Referee Strategy (jacs-referee-strategy)
When to trigger
- You are choosing suggested and excluded reviewers for Paragon Plus
- You want to anticipate and disarm objections before submission
- You are stress-testing the manuscript as a skeptical referee would
- A revision is coming and you want to predict reviewer concerns
Choosing reviewers
- Suggested: independent experts who can judge the chemistry — across the
relevant subfields (e.g., a synthesis expert and a mechanism/spectroscopy
expert for a catalysis paper). No collaborators, advisors, or same-institution.
- Breadth coverage: because JACS is broad-scope, include at least one
reviewer who can speak to the general-interest claim, not only the niche.
- Excluded: only with a brief, professional reason (direct competitor with a
conflict, prior dispute). Keep the list short and credible.
Pre-empting the standard JACS objections
Referees at JACS predictably probe rigor and significance. Address each before
they raise it:
| Likely objection |
Pre-empt by |
| "Not broad enough for JACS" |
Lead with the breadth driver; cite cross-field relevance |
| "Compound X is not fully characterized" |
Complete SI characterization + purity for every compound |
| "Purity not demonstrated" |
EA or HPLC/GC trace + clean NMR for key compounds |
| "Mechanism is speculative" |
Add controls, kinetics, KIE, or labeling; soften unproven steps |
| "Scope is cherry-picked" |
Report failed substrates; show functional-group tolerance |
| "Selectivity claim unsupported" |
Provide ee/dr with method and racemate/standard traces |
| "Crystal structure not deposited" |
CCDC number + checkCIF-clean CIF |
| "Yields/conditions not reproducible" |
Procedures with scale/equiv; replicate key results |
| "Over-claimed novelty" |
State closest prior art and the specific delta |
Reviewer-simulation pass
Read the manuscript once as a hostile referee and write the three harshest
defensible criticisms. For each, decide: (a) fix now with data, (b) soften the
claim, or (c) prepare a rebuttal point. Carry these into jacs-revision.
Checklist
Anti-patterns
- Suggesting friends/collaborators as reviewers (editors notice)
- Excluding everyone competent under vague "competitor" claims
- Ignoring an obvious rigor gap and hoping a referee misses it
- Leaving an over-claim in place that a referee will seize on
- No breadth-competent reviewer for a paper whose pitch is broad interest
Operating pass for Journal of the American Chemical Society
Treat this skill as an executable review pass, not a prose hint. First lock the chemical novelty, characterization chain, controls, and scope or mechanism evidence; then judge whether the current manuscript answers the venue's real reader: chemistry reviewers who expect a molecule/material/reaction claim to be supported by rigorous characterization and mechanistic insight.
- Do the pass: Return a claim-evidence-risk ledger rather than a prose-only diagnosis; every recommendation must point to a manuscript location or missing artifact.
- Return a ledger: give
claim / evidence / risk / manuscript location rows, so the next agent can edit rather than rediscover the issue.
- Sibling guard: compare against ACS Central Science for broad conceptual reach, Angewandte for communication style, specialized ACS journals for narrower chemistry; if a sibling owns the contribution, recommend re-routing before polishing format.
- Stop condition: do not give submission-ready advice until the pack's
resources/official-source-map.md has been checked for volatile rules and the manuscript has one concrete fix for the largest venue-specific risk.
Output format
【Suggested】names/areas: synthesis [..], mechanism [..], breadth [..]
【Excluded】name — reason (brief)
【Objections pre-empted】[...]; planned rebuttals: [...]
【Top-3 hostile criticisms】1) ... 2) ... 3) ...
【Actions】fix-now: [...]; soften: [...]
