Plugin Review

Plugin Review

Overview

Tiered quality review of plugins with dependency-aware scoping.

When NOT To Use

• Reviewing one skill rather than a plugin (use abstract:skills-eval)
• Reviewing hooks (use abstract:hooks-eval)
• Tracing Skill() references across plugins (use abstract:skill-graph-audit)

Table of Contents

• Tiers
• Orchestration
• Scope Detection
• Module Loading
• Verdict
• Output Format
• Quality Gate Mode
• Configuration

Tiers

Orchestration

1. Detect scope: parse --tier flag, find affected plugins from git diff, resolve related plugins from docs/plugin-dependencies.json
2. Plan: build check matrix (tier x plugin x role)
3. Execute: run checks per tier definition
4. Report: per-plugin table, aggregate verdict

Scope Detection

Affected plugins: git diff main --name-only filtered to plugins/*/.

Related plugins: load docs/plugin-dependencies.json, look up each affected plugin's reverse index to find dependents. Mark as "related" (lighter checks).

If --tier release or no git diff available, scope to all plugins.

Module Loading

• Always: this SKILL.md (orchestration logic)
• branch tier: load modules/tier-branch.md
• pr tier: load modules/tier-branch.md then modules/tier-pr.md
• release tier: load all tier modules plus modules/tier-release.md
• When resolving deps: load modules/dependency-detection.md

Verdict

Output Format

Plugin Review (<tier> tier)
Affected: <list>
Related:  <list> (<reason>)

Plugin          test  lint  type  reg   verdict
<name>          PASS  PASS  PASS  PASS  PASS
...

Verdict: <PASS|PASS-WITH-WARNINGS|FAIL> (N/N plugins healthy)

PR and release tiers add scorecard sections.

Quality Gate Mode

The --quality-gate flag enables CI/CD integration with exit codes that distinguish warnings from failures:

• 0: all quality gates passed
• 1: warnings present but gates passed (non-blocking)
• 2: quality gate failures (blocking)
• 3: critical issues found (blocking)

Use --fail-on warning to treat warnings as blocking.

Configuration

Place a .plugin-review.yaml file in the plugin root to customize thresholds and focus areas:

plugin_review:
  quality_gates:
    structure_min: 80
    skills_min: 75
    hooks_min: 70
    tokens_max_total: 50000
    bloat_max_percentage: 15
  focus_areas:
    - skills
    - hooks
    - tokens
  exclude_patterns:
    - "*/legacy/*"
    - "*/deprecated/*"
  severity_overrides:
    missing_description: warning
    large_file: info

See the /plugin-review command reference for full usage examples.

Exit Criteria

• The output includes a per-plugin table with columns: test, lint, type, reg, verdict, and an aggregate PASS / PASS-WITH-WARNINGS / FAIL verdict.
• Scope detection identifies affected plugins via git diff main --name-only filtered to plugins/*/; if git diff is unavailable, the skill falls back to all-plugin scope and states this explicitly.
• Any plugin scoring below the structure_min (default 80) or skills_min (default 75) threshold is listed as a FAIL, not a warning.
• --quality-gate mode returns exit code 2 for blocking failures and exit code 1 for non-blocking warnings, distinguishable by the calling CI step.