Handoff Readiness

Handoff Readiness

Overview

Readiness is judged per consumption channel, not per repo: first detect what is being handed off and every way the project itself advertises consuming it, then walk each channel end-to-end as a cold external consumer would. An artifact that builds internally but breaks on npm install or on copy-paste is NOT ready.

When to use / when NOT

Use for:

• Pre-publish audits of packages, SDKs, CLIs, component kits, templates
• Hosted/copy registries (shadcn-style) before exposing them to users
• "Is this ready / can we ship / can we hand this off" questions about reusable artifacts
• Verifying exports maps, type declarations, peer dependencies, files whitelists

Do NOT use for:

• Docs/content site deploy checks → see docs-deploy-readiness
• Internal cross-package reuse/duplication questions → see reusability-audit
• General code quality/architecture → see code-audit
• Deep security or a11y review → see security-review, accessibility-compliance (this skill only checks the contract exists)
• Running this audit across many packages with parallel agents → orchestrate via convergence-loop

How it works

1. DETECT the artifact and its channels. Read, in order: root + per-package manifests (package.json or ecosystem equivalent — pyproject.toml, Cargo.toml, go.mod), exports/bin/files/main/types fields, build config (tsup/rollup/vite/esbuild/etc.), any committed registry JSON directories, README + docs install instructions. Classify the artifact as one or more of:
   • Runtime package (installed from a registry like npm, imported at runtime)
   • Copy/source distribution (code lands in the consumer's repo: shadcn-style registry, template, "copy this folder")
   • Hosted registry (committed JSON/index that a CLI or tool resolves; illustrative example only: public/r/*.json consumed by a shadcn-compatible or project-specific add CLI)
   • CLI binary (bin entry, installed globally or via npx/pnpm dlx)
   • Template/starter (cloned, then built by the consumer)
2. Enumerate every ADVERTISED consumption path. Only what the project documents counts as a channel — README install sections, docs "Installation" pages, registry index files, bin entries. Each advertised path becomes a row in the scorecard. An advertised-but-broken path is a blocker; an unadvertised path is out of scope.
3. Apply the universal bar (a–e below) to each channel. Skip dimensions that don't apply (e.g. exports-map checks for a pure copy distribution) and mark them N/A — never silently.
4. Simulate the consumer journey statically per channel. Follow the project's own install docs from zero: every referenced file, command, flag, alias, import specifier, and registry item must exist; no orphan imports (files importing siblings that the channel doesn't deliver); CSS/peer/env setup steps documented where required.
5. Run mechanical verifiers where tools exist. For npm-ecosystem packages, publint and @arethetypeswrong/cli --pack are the named 2026 baseline; also inspect pnpm pack (or npm pack --dry-run) output against what runtime actually needs. Use ecosystem equivalents elsewhere (twine check, cargo package --list). Prefer running tools over eyeballing.
6. Score and report using the Output format. Order blockers by what breaks the consumer first.

Quality bar (universal, per channel)

(a) Packaging correctness — runtime packages

(b) Public API contract

• UI value controls: controlled/uncontrolled duality (value/defaultValue/onChange-style pairs); semantic callback names (onOpenChange, not setOpen/handleClick2)
• ref handled per current ecosystem norm; stable ids wired via a useId-style mechanism, not hardcoded
• The stable public surface is documented; internals are not reachable through public entries
• No deprecated aliases before the first public release — rename and update all consumers/docs/registry files instead
• React-specific depth → react-senior-guide

(c) Division standard (file/component split)

• Detect the ecosystem norm the artifact targets (e.g. shadcn-style single file, per-part folders, flat one-file-per-component) and judge the split by-responsibility and ecosystem-compatible, not by personal taste
• For copy-distributed units: one install yields a complete, buildable unit; one obvious public entry per unit; remove/diff tooling treats the unit as the ownership boundary; docs list the installed file set

(d) Installability end-to-end

• Each channel verified separately; copy mode must rewrite package-only imports to local relative paths
• No dangling references: every documented command, item name, file target, and import specifier resolves
• Peer setup (CSS imports, provider wrapping, config files) is part of the install docs, not tribal knowledge

(e) A11y contract (UI libraries only)

• Each interactive component states its pattern contract (roles, keyboard table, focus behavior) somewhere consumable
• Deep verification is out of scope here → run accessibility-compliance

If the artifact handles user input, secrets, or network listeners (e.g. a CLI that starts a local server), also dispatch security-review.

Quality bar (2026 snapshot)

Snapshot dated 2026-06-10, distilled from researched sources. Refresh via websearch with the current year before trusting any version number or tool claim below.

