Data & Transparency (crim-data-and-transparency)
Criminology research increasingly travels with its data and code. Expert reviewers and editors expect
that your reported tables and figures could be reproduced. Wiley's general data-sharing guidance requires
a Data Availability Statement for research- and synthesis-based articles, while the current Wiley ACT row
for Criminology lists the journal-specific data-sharing policy field as No Policy. Treat that as:
prepare a credible statement and package, but do not claim a journal-specific mandatory repository deposit
unless the live portal requires it.
When to trigger
- Building the reproducibility/replication package and the data-availability statement
- Deciding whether and how to preregister a prospective study
- Working with restricted data (juvenile records, NACJD restricted-use, agency administrative data)
- A reviewer asked how the analysis can be reproduced or the data accessed
What to prepare
- Data-availability statement. State where data and code live (e.g., ICPSR / NACJD, OSF, a
Wiley/Dryad repository) or why they cannot be shared. Use Wiley DAS templates and the live portal
wording; do not imply mandatory deposit where restricted data make that impossible.
- Reproducibility package. Data (or synthetic/derived substitutes), a master script that
regenerates every table and figure, a README documenting provenance and construction, seeds
for stochastic steps, and pinned software/package versions.
- Preregistration (prospective work). Lodge a pre-analysis plan (OSF Registries, AsPredicted) and
mark registered vs. exploratory analyses. Wiley ACT currently says Criminology does not
accept preprints, so separate preregistration from manuscript preprint posting.
- Open-science badges. Wiley offers Open Data, Open Materials, and Preregistered badges
via the Center for Open Science on participating journals; follow the live submission prompts.
Restricted criminal-justice data (common in criminology)
- Explain why the data cannot be shared (juvenile confidentiality, agency/IRB restrictions, DUAs).
- Provide README instructions on exactly how others obtain it — the application process, the archive
(often NACJD restricted-use), enclave requirements, and contacts.
- Where feasible, provide synthetic or de-identified derived data so the code can be exercised.
Build-as-you-go checklist
Anti-patterns
- Treating data/transparency as a post-acceptance afterthought
- A data-availability statement that says "available on request" with no archive or access path
- Depositing code that does not actually reproduce the printed tables/figures
- Claiming data are restricted without giving an access route or synthetic substitute
- Undocumented, un-seeded, unpinned code that "works on my machine"
Restricted-data transparency decision table (criminology specifics)
Criminal-justice data is often restricted — juvenile records, agency systems, NACJD restricted-use
files behind enclaves. The ASC/Wiley open-science direction still expects a credible reproducibility
path, so the answer is rarely "cannot share." Match your situation to a tier.
| Data situation |
Acceptable transparency move |
What to deposit |
| Public file (e.g., NCVS, UCR/NIBRS extracts) |
full open deposit |
data + master script + README |
| NACJD restricted-use |
exemption note + exact application path |
code + synthetic/derived data + access steps |
| Agency / juvenile confidential records |
DUA or confidentiality exemption + contact |
code + simulated data matching schema |
The principle: even when raw data cannot travel, the code and a runnable substitute should. Confirm
the final statement wording against the journal's current submission guidelines.
Worked vignette: a restricted-data statement (illustrative)
A study uses a state juvenile-justice extract that cannot be redistributed. The package ships a master
script regenerating all 8 exhibits; a README documenting construction and the application process
(agency contact, IRB requirement, ~12-week window, illustrative); a synthetic dataset matching the
schema so reviewers can run the script; and seeds for the EM-based trajectory fit. The statement names
the restriction, the legal basis, and the access route — not "available on request."
Transparency-stage referee pushback (with the Criminology fix)
- "'Available on request' is not a path." Fix: name the archive (NACJD/ICPSR) or the agency steps and contact.
- "Code doesn't reproduce Table 3." Fix: one master script regenerates every exhibit; verify before deposit.
- "Restricted data with no way in." Fix: give the access route plus a synthetic substitute.
Output format
【Data-availability statement】drafted to Wiley/current portal wording? [Y/N]
【Reproduces tables/figures?】master script verified locally? [Y/N]
【Documentation】README + provenance + seeds + pinned versions? [Y/N]
【Restricted data?】exemption note + access path (NACJD/agency) + synthetic data?
