Principle Evidence Over Assertion

Requires evidence for claims and verdicts. Apply when reporting completion, review findings, or verification results.

bostonaholic Updated

File contents

Evidence Over Assertion

Give every verdict cited evidence from a command run, file:line read, or authoritative value re-queried; degrade unverifiable verdicts explicitly.

  • Verify by re-querying, never by memory; zero exit proves acceptance, not resulting state, so re-read the authority.
  • Allow No PASS without cited evidence; report unverifiable items at degraded confidence.
  • Ground verdicts in named facts you observed; verify third-party claims at concrete file:line before adopting them.
  • Treat reviewer or model agreement as corroboration, never proof or a substitute for your check.
  • Verify a dependency claim by resolving it, never by reading a version range or a changelog; load the lowest version the range admits and call the API there, because that boundary is where a removed constant or a missing symbol actually breaks.

bostonaholic/team/tree/main/skills/principle-evidence-over-assertion commit 55bf012525

Frequently asked questions

npx skillmds@latest add bostonaholic/principle-evidence-over-assertion