Packaging (npm ecosystem):

• publint + @arethetypeswrong/cli --pack are the standard mechanical pair; "types condition first in every condition block" is the named rule
• ESM-only is the accepted default for new packages (Node ≥20.19/22.12 can require() ESM); dual CJS/ESM only for a concrete consumer need
• sideEffects: false with CSS files excepted; files verified via pnpm pack
• Changesets is the standard versioning tool for pnpm monorepos; npm provenance/trusted publishing (OIDC) increasingly expected for public packages
• 0.x semver is honest pre-release signaling (^0.x only patches within the minor), but README/LICENSE/CHANGELOG/repository.directory are still required

Component libraries (React line):

• forwardRef is deprecated; ref-as-prop is the norm (React 19+). New library code should not contain forwardRef
• React Compiler v1.0: npm libraries pre-compile before publishing; copy-distributed source still follows "no defensive useMemo/useCallback/memo" since consumer compiler use is unknown
• Consumers assume: controlled/uncontrolled pairs, state exposed as data-attributes (data-state, data-slot) for Tailwind selectors, composition via asChild or a render prop, useId for ARIA wiring
• Tailwind v4 libs: ship uncompiled source CSS consumers @import; never ship @import "tailwindcss" in dist CSS; document the @source "../node_modules/<pkg>" directive (v4 skips node_modules scanning)
• "use client" must survive the build (bundlers strip directives by default) for RSC-host compatibility; peer ranges honest (>=19 for ref-as-prop, >=19.2 for useEffectEvent/Activity)

File division / registry distribution:

• The shadcn registry schema fully supports multi-file items (files[] with per-file path, type, target; target placeholders preserve subdirectories) — both single-file (Radix/React Aria/classic shadcn) and per-part folders (Base UI, now a supported shadcn layer) are mainstream
• A multi-file-but-ecosystem-compatible unit MUST: (1) declare every file in the registry item with correct targets so one add is complete and buildable; (2) rewrite package-only imports to local relative paths in copy mode; (3) keep one obvious entry (index.ts per unit); (4) have remove/diff treat the unit as the ownership boundary; (5) list the installed file set in docs
• Split by responsibility (part/hook/variants/types), never by line-count ritual — copy readers must still be able to skim
• Registry index (registry.json) + per-item (registry-item.json); dependencies (npm) vs registryDependencies (other items); namespaced registries and CLI/MCP installs are current norms
• Copy/registry "published" = the committed public registry JSON is the contract; it must install cleanly via every advertised path — same bar as npm publish validation

Output

Produce exactly this report shape:

# Handoff Readiness — <artifact/repo name>

Detected artifact: <classification, e.g. "npm package + copy registry + CLI binary">
Detected channels (advertised):
- <channel> — evidence: <file path(s)>

## Per-channel scorecard
| Channel | Packaging | API contract | Division | Installability | A11y contract | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| <channel> | PASS/FAIL/N/A | PASS/FAIL/N/A | PASS/FAIL/N/A | PASS/FAIL/N/A | PASS/FAIL/N/A | READY / BLOCKED |

## Blockers (ordered: what breaks the consumer first)
1. [BLOCKER] <channel> — <what a real consumer hits> — <file:line> — <concrete fix>

## Warnings (non-blocking)
1. [WARN] <channel> — <issue> — <file:line>

## Verification run
- <tool/command> → <result>  (e.g. publint, attw --pack, pnpm pack inspection; or "not available: <why>")

## Verdict: READY | NOT READY (<n> blockers)

A channel is BLOCKED if any consumer-facing failure exists on it; the artifact is NOT READY if any advertised channel is blocked.

Common mistakes

• Auditing only the npm channel when copy/registry/CLI paths are also advertised — every documented path is a contract
• Eyeballing the exports map instead of running publint/attw; the map can look right and still resolve wrong types
• Treating a green internal monorepo build as proof consumers can build — workspace: protocol, tsconfig path aliases, and sibling-source imports all vanish or break outside the repo
• Judging file division by taste instead of the detected ecosystem norm
• Marking READY with undocumented peer/CSS/provider setup ("it works in our app" is not install docs)
• Hardcoding one project's specifics as required checks — a Hono localhost server, a dgadd-style CLI, or --tui-* tokens are illustrative shapes to detect, never assumed to exist
• Skipping the a11y-contract row for UI kits because "accessibility is a separate audit" — the contract's existence is part of handoff
• Re-explaining sibling skills inline instead of dispatching to accessibility-compliance, security-review, react-senior-guide, or reusability-audit
• Trusting the dated snapshot above without refreshing it against the current year