ECSS Structures — Strength Functionality (space-systems/ecss/strength-functionality)
Use when the task is verifying that a structural design satisfies the
strength functionality requirements of ECSS-E-ST-32C clause 4.3.2 —
confirming no permanent deformation at the Design Yield Load and no
fracture or collapse at the Design Ultimate Load, applied at every
level of the assembly hierarchy.
Domain quick reference
- Clause 4.3.2 establishes two load-level gates: the Design Yield Load
(DYL) and the Design Ultimate Load (DUL). The DYL is derived from the
limit load by applying a yield factor of safety; the DUL is derived by
applying a higher ultimate factor of safety. Both are applied at each
assembly level — component, subsystem, and system — not only at the top
level.
- The no-yielding criterion at DYL requires that the equivalent stress
at every critical location remains below the material yield strength.
For metallic isotropic materials the multiaxial stress state is reduced
to an equivalent scalar stress using the von Mises criterion before
comparison against the allowable.
- The no-failure criterion at DUL requires that the equivalent stress
remains below the material ultimate strength (or that the applied load
remains below the section's ultimate capacity for net-section or
fastener checks). No plastic collapse, fracture, or instability may
occur below DUL.
- Margin of safety (MoS) is the standard reporting metric: MoS =
(allowable / applied) − 1. A non-negative MoS is required; a negative
MoS at either gate is a non-compliance finding regardless of the
magnitude.
- The standard permits nonlinear analysis (material or geometric) when
linear methods are not conservative. Nonlinear runs must still satisfy
the same DYL and DUL thresholds and must report MoS referenced to the
same allowables.
Workflow
- Identify the limit load for each load case and assembly level under
assessment. Do not apply factors of safety to the limit load at this
step; retain them as a separate multiplier.
- Derive DYL and DUL by multiplying the limit load by the applicable
yield and ultimate factors of safety respectively (per the program
factors-of-safety document and ECSS-E-ST-32C Table 4-1 or equivalent).
- Run the structural analysis (linear or nonlinear finite element, or
closed-form) for each load case at both DYL and DUL. Record the peak
equivalent stress at each critical location. For multiaxial states,
apply the von Mises criterion to compute the equivalent scalar stress
before comparing against the allowable.
- Compute MoS for the yield gate: MoS_yield = (yield_strength /
vm_stress_at_DYL) − 1. Flag any location where MoS_yield < 0.
- Compute MoS for the ultimate gate: MoS_ultimate = (ultimate_strength /
vm_stress_at_DUL) − 1. Flag any location where MoS_ultimate < 0.
- Repeat steps 1–5 for every level of the assembly hierarchy that has
been identified as a structural load path. A finding at any level is a
non-compliance regardless of the pass/fail status at other levels.
- Consolidate results into a strength summary table listing assembly
level, load case, DYL, DUL, peak von Mises stress at each gate, and
both MoS values. All entries must show MoS ≥ 0 for the design to
satisfy clause 4.3.2.
Pitfalls
- Applying factors of safety to the analysis input loads rather than
deriving DYL/DUL from the limit load — factors of safety must be
applied to the limit load, not stacked on top of an already-factored
load, or the DUL calculation double-counts the margin.
- Checking only the system-level assembly and treating subsystem and
component findings as bounded by the system result — clause 4.3.2
requires independent verification at all levels; a component may fail
its own yield criterion even when the system-level MoS is positive.
- Using maximum principal stress as the scalar for yield comparison on
metallic ductile materials — the von Mises criterion is the appropriate
choice for isotropic ductile metals; principal stress comparisons are
appropriate for brittle materials where a different failure criterion
applies.
- Reading a near-zero positive MoS as comfortable — MoS ≥ 0 is the
binary pass criterion, but program requirements often mandate a minimum
positive MoS (e.g. MoS ≥ 0.00) and acceptance boards may impose
stricter limits; always verify the program-specific threshold.
- Running a linear analysis at DUL without checking whether large
displacements or material nonlinearity change the load path — when the
structure exhibits geometric or material softening before DUL, a linear
analysis underestimates peak stresses and is not conservative.
Behavior contract (gate 3)
The DYL/DUL scaling, von Mises equivalent stress, margin-of-safety, and
multi-level compliance logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:
scripts/test_strength_functionality.py against
scripts/strength_functionality_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:
python3 scripts/test_strength_functionality.py
Compliance
- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and
paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.
- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.
