gated: false10domain: space-systems11pack: space-systems12compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/q6013-class-2-selection-rules15 domain: space-systems16 subdomain: ecss17 tags: [ecss, q-st-60-13-commercial-eee-component-scope, q6013-class-2-selection-rules, class-two-commercial-part-admissibility, baseline-rule-mitigation-measure, part-uprating-assessment-kelvin-cap, open-market-procurement-mitigation, class-two-stacked-residual-risk-ceiling, authentic-provenance-hard-bar]18 version: 0.1.019 author: Aero Agent Skills20---2122# ECSS Commercial EEE Components -- Class 2 Baseline Selection Rules (space-systems/ecss/q6013-class-2-selection-rules)2324Use when the task is clause 5.2.2.1 of ECSS-Q-ST-60-13C at the25intermediate assurance class: putting a named candidate commercial part26through the baseline rules that steer whether it may be chosen at all.27The framing clause says what the selection owes; this is the rule set a28real part is measured against, and it is the step where the intermediate29class stops being the highest class with softer numbers.3031## Domain quick reference3233- Seven baseline rules are applied: authentic provenance, a certified34 manufacturer quality system, a controlled procurement route, flight lot35 homogeneity, a rated temperature range enveloping the mission range36 with its declared margin, a change-notification agreement, and a37 declared radiation capability.38- One rule is a hard bar and the rest are carried. Provenance that39 cannot be established bars the part, because every other rule is a40 statement about a part whose identity is assumed. The remaining six41 admit a declared mitigation, which is the mechanism the highest class42 does not offer at all.43- A mitigation is recognised per rule, not in general. Lot-by-lot44 acceptance testing carries a lot homogeneity failure and nothing else;45 a construction audit carries a missing change-notification agreement46 and nothing else. Attaching the wrong measure to a rule is not a47 partial credit, it is an unmitigated failure.48- The uprating route carries a temperature shortfall only so far. Past49 the declared kelvin cap the assessment is no longer an assessment of50 the same part, and the shortfall is reported in kelvin so the reviewer51 can see how far past the cap the design actually sits.52- Residual risk stacks. Each carried rule leaves a declared share53 behind, and a part held up by four individually valid mitigations is54 refused on the total even though no single mitigation was wrong. The55 ceiling is what stops the class becoming a way to admit anything with56 enough paperwork.57- A mitigation attached to a rule the part already meets is reported,58 not counted. It costs the programme money and it hides which rules the59 part actually failed.6061## Workflow62631. Validate the candidate: every rule fact declared true or false, a64 recognised procurement route, and a temperature case whose rated and65 mission ranges are both real ranges.662. Compute the temperature shortfall in kelvin from the mission range67 extended by its declared margin, summing the hot and cold ends.683. Evaluate the seven baseline rules and collect the failures.694. Validate each mitigation record, refusing one attached to the hard70 bar and refusing two records on one rule.715. For every failed rule, accept the mitigation only when it is the72 measure recognised for that rule and inside the limit the measure73 carries; the uprating route is compared with the kelvin cap, treating74 an exactly-met cap as met through a named tolerance.756. Sum the residual shares of the carried rules and compare the total76 with the declared ceiling under the same tolerance.777. Report mitigations attached to rules the part already meets.788. Return ranked findings, the shortfall in kelvin, the residual risk79 and one verdict: admissible, admissible with mitigation, or not80 admissible.8182## Pitfalls8384- Letting a mitigation carry the provenance rule. A part of unknown85 origin is not a part with a gap in its paperwork, and every other rule86 is silently conditioned on the identity that rule establishes.87- Accepting any declared mitigation for any failed rule. The measure is88 recognised per rule; a generic quality argument attached to a lot89 homogeneity failure changes nothing about the lots that will fly.90- Uprating past the cap because the shortfall is only a few kelvin over.91 The cap is the point the measure stops being evidence, and the92 shortfall is reported in kelvin precisely so that decision is visible93 rather than buried in a pass.94- Judging each mitigation alone. Individually valid measures stack into95 a part nobody would have chosen on its merits, which is what the96 residual ceiling exists to catch.97- Reading margin as optional. A rated range that just touches the98 mission range fails, and dropping the margin turns a real shortfall99 into a clean pass.100- Treating an undeclared rule fact as a met rule. Unknown is not true;101 the candidate is refused until the fact is declared.102- Leaving mitigations attached to rules the part passes. They inflate103 the apparent effort and obscure the failures the reviewer came for.104105## Behavior contract (gate 3)106107The candidate validation, temperature shortfall, baseline rule108evaluation, mitigation validation, per-rule recognition, uprating cap,109residual risk summation, ceiling comparison, unused mitigation report110and admissibility verdict are exercised by the gate 3 contract test:111scripts/test_q6013_class_2_selection_rules.py against112scripts/q6013_class_2_selection_rules_logic.py (stdlib unittest,113offline). Run:114python3 scripts/test_q6013_class_2_selection_rules.py115116## Compliance117118- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and119 paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.120- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.