ECSS Offgassing — Odour Assessment (space-systems/ecss/q7029-odour-assessment)
Use when the task is the odour step of ECSS-Q-ST-70-29: turning the individual
intensity ratings given by a trained sensory panel on an offgassing sample into
an acceptability verdict for a crew compartment, together with the reasons the
verdict can or cannot be relied on.
Domain quick reference
- The rating scale is bounded and ordinal: from undetectable at the bottom to
irritating at the top, in fixed steps a judge may halve but not exceed. A
score outside the scale is a transcription error, not a strong opinion, and
is refused rather than clamped.
- Only a judge currently qualified on the reference odour set contributes.
Qualification lapses, so the raw sheet usually contains scores that have to
be set aside; the panel size that matters is the size after they are.
- A panel below its minimum size does not produce a weaker verdict, it
produces no verdict. The correct output is a finding calling for the test to
be repeated with a full panel.
- Agreement is part of the result. A mean that sits comfortably under the
acceptance rating but is built from one undetectable and one irritating
score is not an acceptable sample; it is an unrepeatable measurement, and
the dispersion check is what surfaces it.
- A single score at the top of the scale overrides the mean. One judge finding
the sample irritating is a veto, because the crew member who reacts that way
is the case the limit exists for.
Workflow
- Validate every score against the bounded scale and every judge entry
against its qualification flag; refuse a malformed sheet outright.
- Separate the qualified scores from the rest and record which judges were
set aside and why.
- Compare the qualified panel size with the declared minimum. Below it, stop
and return the incomplete-panel finding rather than a number.
- Compute the mean intensity of the qualified scores.
- Compute the dispersion of those scores as the sample standard deviation and
compare it with the agreement threshold.
- Test for a veto score at the top of the scale.
- Grade the mean against the acceptance rating, treating a mean sitting
exactly on the rating as meeting it and absorbing representation error with
a named tolerance rather than by moving the rating.
- Report the verdict, the qualified panel size, the mean, the dispersion and
every finding: dropped judges, short panel, poor agreement, veto score.
Pitfalls
- Averaging the whole sheet because more scores look like more evidence.
Unqualified judges are not a smaller weight, they are not evidence.
- Passing a sample on the mean alone when the panel did not agree. The spread
is the signal that the sample presents differently to different people, and
it belongs in the verdict.
- Letting a top-of-scale score be averaged away by mild scores. The veto is
deliberate; the mean does not represent the judge who could not stay in the
compartment.
- Reporting a verdict from a short panel with a caveat instead of a finding. A
panel under its minimum has no statistical standing and the result must not
be carried into acceptance.
- Nudging the acceptance rating upward to absorb a mean a hair above it. The
rating is fixed; only representation error is absorbed, by the tolerance
inside the comparison.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The scale validation, qualification filtering, minimum-panel rule, mean and
dispersion computation, veto rule and acceptance grading are exercised by the
gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_q7029_odour_assessment.py against
scripts/q7029_odour_assessment_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_q7029_odour_assessment.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and
paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: q7029-odour-assessment3description: "Evaluate the acceptability of the odour an offgassing sample presents to a trained sensory panel under ECSS-Q-ST-70-29: keep only the scores of judges currently qualified on the reference set, check the panel is still large enough once they are dropped, average the intensity ratings, test the spread for a panel that did not agree, and grade the result against the acceptance rating. Use when an offgassing test has produced panel scores and they must become a defensible odour verdict rather than an average. Trigger: ecss, q-st-70-29, offgassing-odour-assessment, offgassing-sensory-panel, offgassing-odour-rating-scale, offgassing-panel-qualification, offgassing-panel-dispersion, crew-compartment-offgassing."4license: Apache-2.05compliance: STANDARDS-REF6standards:7 - id: ecss8 reference-only: true9gated: false10domain: space-systems11pack: space-systems12compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"13metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/q7029-odour-assessment15 domain: space-systems16 subdomain: ecss17 tags: [ecss, q-st-70-materials-scope, q7029-odour-assessment, offgassing-odour-assessment, offgassing-sensory-panel, offgassing-odour-rating-scale, offgassing-panel-qualification, offgassing-panel-dispersion]18 version: 0.1.019 author: Aero Agent Skills20---2122# ECSS Offgassing — Odour Assessment (space-systems/ecss/q7029-odour-assessment)2324Use when the task is the odour step of ECSS-Q-ST-70-29: turning the individual25intensity ratings given by a trained sensory panel on an offgassing sample into26an acceptability verdict for a crew compartment, together with the reasons the27verdict can or cannot be relied on.2829## Domain quick reference3031- The rating scale is bounded and ordinal: from undetectable at the bottom to32 irritating at the top, in fixed steps a judge may halve but not exceed. A33 score outside the scale is a transcription error, not a strong opinion, and34 is refused rather than clamped.35- Only a judge currently qualified on the reference odour set contributes.36 Qualification lapses, so the raw sheet usually contains scores that have to37 be set aside; the panel size that matters is the size after they are.38- A panel below its minimum size does not produce a weaker verdict, it39 produces no verdict. The correct output is a finding calling for the test to40 be repeated with a full panel.41- Agreement is part of the result. A mean that sits comfortably under the42 acceptance rating but is built from one undetectable and one irritating43 score is not an acceptable sample; it is an unrepeatable measurement, and44 the dispersion check is what surfaces it.45- A single score at the top of the scale overrides the mean. One judge finding46 the sample irritating is a veto, because the crew member who reacts that way47 is the case the limit exists for.4849## Workflow50511. Validate every score against the bounded scale and every judge entry52 against its qualification flag; refuse a malformed sheet outright.532. Separate the qualified scores from the rest and record which judges were54 set aside and why.553. Compare the qualified panel size with the declared minimum. Below it, stop56 and return the incomplete-panel finding rather than a number.574. Compute the mean intensity of the qualified scores.585. Compute the dispersion of those scores as the sample standard deviation and59 compare it with the agreement threshold.606. Test for a veto score at the top of the scale.617. Grade the mean against the acceptance rating, treating a mean sitting62 exactly on the rating as meeting it and absorbing representation error with63 a named tolerance rather than by moving the rating.648. Report the verdict, the qualified panel size, the mean, the dispersion and65 every finding: dropped judges, short panel, poor agreement, veto score.6667## Pitfalls6869- Averaging the whole sheet because more scores look like more evidence.70 Unqualified judges are not a smaller weight, they are not evidence.71- Passing a sample on the mean alone when the panel did not agree. The spread72 is the signal that the sample presents differently to different people, and73 it belongs in the verdict.74- Letting a top-of-scale score be averaged away by mild scores. The veto is75 deliberate; the mean does not represent the judge who could not stay in the76 compartment.77- Reporting a verdict from a short panel with a caveat instead of a finding. A78 panel under its minimum has no statistical standing and the result must not79 be carried into acceptance.80- Nudging the acceptance rating upward to absorb a mean a hair above it. The81 rating is fixed; only representation error is absorbed, by the tolerance82 inside the comparison.8384## Behavior contract (gate 3)8586The scale validation, qualification filtering, minimum-panel rule, mean and87dispersion computation, veto rule and acceptance grading are exercised by the88gate 3 contract test: scripts/test_q7029_odour_assessment.py against89scripts/q7029_odour_assessment_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:90python3 scripts/test_q7029_odour_assessment.py9192## Compliance9394- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and95 paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.96- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.