1---2name: strength-functionality3description: "Use when verify strength functionality requirements per4 ECSS-E-ST-32C clause 4.3.2 across all levels of assembly: confirm no5 yielding occurs at the Design Yield Load (DYL) and no failure at the6 Design Ultimate Load (DUL). Scale limit loads by yield and ultimate factors7 of safety, evaluate multiaxial stress states with the von Mises criterion,8 and compute margins of safety for yield and ultimate thresholds at each9 assembly level (component, subsystem, system). Flag any level where a10 margin falls below zero. Applicable to linear and nonlinear finite element11 analyses. Trigger: ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, strength-functionality,12 margin-of-safety, design-yield-load, design-ultimate-load, von-mises,13 factors-of-safety."14license: Apache-2.015compliance: STANDARDS-REF16standards:17 - id: ecss18 reference-only: true19gated: false20domain: space-systems21pack: space-systems22compatibility: "agentskills.io SKILL.md; any SKILL.md host (Claude Code, Hermes, OpenClaw)"23metadata:24 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/ashfordeou/strength-functionality25 domain: space-systems26 subdomain: ecss27 tags: [ecss, e-st-32-structures-scope, strength-functionality, margin-of-safety, design-yield-load, design-ultimate-load, von-mises, factors-of-safety]28 version: 0.1.029 author: Aero Agent Skills30---3132# ECSS Structures — Strength Functionality (space-systems/ecss/strength-functionality)3334Use when the task is verifying that a structural design satisfies the35strength functionality requirements of ECSS-E-ST-32C clause 4.3.2 —36confirming no permanent deformation at the Design Yield Load and no37fracture or collapse at the Design Ultimate Load, applied at every38level of the assembly hierarchy.3940## Domain quick reference4142- Clause 4.3.2 establishes two load-level gates: the Design Yield Load43 (DYL) and the Design Ultimate Load (DUL). The DYL is derived from the44 limit load by applying a yield factor of safety; the DUL is derived by45 applying a higher ultimate factor of safety. Both are applied at each46 assembly level — component, subsystem, and system — not only at the top47 level.48- The no-yielding criterion at DYL requires that the equivalent stress49 at every critical location remains below the material yield strength.50 For metallic isotropic materials the multiaxial stress state is reduced51 to an equivalent scalar stress using the von Mises criterion before52 comparison against the allowable.53- The no-failure criterion at DUL requires that the equivalent stress54 remains below the material ultimate strength (or that the applied load55 remains below the section's ultimate capacity for net-section or56 fastener checks). No plastic collapse, fracture, or instability may57 occur below DUL.58- Margin of safety (MoS) is the standard reporting metric: MoS =59 (allowable / applied) − 1. A non-negative MoS is required; a negative60 MoS at either gate is a non-compliance finding regardless of the61 magnitude.62- The standard permits nonlinear analysis (material or geometric) when63 linear methods are not conservative. Nonlinear runs must still satisfy64 the same DYL and DUL thresholds and must report MoS referenced to the65 same allowables.6667## Workflow68691. Identify the limit load for each load case and assembly level under70 assessment. Do not apply factors of safety to the limit load at this71 step; retain them as a separate multiplier.722. Derive DYL and DUL by multiplying the limit load by the applicable73 yield and ultimate factors of safety respectively (per the program74 factors-of-safety document and ECSS-E-ST-32C Table 4-1 or equivalent).753. Run the structural analysis (linear or nonlinear finite element, or76 closed-form) for each load case at both DYL and DUL. Record the peak77 equivalent stress at each critical location. For multiaxial states,78 apply the von Mises criterion to compute the equivalent scalar stress79 before comparing against the allowable.804. Compute MoS for the yield gate: MoS_yield = (yield_strength /81 vm_stress_at_DYL) − 1. Flag any location where MoS_yield < 0.825. Compute MoS for the ultimate gate: MoS_ultimate = (ultimate_strength /83 vm_stress_at_DUL) − 1. Flag any location where MoS_ultimate < 0.846. Repeat steps 1–5 for every level of the assembly hierarchy that has85 been identified as a structural load path. A finding at any level is a86 non-compliance regardless of the pass/fail status at other levels.877. Consolidate results into a strength summary table listing assembly88 level, load case, DYL, DUL, peak von Mises stress at each gate, and89 both MoS values. All entries must show MoS ≥ 0 for the design to90 satisfy clause 4.3.2.9192## Pitfalls9394- Applying factors of safety to the analysis input loads rather than95 deriving DYL/DUL from the limit load — factors of safety must be96 applied to the limit load, not stacked on top of an already-factored97 load, or the DUL calculation double-counts the margin.98- Checking only the system-level assembly and treating subsystem and99 component findings as bounded by the system result — clause 4.3.2100 requires independent verification at all levels; a component may fail101 its own yield criterion even when the system-level MoS is positive.102- Using maximum principal stress as the scalar for yield comparison on103 metallic ductile materials — the von Mises criterion is the appropriate104 choice for isotropic ductile metals; principal stress comparisons are105 appropriate for brittle materials where a different failure criterion106 applies.107- Reading a near-zero positive MoS as comfortable — MoS ≥ 0 is the108 binary pass criterion, but program requirements often mandate a minimum109 positive MoS (e.g. MoS ≥ 0.00) and acceptance boards may impose110 stricter limits; always verify the program-specific threshold.111- Running a linear analysis at DUL without checking whether large112 displacements or material nonlinearity change the load path — when the113 structure exhibits geometric or material softening before DUL, a linear114 analysis underestimates peak stresses and is not conservative.115116## Behavior contract (gate 3)117118The DYL/DUL scaling, von Mises equivalent stress, margin-of-safety, and119multi-level compliance logic is exercised by the gate 3 contract test:120scripts/test_strength_functionality.py against121scripts/strength_functionality_logic.py (stdlib unittest, offline). Run:122python3 scripts/test_strength_functionality.py123124## Compliance125126- ECSS standards are freely downloadable (ESA); cite the source and127 paraphrase per standards-map.yaml.128- compliance: STANDARDS-REF, gated: false.