Sources & Evidence (jaar-sources-and-evidence)
Religious-studies scholarship rests on primary materials: scriptures and commentaries, ritual and
liturgical texts, historical archives, material and visual culture, or fieldwork. JAAR judges whether
your handling of these sources is careful, well-situated, and adequate to the claim. This is humanities
evidence — no datasets or replication, but rigor still governs.
When to trigger
- Selecting and justifying the primary sources the argument rests on
- A reviewer questioned your translation, dating, provenance, or representativeness
- Integrating fieldwork/interviews into a humanities argument
- Deciding what is primary vs. secondary and how much to quote
Source-work standards JAAR expects
- Cite from primary sources. Ground claims in the texts/traditions/objects themselves, not only in
others' summaries; secondary literature situates, primary evidence proves.
- Languages and translation. Work from originals where the argument depends on wording; state which
edition/translation you use and why; flag contested terms (and consider transliteration conventions).
- Provenance, dating, and context. Establish what a source is, when/where it comes from, and its
genre — a claim is only as strong as the source's status supports.
- Representativeness and selection. Be explicit about why these sources/cases; do not generalize a
tradition from one atypical text without saying so.
- Fieldwork/ethnography. Describe access, consent, and positionality; protect interlocutors;
represent them fairly (this connects to
jaar-theory-and-method reflexivity).
- Disconfirming evidence. Engage sources that cut against the thesis rather than omitting them.
Quoting and apparatus
- Quote enough to let the reader see the evidence, not so much that the essay becomes a source-reader.
- Translations: provide the original where the argument turns on it; note translator.
- Images/material culture: secure permissions if reproduced; describe what the reader cannot see.
Anti-patterns
- Building a claim only on secondary summaries of primary texts
- Cherry-picking passages and ignoring counter-evidence in the same corpus
- Generalizing a whole tradition from one unrepresentative source
- Silent reliance on a translation when the argument depends on the original wording
- Ethnographic claims with no account of access, consent, or positionality
Output format
【Primary sources】what they are + why these
【Languages/editions】originals vs translations; contested terms flagged
【Provenance/context】dating, genre, status established?
【Selection/representativeness】justified? atypical cases flagged?
【Fieldwork (if any)】access, consent, positionality handled?
【Counter-evidence】engaged, not omitted?
【Next】jaar-theory-and-method
Evidence-type rigor matrix
JAAR articles run on radically different evidence — a Sanskrit manuscript, a colonial archive, a temple
relief, a set of interviews — and a referee for the AAR/Oxford University Press flagship will judge each
by its own craft standard. Identify your dominant evidence type and meet the column that governs it.
| Evidence type |
What a JAAR referee scrutinizes |
Easy disqualifier |
| Scriptural / commentarial text |
Edition, recension, language of access |
Translation quoted where wording carries the claim |
| Historical archive |
Provenance, dating, the document's genre and bias |
A polemical source read as neutral report |
| Material / visual culture |
Object description, context of use, permissions |
Iconographic claims with no image |
| Ethnographic fieldwork |
Access, consent, positionality, fair representation |
Generalizing from a few interlocutors |
| Comparative corpus |
Why these cases; commensurability |
Cherry-picked exemplars that flatter the thesis |
Worked vignette: an over-reaching textual claim, right-sized
An author argues that "Sufi poetry rejects legalism," quoting Rumi in a popular translation. A JAAR
reader will resist on source grounds:
- Cite from the primary source. The claim turns on wording, so the author moves to the Persian,
names the edition, and notes where the popular translation smooths a key term.
- Representativeness. One poet's verses cannot stand for "Sufi poetry"; the author narrows the
claim to the corpus actually examined, or flags the case as illustrative.
- Disconfirming evidence. The author engages Sufi texts that uphold sharī'a rather than omitting
them, converting an over-claim into a defensible, bounded reading (with apparatus discipline that
dovetails with
jaar-citation-and-style).
Source-handling pushback → the fix
- "You read translations as if they were the text" → supply the original; note edition and translator.
- "One case, whole-tradition claim" → narrow the claim or justify the selection.
- "Where is the consent / positionality account?" → add all three.
Hedged calibration: as a humanities venue JAAR has no datasets, statistics, or replication archive —
rigor is sourcing rigor, not reproducibility. Specific permissions practice for reproduced images and
any data-availability language for fieldwork-based work should be confirmed against the journal's
current submission guidelines, which can change with publisher policy.
