TRIZ Cross-Domain Analysis
When To Use
- Stuck on a problem and need perspectives from other domains
- Exploring cross-domain analogies for inventive solutions
When NOT To Use
- Standard code search or literature review (use other
tome channels)
- Problems with obvious, well-known solutions
Apply Altshuller's Theory of Inventive Problem Solving
to find solutions from adjacent fields.
Depth Levels
| Depth |
Fields |
Analysis |
| light |
1 |
Ideality and contradiction |
| medium |
2 |
Ideality, contradiction, field mapping |
| deep |
3 |
Adds principle suggestions and separation |
| maximum |
5 |
Adds distant fields |
Workflow
Run the catalogue steps first. One command returns, per ranked
candidate, the contradiction record, its ideal final result, the
physical-contradiction check, the five reformulation probes, and the
near resolutions or separation axes where they apply:
PYTHONPATH="${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/src" python3 -m tome.channels.triz analyze --topic "<topic>" --domain <domain>
- State the Ideal Final Result: the function delivered
without the system existing. Ask what would make the
system unnecessary while the function still happens.
- Formulate the technical contradiction: improving X
worsens Y. Every record carries
matched: keyword when
a catalogue row named the topic, fallback when none did.
Treat a fallback as unformulated: its near_resolutions
list the rows within one or two edits of the topic's
words. Restate the topic in a row's terms or keep the
fallback with a reason. For a physical contradiction (one
parameter pulled toward two opposite values, physical: true), apply separation in time, space, condition, or
system/scale instead of compromise. separation lists
the axis the system description points at first, with
the words that put it there in why.
- Probe the statement before searching:
probes holds
five fixed probes, each with its principle and a dated
source. Swap
the sides (#13), relax the equality into a range (#16),
name the parameter and direction that would surface a
near-solution (#35), promote a constant to a variable
(#15), and ask whether any value satisfies both demands.
The swap probe carries both principle sets and
principle_set_differs. Show the inverted form only when
it is true. Answer each in a line or dismiss it with a
reason. When
nothing satisfies both, stop searching harder: separate
the demands or state the ideal final result.
- Map to adjacent fields using the field taxonomy.
- Search for solved analogues in those fields.
- Build bridge mappings with rationale and a confidence
score.
Field Mapping Strategy
- Software architecture: civil engineering, biology
- Data structures: logistics, materials science
- Algorithms: operations research, genetics
- Security: military strategy, immunology
- Financial: game theory, ecology
Related
TRIZ is the analogical method in the broader ideation catalog.
For diverse, category-spanning ideation with rotation, see
Skill(tome:ideate).
Limitations
- The built-in contradiction catalog maps common software
trade-offs to principles. It is a convenience mapping
rather than part of the classical TRIZ Body of Knowledge, which is
scoped to technological systems.
- The strongest, most portable parts of TRIZ are the 40
principles as a divergence checklist and Ideality as a
framing question. ARIZ, Substance-Field analysis, the 76 standard
solutions, the Laws of Technical Systems Evolution (S-curves), and
Function-Oriented Search (FOS) are out of scope here.
Sources
- TRIZ Body of Knowledge (MATRIZ) and the classical
contradiction matrix (matriz.org).
- AutoTRIZ (arXiv 2403.13002, 2024): LLM-driven TRIZ ideation.
- TRIZ Agents (arXiv 2506.18783, 2025): multi-agent LLM orchestration
across TRIZ steps, a companion to AutoTRIZ.
- Madrigal, "The Shadows Lurking in the Equations" (gods.art, 2025)
and the literature the reformulation probes cite: Chinneck,
Feasibility and Infeasibility in Optimization (2008); Allgower and
Georg, Numerical Continuation Methods (1990); Liberti,
Reformulations in Mathematical Programming (2009); Duncker, On
Problem-Solving (1945); Hipple, TRIZ Separation Principles (2012).
ADR-0026.
