Pic Decide

PIC Decision Recording

You are recording a formal decision for the PIC workflow. Follow this protocol exactly.

Input

The user wants to record a decision titled: $ARGS

If no title was provided, ask the user what decision they want to document.

Protocol

Step 1: Verify Workflow State

Read .pic/state.json to verify a workflow is active.

If no workflow:

No active workflow. Use `/pic-start [problem]` first.

And stop.

Step 2: Generate Decision ID

Read existing decisions in .pic/decisions/ to determine the next ID.

Format: DEC-[NNN] where NNN is zero-padded (e.g., DEC-001, DEC-002)

Step 3: Gather Decision Details

Ask the user for (if not already provided):

1. Decision Title: What is being decided
2. Context: Why this decision is needed
3. Options Considered: What alternatives were evaluated
4. Decision: What was chosen
5. Rationale: Why this option was selected
6. Consequences: What this decision enables or constrains
7. Evidence: Data or findings supporting this decision

Step 4: Create Decision Document

Write to .pic/decisions/DEC-[NNN].md:

# DEC-[NNN]: [Title]

**Date**: [ISO date]
**Workflow**: [workflow id]
**Phase**: [current phase]
**Status**: Accepted

## Context

[Why this decision is needed]

## Decision

[What was decided]

## Options Considered

### Option 1: [Name]
- **Pros**: [advantages]
- **Cons**: [disadvantages]

### Option 2: [Name]
- **Pros**: [advantages]
- **Cons**: [disadvantages]

[... more options as needed ...]

## Rationale

[Why this option was selected over others]

## Evidence

[Data, research findings, or other evidence supporting this decision]

## Consequences

### Enables
- [What this decision makes possible]

### Constrains
- [What this decision limits or prevents]

## Related Decisions

- [Links to related DEC-XXX documents, if any]

Step 5: Update State

Add decision reference to .pic/state.json decisions array:

{
  "id": "DEC-[NNN]",
  "title": "[title]",
  "phase": "[current phase]",
  "timestamp": "[ISO]"
}

Step 6: Log Decision

Append to .pic/status-log.jsonl:

{"timestamp": "[ISO]", "event": "decision_recorded", "decision": "DEC-[NNN]", "title": "[title]", "phase": "[phase]"}

Step 7: Confirm to User

Display:

## Decision Recorded

**ID**: DEC-[NNN]
**Title**: [title]
**File**: .pic/decisions/DEC-[NNN].md

The decision has been formally documented. It can be referenced by other phases and will be included in the final review.

Viewing Existing Decisions

If the user runs /pic-decide without arguments and there are existing decisions, offer to:

1. Create a new decision
2. List existing decisions
3. View a specific decision

Decision Quality Standards

Per the config, decisions should include:

• Clear rationale (required)
• Alternatives considered (required)
• Supporting evidence (recommended)

If the user's input is missing required elements, prompt for them.

Error Handling

• If decisions directory doesn't exist, create it
• If unable to write, report the error
• If state update fails, note the decision was created but state wasn't updated