Supplementary resources
1---2name: jaar-sources-and-evidence3description: Use when handling the evidence base of a Journal of the American Academy of Religion (JAAR) article — primary texts, traditions, historical documents, material/visual sources, or ethnographic fieldwork. Plans rigorous, transparent source work for humanities scholarship in the study of religion; it does not run statistics.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/jaar-sources-and-evidence6---78# Sources & Evidence (jaar-sources-and-evidence)910Religious-studies scholarship rests on **primary materials**: scriptures and commentaries, ritual and11liturgical texts, historical archives, material and visual culture, or fieldwork. JAAR judges whether12your handling of these sources is careful, well-situated, and adequate to the claim. This is humanities13evidence — no datasets or replication, but rigor still governs.1415## When to trigger1617- Selecting and justifying the primary sources the argument rests on18- A reviewer questioned your translation, dating, provenance, or representativeness19- Integrating fieldwork/interviews into a humanities argument20- Deciding what is primary vs. secondary and how much to quote2122## Source-work standards JAAR expects23241. **Cite from primary sources.** Ground claims in the texts/traditions/objects themselves, not only in25 others' summaries; secondary literature situates, primary evidence proves.262. **Languages and translation.** Work from originals where the argument depends on wording; state which27 edition/translation you use and why; flag contested terms (and consider transliteration conventions).283. **Provenance, dating, and context.** Establish what a source is, when/where it comes from, and its29 genre — a claim is only as strong as the source's status supports.304. **Representativeness and selection.** Be explicit about why these sources/cases; do not generalize a31 tradition from one atypical text without saying so.325. **Fieldwork/ethnography.** Describe access, consent, and positionality; protect interlocutors;33 represent them fairly (this connects to `jaar-theory-and-method` reflexivity).346. **Disconfirming evidence.** Engage sources that cut against the thesis rather than omitting them.3536## Quoting and apparatus3738- Quote enough to let the reader see the evidence, not so much that the essay becomes a source-reader.39- Translations: provide the original where the argument turns on it; note translator.40- Images/material culture: secure permissions if reproduced; describe what the reader cannot see.4142## Anti-patterns4344- Building a claim only on secondary summaries of primary texts45- Cherry-picking passages and ignoring counter-evidence in the same corpus46- Generalizing a whole tradition from one unrepresentative source47- Silent reliance on a translation when the argument depends on the original wording48- Ethnographic claims with no account of access, consent, or positionality4950## Output format5152```53【Primary sources】what they are + why these54【Languages/editions】originals vs translations; contested terms flagged55【Provenance/context】dating, genre, status established?56【Selection/representativeness】justified? atypical cases flagged?57【Fieldwork (if any)】access, consent, positionality handled?58【Counter-evidence】engaged, not omitted?59【Next】jaar-theory-and-method60```6162## Evidence-type rigor matrix6364JAAR articles run on radically different evidence — a Sanskrit manuscript, a colonial archive, a temple65relief, a set of interviews — and a referee for the AAR/Oxford University Press flagship will judge each66by its own craft standard. Identify your dominant evidence type and meet the column that governs it.6768| Evidence type | What a JAAR referee scrutinizes | Easy disqualifier |69|---------------|--------------------------------|-------------------|70| Scriptural / commentarial text | Edition, recension, language of access | Translation quoted where wording carries the claim |71| Historical archive | Provenance, dating, the document's genre and bias | A polemical source read as neutral report |72| Material / visual culture | Object description, context of use, permissions | Iconographic claims with no image |73| Ethnographic fieldwork | Access, consent, positionality, fair representation | Generalizing from a few interlocutors |74| Comparative corpus | Why these cases; commensurability | Cherry-picked exemplars that flatter the thesis |7576## Worked vignette: an over-reaching textual claim, right-sized7778An author argues that "Sufi poetry rejects legalism," quoting Rumi in a popular translation. A JAAR79reader will resist on source grounds:8081- **Cite from the primary source.** The claim turns on wording, so the author moves to the Persian,82 names the edition, and notes where the popular translation smooths a key term.83- **Representativeness.** One poet's verses cannot stand for "Sufi poetry"; the author narrows the84 claim to the corpus actually examined, or flags the case as illustrative.85- **Disconfirming evidence.** The author engages Sufi texts that uphold *sharī'a* rather than omitting86 them, converting an over-claim into a defensible, bounded reading (with apparatus discipline that87 dovetails with `jaar-citation-and-style`).8889## Source-handling pushback → the fix9091- "You read translations as if they were the text" → supply the original; note edition and translator.92- "One case, whole-tradition claim" → narrow the claim or justify the selection.93- "Where is the consent / positionality account?" → add all three.9495Hedged calibration: as a humanities venue JAAR has no datasets, statistics, or replication archive —96rigor is sourcing rigor, not reproducibility. Specific permissions practice for reproduced images and97any data-availability language for fieldwork-based work should be confirmed against the journal's98current submission guidelines, which can change with publisher policy.99100## Supplementary resources101102- [`../../resources/external_tools.md`](../../resources/external_tools.md) — primary-source databases and tools for the study of religion103- [`../../resources/official-source-map.md`](../../resources/official-source-map.md) — JAAR scope across traditions and methods