【Preregistration】lodged + registered vs. exploratory marked? [Y/N/NA]
【Badges】Open Data / Materials / Preregistered targeted if portal offers them? [list / NA]
【Next】crim-review-process
Supplementary resources
1---2name: crim-data-and-transparency3description: Use when preparing the data, replication, and transparency materials for a Criminology (ASC / Wiley) manuscript — data-availability statements, reproducibility packages, preregistration, and handling restricted criminal-justice data under DUAs. Criminology operates under growing open-science norms (Wiley open-science badges, ICPSR/NACJD archiving). Prepares the package; it does not waive requirements.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/crim-data-and-transparency6---78# Data & Transparency (crim-data-and-transparency)910Criminology research increasingly travels with its data and code. Expert reviewers and editors expect11that your reported tables and figures could be reproduced. Wiley's general data-sharing guidance requires12a Data Availability Statement for research- and synthesis-based articles, while the current Wiley ACT row13for *Criminology* lists the journal-specific data-sharing policy field as **No Policy**. Treat that as:14prepare a credible statement and package, but do not claim a journal-specific mandatory repository deposit15unless the live portal requires it.1617## When to trigger1819- Building the reproducibility/replication package and the data-availability statement20- Deciding whether and how to preregister a prospective study21- Working with restricted data (juvenile records, NACJD restricted-use, agency administrative data)22- A reviewer asked how the analysis can be reproduced or the data accessed2324## What to prepare25261. **Data-availability statement.** State where data and code live (e.g., **ICPSR / NACJD**, OSF, a27 Wiley/Dryad repository) or why they cannot be shared. Use Wiley DAS templates and the live portal28 wording; do not imply mandatory deposit where restricted data make that impossible.292. **Reproducibility package.** Data (or synthetic/derived substitutes), a **master script** that30 regenerates every table and figure, a **README** documenting provenance and construction, **seeds**31 for stochastic steps, and **pinned** software/package versions.323. **Preregistration (prospective work).** Lodge a pre-analysis plan (OSF Registries, AsPredicted) and33 mark **registered vs. exploratory** analyses. Wiley ACT currently says *Criminology* does **not**34 accept preprints, so separate preregistration from manuscript preprint posting.354. **Open-science badges.** Wiley offers **Open Data**, **Open Materials**, and **Preregistered** badges36 via the Center for Open Science on participating journals; follow the live submission prompts.3738## Restricted criminal-justice data (common in criminology)3940- **Explain why** the data cannot be shared (juvenile confidentiality, agency/IRB restrictions, DUAs).41- Provide **README instructions on exactly how others obtain it** — the application process, the archive42 (often **NACJD restricted-use**), enclave requirements, and contacts.43- Where feasible, **provide synthetic or de-identified derived data** so the code can be exercised.4445## Build-as-you-go checklist4647- [ ] Data-availability statement drafted to Wiley/current portal wording48- [ ] One **master script** regenerates **every** table and figure from raw/constructed data49- [ ] **README** documents data provenance, construction, and how to reproduce each exhibit50- [ ] **Seeds** set/reported for every stochastic step (bootstrap, RI, EM-based trajectory fits)51- [ ] Software/package **versions pinned** (`renv.lock` / `requirements.txt` / recorded installs)52- [ ] Restricted data: exemption note + access path (NACJD/agency) + synthetic substitute where feasible53- [ ] Preregistration linked (anonymized) where applicable; registered vs. exploratory marked5455## Anti-patterns5657- Treating data/transparency as a post-acceptance afterthought58- A data-availability statement that says "available on request" with no archive or access path59- Depositing code that does not actually reproduce the printed tables/figures60- Claiming data are restricted without giving an access route or synthetic substitute61- Undocumented, un-seeded, unpinned code that "works on my machine"6263## Restricted-data transparency decision table (criminology specifics)6465Criminal-justice data is often restricted — juvenile records, agency systems, NACJD restricted-use66files behind enclaves. The ASC/Wiley open-science direction still expects a *credible reproducibility67path*, so the answer is rarely "cannot share." Match your situation to a tier.6869| Data situation | Acceptable transparency move | What to deposit |70|----------------|------------------------------|-----------------|71| Public file (e.g., NCVS, UCR/NIBRS extracts) | full open deposit | data + master script + README |72| NACJD restricted-use | exemption note + exact application path | code + synthetic/derived data + access steps |73| Agency / juvenile confidential records | DUA or confidentiality exemption + contact | code + simulated data matching schema |7475The principle: even when raw data cannot travel, the *code* and a runnable substitute should. Confirm76the final statement wording against the journal's current submission guidelines.7778## Worked vignette: a restricted-data statement (illustrative)7980A study uses a state juvenile-justice extract that cannot be redistributed. The package ships a master81script regenerating all 8 exhibits; a README documenting construction and the application process82(agency contact, IRB requirement, ~12-week window, illustrative); a synthetic dataset matching the83schema so reviewers can run the script; and seeds for the EM-based trajectory fit. The statement names84the restriction, the legal basis, and the access route — not "available on request."8586## Transparency-stage referee pushback (with the Criminology fix)8788- *"'Available on request' is not a path."* Fix: name the archive (NACJD/ICPSR) or the agency steps and contact.89- *"Code doesn't reproduce Table 3."* Fix: one master script regenerates every exhibit; verify before deposit.90- *"Restricted data with no way in."* Fix: give the access route plus a synthetic substitute.9192## Output format9394```95【Data-availability statement】drafted to Wiley/current portal wording? [Y/N]96【Reproduces tables/figures?】master script verified locally? [Y/N]97【Documentation】README + provenance + seeds + pinned versions? [Y/N]98【Restricted data?】exemption note + access path (NACJD/agency) + synthetic data?99【Preregistration】lodged + registered vs. exploratory marked? [Y/N/NA]100【Badges】Open Data / Materials / Preregistered targeted if portal offers them? [list / NA]101【Next】crim-review-process102```103104## Supplementary resources105106- [`../../resources/external_tools.md`](../../resources/external_tools.md) — ICPSR/NACJD archiving, preregistration, reproducibility tooling107- [`../../resources/official-source-map.md`](../../resources/official-source-map.md) — Wiley DAS guidance, ACT data-policy/preprint fields, and open-badge sources