Topic Selection & Venue Fit (aeja-topic-selection)
When to trigger
- A project is empirically promising but you are unsure it is "AEJ: Applied-shaped"
- The question reads like a policy evaluation, a field-specialist note, or a top-general-interest swing — and you need to place it
- Several possible framings of the same dataset exist and you must pick the one that lands here
- Reviewers (or a co-author) say "this is fine but why this journal?"
The AEJ: Applied fit test
AEJ: Applied wants empirical applied microeconomics where a credible causal research design answers a substantive economic question of broad applied-micro interest — above a pure field journal but more specialized than AER. Use this decision table to place the project.
| Signal in your project |
Likely fit |
| Clean identification + a question labor/dev/health/ed/public economists all care about |
AEJ: Applied (core) |
| Same design but the contribution is mainly a policy verdict / program ROI framing |
lean AEJ: Economic Policy |
| Genuinely general-interest, agenda-setting, methodologically ambitious, long |
aim AER first |
| Contribution is field-internal (only sub-field specialists will cite it) |
a field journal (JHE / JOLE / JDE) |
| New estimator with a toy application |
Econometrica / REStud / JoE, not AEJ: Applied |
AEJ: Applied is empirical-first: theory appears to interpret and discipline the estimate, not to lead. A descriptive or measurement paper can fit if the question is sharp and the measurement is the contribution — but it must not overclaim causality.
Sharpening the question (do this before writing anything)
- One-sentence question with the causal object named: "What is the effect of X on Y for population P, identified by design D?"
- Why broad applied-micro readers care — name two subfields beyond your own that should cite it.
- What the headline number will be (a magnitude with units, even if approximate) — if you cannot imagine the sentence "we find X raises Y by ___," the question is not yet AEJ: Applied-shaped.
- The credible-design seed — which design (RCT / DID / RD / IV / shift-share) makes the estimate believable; if none, the topic is not ready (route to
aeja-identification).
Checklist
Anti-patterns
- A field-internal contribution dressed up as general — desk-reject risk for "fit"
- A pure policy-ROI framing that reads as AEJ: Economic Policy
- An ambitious agenda paper that is really an AER swing sent to AEJ: Applied as a hedge (or vice versa)
- "Interesting dataset, no question" — data-availability is not a contribution
- Implying causality from a design that cannot support it just to clear the bar
Worked vignette (illustrative)
A researcher has linked administrative tax and education records for one country and wants to "study
inequality." That is a dataset, not a question. Working through the fit test: the cleanest variation in the
data is a school-finance reform that changed per-pupil spending at a sharp formula threshold — an RD. The
question becomes "what is the effect of marginal school spending on adult earnings, identified by the
funding-formula discontinuity?" Two subfields beyond education (labor and public) will cite it; the
imaginable headline is "a $1,000 increase in per-pupil spending raises adult earnings by ~___%." Now it is
AEJ: Applied-shaped — and clearly not an AER agenda paper or an AEJ: Policy program verdict.
Sibling-placement quick test
- Would a non-specialist applied economist find the question interesting, not just the finding? → AEJ: Applied
- Is the deliverable a policy recommendation / cost-benefit verdict? → lean AEJ: Economic Policy
- Is the ambition field-defining and the design unusually novel? → try AER first
- Will only sub-field specialists ever cite it? → a field journal
Output format
【Question】one sentence, estimand + population named
【Venue verdict】AEJ: Applied because [not AER: ___] [not AEJ: Policy: ___] [not field: ___]
【Cross-field appeal】subfields that will cite: [..., ...]
