ML Paper Review
Use this skill to write concise peer reviews for ML and AI submissions.
Files
submission.tex- paper to reviewtemplates/review_template.tex- review form and scoring rubric
Workflow
- Read
templates/review_template.texto load the required review sections and scoring format. - Read
submission.texto understand the paper's claims, methods, evidence, and limitations. - Write a review with:
- 2-3 sentence summary
- strengths
- weaknesses
- questions for authors
- numeric scores
- overall recommendation
- confidence
- Base the written critique on the submitted paper and the review template.
Review Criteria
Score each criterion on a 1-10 scale:
- Novelty / Originality
- Technical Quality
- Clarity / Presentation
- Significance / Impact
- Reproducibility
Use the overall score and recommendation fields from the template.