ICLR Review Process
Use this to plan strategy around ICLR's OpenReview process. Reopen the current Reviewer Guide and
Author Guide before advising on timelines, visibility, or revision permissions.
Process model
- Submissions are reviewed double-blind on OpenReview.
- Reviews evaluate contribution, correctness, empirical/theoretical support, clarity, and value to
the ICLR community.
- Authors can respond in discussion; current-cycle rules determine whether and how revised PDFs or
supplementary files may be uploaded.
- Reviewers may update their recommendations after discussion; ACs synthesize reviews, comments,
and paper fit for the final decision.
- Some comments are public, while others can be restricted by audience. Visibility affects tone,
specificity, and what should be escalated privately.
- Ethics or conduct concerns can move outside ordinary score negotiation.
Author strategy
- Treat the AC as the decision reader. Help them see which objections are resolved and which remain.
- Do not chase every score. Resolve the few issues that change acceptability.
- Use revisions only when they clarify, correct, or support existing claims.
- Keep public comments short, factual, and civil; do not accuse reviewers publicly.
- Use official confidential paths for abusive reviews, severe review defects, conflicts, or suspected
integrity issues.
How public reviews change strategy
ICLR pioneered fully open review: submissions, reviews, scores, author responses, and final
decisions remain on OpenReview permanently, and community members may post comments. This visibility
changes the calculus at every stage.
| Visibility property |
Strategic consequence |
Failure mode it punishes |
| Reviews are public forever |
Reply as if future citers will read it |
Defensive or rude rebuttals |
| Scores are visible |
Address the objection behind the score, not the digit |
Score-haggling that clutters the thread |
| Community can comment |
A "this is just X" post can appear |
Weak novelty framing left unguarded |
| Decisions are archived |
The meta-review must match your final PDF |
Quietly changing claims after acceptance |
Worked vignette
A submission on an alignment objective gets two borderline reviews and one negative. Instead of
arguing all three, the authors identify the one concern the AC will weigh: whether the objective
generalizes beyond the tuned prompt set. They post a public reply with a held-out-prompt table and
upload an allowed revision. One reviewer's updated, still-public review raises the score, and the
AC's meta-review cites the resolved concern.
Reviewer-pushback patterns
- "Reviewer is hostile in public." Stay factual; flag genuine abuse confidentially to the AC.
- "Revision not allowed yet." Check the current cycle's upload window before promising a new PDF.
- "Score did not move." A fixed score can still accept if the AC sees the core objection resolved.
Output format
[Stage] pre-review / reviews released / discussion / final recommendation / decision
[Decision reader] reviewer / AC / SAC / PC
[Best action] reply / revise / provide evidence / escalate / wait
[Visibility] public / restricted / confidential
[Rationale] <why this action fits ICLR process>
1---2name: iclr-review-process3description: Use when explaining or planning around the ICLR review process, including OpenReview public review, AC/SAC roles, reviewer questions, discussion, revisions, final recommendations, and ethics escalation. Use when deciding whether to reply publicly or privately, how a permanently visible review thread shapes strategy, when to upload an allowed revision, or when to escalate a defective review to the AC for the current cycle.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/iclr-review-process6---78# ICLR Review Process910Use this to plan strategy around ICLR's OpenReview process. Reopen the current Reviewer Guide and11Author Guide before advising on timelines, visibility, or revision permissions.1213## Process model1415- Submissions are reviewed double-blind on OpenReview.16- Reviews evaluate contribution, correctness, empirical/theoretical support, clarity, and value to17 the ICLR community.18- Authors can respond in discussion; current-cycle rules determine whether and how revised PDFs or19 supplementary files may be uploaded.20- Reviewers may update their recommendations after discussion; ACs synthesize reviews, comments,21 and paper fit for the final decision.22- Some comments are public, while others can be restricted by audience. Visibility affects tone,23 specificity, and what should be escalated privately.24- Ethics or conduct concerns can move outside ordinary score negotiation.2526## Author strategy2728- Treat the AC as the decision reader. Help them see which objections are resolved and which remain.29- Do not chase every score. Resolve the few issues that change acceptability.30- Use revisions only when they clarify, correct, or support existing claims.31- Keep public comments short, factual, and civil; do not accuse reviewers publicly.32- Use official confidential paths for abusive reviews, severe review defects, conflicts, or suspected33 integrity issues.3435## How public reviews change strategy3637ICLR pioneered fully open review: submissions, reviews, scores, author responses, and final38decisions remain on OpenReview permanently, and community members may post comments. This visibility39changes the calculus at every stage.4041| Visibility property | Strategic consequence | Failure mode it punishes |42| --- | --- | --- |43| Reviews are public forever | Reply as if future citers will read it | Defensive or rude rebuttals |44| Scores are visible | Address the objection behind the score, not the digit | Score-haggling that clutters the thread |45| Community can comment | A "this is just X" post can appear | Weak novelty framing left unguarded |46| Decisions are archived | The meta-review must match your final PDF | Quietly changing claims after acceptance |4748## Worked vignette4950A submission on an alignment objective gets two borderline reviews and one negative. Instead of51arguing all three, the authors identify the one concern the AC will weigh: whether the objective52generalizes beyond the tuned prompt set. They post a public reply with a held-out-prompt table and53upload an allowed revision. One reviewer's updated, still-public review raises the score, and the54AC's meta-review cites the resolved concern.5556## Reviewer-pushback patterns5758- "Reviewer is hostile in public." Stay factual; flag genuine abuse confidentially to the AC.59- "Revision not allowed yet." Check the current cycle's upload window before promising a new PDF.60- "Score did not move." A fixed score can still accept if the AC sees the core objection resolved.6162## Output format6364```text65[Stage] pre-review / reviews released / discussion / final recommendation / decision66[Decision reader] reviewer / AC / SAC / PC67[Best action] reply / revise / provide evidence / escalate / wait68[Visibility] public / restricted / confidential69[Rationale] <why this action fits ICLR process>70```71