【Headline (anticipated)】"X raises/lowers Y by ~___ (units)"
【Design seed】RCT / DID / RD / IV / shift-share / descriptive
【JEL draft】[codes]
【Next step】aeja-literature-positioning
1---2name: aeja-topic-selection3description: "Use when deciding whether an applied-micro project belongs at the American Economic Journal: Applied Economics (AEJ: Applied) rather than AER, AEJ: Economic Policy, or a field journal, and what its central question should be. Sets venue fit and question scope; it does not design the identification (see aeja-identification)."4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/aeja-topic-selection6---78# Topic Selection & Venue Fit (aeja-topic-selection)910## When to trigger1112- A project is empirically promising but you are unsure it is "AEJ: Applied-shaped"13- The question reads like a policy evaluation, a field-specialist note, or a top-general-interest swing — and you need to place it14- Several possible framings of the same dataset exist and you must pick the one that lands here15- Reviewers (or a co-author) say "this is fine but why this journal?"1617## The AEJ: Applied fit test1819AEJ: Applied wants **empirical applied microeconomics** where a **credible causal research design** answers a **substantive economic question** of **broad applied-micro interest** — above a pure field journal but more specialized than AER. Use this decision table to place the project.2021| Signal in your project | Likely fit |22|------------------------|-----------|23| Clean identification + a question labor/dev/health/ed/public economists all care about | **AEJ: Applied** (core) |24| Same design but the contribution is mainly a policy verdict / program ROI framing | lean **AEJ: Economic Policy** |25| Genuinely general-interest, agenda-setting, methodologically ambitious, long | aim **AER** first |26| Contribution is field-internal (only sub-field specialists will cite it) | a **field journal** (JHE / JOLE / JDE) |27| New estimator with a toy application | **Econometrica / REStud / JoE**, not AEJ: Applied |2829AEJ: Applied is **empirical-first**: theory appears to interpret and discipline the estimate, not to lead. A descriptive or measurement paper can fit *if* the question is sharp and the measurement is the contribution — but it must not overclaim causality.3031## Sharpening the question (do this before writing anything)32331. **One-sentence question** with the causal object named: "What is the effect of X on Y for population P, identified by design D?"342. **Why broad applied-micro readers care** — name two subfields beyond your own that should cite it.353. **What the headline number will be** (a magnitude with units, even if approximate) — if you cannot imagine the sentence "we find X raises Y by ___," the question is not yet AEJ: Applied-shaped.364. **The credible-design seed** — which design (RCT / DID / RD / IV / shift-share) makes the estimate believable; if none, the topic is not ready (route to `aeja-identification`).3738## Checklist3940- [ ] One-sentence causal (or sharply descriptive) question with a named estimand41- [ ] Venue placed against the table above; reason it is AEJ: Applied and not AER / AEJ: Policy / a field journal written in one line42- [ ] Two subfields beyond your own that will cite it, named43- [ ] An imaginable headline sentence with a magnitude and units44- [ ] A candidate research design that could make the estimate credible45- [ ] JEL codes drafted (required at submission) reflecting the cross-field appeal4647## Anti-patterns4849- A field-internal contribution dressed up as general — desk-reject risk for "fit"50- A pure policy-ROI framing that reads as AEJ: Economic Policy51- An ambitious agenda paper that is really an AER swing sent to AEJ: Applied as a hedge (or vice versa)52- "Interesting dataset, no question" — data-availability is not a contribution53- Implying causality from a design that cannot support it just to clear the bar5455## Worked vignette (illustrative)5657A researcher has linked administrative tax and education records for one country and wants to "study58inequality." That is a dataset, not a question. Working through the fit test: the cleanest variation in the59data is a school-finance reform that changed per-pupil spending at a sharp formula threshold — an RD. The60question becomes "what is the effect of marginal school spending on adult earnings, identified by the61funding-formula discontinuity?" Two subfields beyond education (labor and public) will cite it; the62imaginable headline is "a $1,000 increase in per-pupil spending raises adult earnings by ~___%." Now it is63AEJ: Applied-shaped — and clearly not an AER agenda paper or an AEJ: Policy program verdict.6465## Sibling-placement quick test6667- Would a non-specialist applied economist find the *question* interesting, not just the *finding*? → AEJ: Applied68- Is the deliverable a policy recommendation / cost-benefit verdict? → lean AEJ: Economic Policy69- Is the ambition field-defining and the design unusually novel? → try AER first70- Will only sub-field specialists ever cite it? → a field journal7172## Output format7374```75【Question】one sentence, estimand + population named76【Venue verdict】AEJ: Applied because [not AER: ___] [not AEJ: Policy: ___] [not field: ___]77【Cross-field appeal】subfields that will cite: [..., ...]78【Headline (anticipated)】"X raises/lowers Y by ~___ (units)"79【Design seed】RCT / DID / RD / IV / shift-share / descriptive80【JEL draft】[codes]81【Next step】aeja-literature-positioning82```