Exit Criteria
1---2name: triz3description: Applies TRIZ cross-domain analogical reasoning to find solutions from adjacent fields. Use when stuck on a problem and needing inventive perspectives.4alwaysApply: false5category: research6tags:7 - triz8 - cross-domain9 - innovation10 - analogy11 - altshuller12estimated_tokens: 45013metadata:14 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/athola/triz15---1617# TRIZ Cross-Domain Analysis1819## When To Use2021- Stuck on a problem and need perspectives from other domains22- Exploring cross-domain analogies for inventive solutions2324## When NOT To Use2526- Standard code search or literature review (use other27 tome channels)28- Problems with obvious, well-known solutions2930Apply Altshuller's Theory of Inventive Problem Solving31to find solutions from adjacent fields.3233## Depth Levels3435| Depth | Fields | Analysis |36|-------|--------|----------|37| light | 1 | Ideality and contradiction |38| medium | 2 | Ideality, contradiction, field mapping |39| deep | 3 | Adds principle suggestions and separation |40| maximum | 5 | Adds distant fields |4142## Workflow4344Run the catalogue steps first. One command returns, per ranked45candidate, the contradiction record, its ideal final result, the46physical-contradiction check, the five reformulation probes, and the47near resolutions or separation axes where they apply:4849```bash50PYTHONPATH="${CLAUDE_PLUGIN_ROOT}/src" python3 -m tome.channels.triz analyze --topic "<topic>" --domain <domain>51```52531. State the Ideal Final Result: the function delivered54 without the system existing. Ask what would make the55 system unnecessary while the function still happens.562. Formulate the technical contradiction: improving X57 worsens Y. Every record carries `matched`: `keyword` when58 a catalogue row named the topic, `fallback` when none did.59 Treat a fallback as unformulated: its `near_resolutions`60 list the rows within one or two edits of the topic's61 words. Restate the topic in a row's terms or keep the62 fallback with a reason. For a physical contradiction (one63 parameter pulled toward two opposite values, `physical:64 true`), apply separation in time, space, condition, or65 system/scale instead of compromise. `separation` lists66 the axis the system description points at first, with67 the words that put it there in `why`.683. Probe the statement before searching: `probes` holds69 five fixed probes, each with its principle and a dated70 source. Swap71 the sides (#13), relax the equality into a range (#16),72 name the parameter and direction that would surface a73 near-solution (#35), promote a constant to a variable74 (#15), and ask whether any value satisfies both demands.75 The swap probe carries both principle sets and76 `principle_set_differs`. Show the inverted form only when77 it is true. Answer each in a line or dismiss it with a78 reason. When79 nothing satisfies both, stop searching harder: separate80 the demands or state the ideal final result.814. Map to adjacent fields using the field taxonomy.825. Search for solved analogues in those fields.836. Build bridge mappings with rationale and a confidence84 score.8586## Field Mapping Strategy8788- Software architecture: civil engineering, biology89- Data structures: logistics, materials science90- Algorithms: operations research, genetics91- Security: military strategy, immunology92- Financial: game theory, ecology9394## Related9596TRIZ is the analogical method in the broader ideation catalog.97For diverse, category-spanning ideation with rotation, see98`Skill(tome:ideate)`.99100## Limitations101102- The built-in contradiction catalog maps common software103 trade-offs to principles. It is a convenience mapping104 rather than part of the classical TRIZ Body of Knowledge, which is105 scoped to technological systems.106- The strongest, most portable parts of TRIZ are the 40107 principles as a divergence checklist and Ideality as a108 framing question. ARIZ, Substance-Field analysis, the 76 standard109 solutions, the Laws of Technical Systems Evolution (S-curves), and110 Function-Oriented Search (FOS) are out of scope here.111112## Sources113114- TRIZ Body of Knowledge (MATRIZ) and the classical115 contradiction matrix (matriz.org).116- AutoTRIZ (arXiv 2403.13002, 2024): LLM-driven TRIZ ideation.117- TRIZ Agents (arXiv 2506.18783, 2025): multi-agent LLM orchestration118 across TRIZ steps, a companion to AutoTRIZ.119- Madrigal, "The Shadows Lurking in the Equations" (gods.art, 2025)120 and the literature the reformulation probes cite: Chinneck,121 Feasibility and Infeasibility in Optimization (2008); Allgower and122 Georg, Numerical Continuation Methods (1990); Liberti,123 Reformulations in Mathematical Programming (2009); Duncker, On124 Problem-Solving (1945); Hipple, TRIZ Separation Principles (2012).125 ADR-0026.126127## Exit Criteria128129- [ ] An Ideal Final Result statement is produced before the130 search begins.131- [ ] A technical contradiction is stated as "improving X132 worsens Y" (or a physical contradiction is named with a133 separation axis).134- [ ] A `fallback` record is either restated in a catalogue135 row's terms via `near_resolutions` or kept with a stated136 reason. It is never reported as a keyword match.137- [ ] Each of the five reformulation probes is answered in a138 line or dismissed with a reason. An infeasible verdict139 routes to separation or the ideal final result and no140 analogy search follows it.141- [ ] At least one cross-domain bridge with a confidence142 score is returned per active adjacent field, or the143 field is explicitly reported as yielding nothing.