【Next】jacs-submission (suggestions) → jacs-revision (after decision)
Related resources
1---2name: jacs-referee-strategy3description: Use when suggesting/excluding reviewers and pre-empting likely referee objections for a Journal of the American Chemical Society (JACS) manuscript. Plans the review-facing strategy — it does not run experiments or write the paper.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/jacs-referee-strategy6---78# Referee Strategy (jacs-referee-strategy)910## When to trigger1112- You are choosing suggested and excluded reviewers for Paragon Plus13- You want to anticipate and disarm objections before submission14- You are stress-testing the manuscript as a skeptical referee would15- A revision is coming and you want to predict reviewer concerns1617## Choosing reviewers1819- **Suggested:** independent experts who can judge the chemistry — across the20 relevant subfields (e.g., a synthesis expert *and* a mechanism/spectroscopy21 expert for a catalysis paper). No collaborators, advisors, or same-institution.22- **Breadth coverage:** because JACS is broad-scope, include at least one23 reviewer who can speak to the general-interest claim, not only the niche.24- **Excluded:** only with a brief, professional reason (direct competitor with a25 conflict, prior dispute). Keep the list short and credible.2627## Pre-empting the standard JACS objections2829Referees at JACS predictably probe rigor and significance. Address each before30they raise it:3132| Likely objection | Pre-empt by |33|------------------|-------------|34| "Not broad enough for JACS" | Lead with the breadth driver; cite cross-field relevance |35| "Compound X is not fully characterized" | Complete SI characterization + purity for every compound |36| "Purity not demonstrated" | EA or HPLC/GC trace + clean NMR for key compounds |37| "Mechanism is speculative" | Add controls, kinetics, KIE, or labeling; soften unproven steps |38| "Scope is cherry-picked" | Report failed substrates; show functional-group tolerance |39| "Selectivity claim unsupported" | Provide ee/dr with method and racemate/standard traces |40| "Crystal structure not deposited" | CCDC number + checkCIF-clean CIF |41| "Yields/conditions not reproducible" | Procedures with scale/equiv; replicate key results |42| "Over-claimed novelty" | State closest prior art and the specific delta |4344## Reviewer-simulation pass4546Read the manuscript once as a hostile referee and write the three harshest47defensible criticisms. For each, decide: (a) fix now with data, (b) soften the48claim, or (c) prepare a rebuttal point. Carry these into `jacs-revision`.4950## Checklist5152- [ ] Suggested reviewers are independent and cover the needed expertise + breadth53- [ ] Excluded reviewers (if any) have a brief, professional justification54- [ ] Each standard objection above is addressed or has a planned response55- [ ] The three harshest defensible criticisms are written down56- [ ] Unproven claims are softened in language before submission57- [ ] Prior-art delta is explicit, pre-empting "incremental" charges5859## Anti-patterns6061- Suggesting friends/collaborators as reviewers (editors notice)62- Excluding everyone competent under vague "competitor" claims63- Ignoring an obvious rigor gap and hoping a referee misses it64- Leaving an over-claim in place that a referee will seize on65- No breadth-competent reviewer for a paper whose pitch is broad interest666768## Operating pass for Journal of the American Chemical Society6970Treat this skill as an executable review pass, not a prose hint. First lock the chemical novelty, characterization chain, controls, and scope or mechanism evidence; then judge whether the current manuscript answers the venue's real reader: chemistry reviewers who expect a molecule/material/reaction claim to be supported by rigorous characterization and mechanistic insight.7172- **Do the pass:** Return a claim-evidence-risk ledger rather than a prose-only diagnosis; every recommendation must point to a manuscript location or missing artifact.73- **Return a ledger:** give `claim / evidence / risk / manuscript location` rows, so the next agent can edit rather than rediscover the issue.74- **Sibling guard:** compare against ACS Central Science for broad conceptual reach, Angewandte for communication style, specialized ACS journals for narrower chemistry; if a sibling owns the contribution, recommend re-routing before polishing format.75- **Stop condition:** do not give submission-ready advice until the pack's `resources/official-source-map.md` has been checked for volatile rules and the manuscript has one concrete fix for the largest venue-specific risk.7677## Output format7879```80【Suggested】names/areas: synthesis [..], mechanism [..], breadth [..]81【Excluded】name — reason (brief)82【Objections pre-empted】[...]; planned rebuttals: [...]83【Top-3 hostile criticisms】1) ... 2) ... 3) ...84【Actions】fix-now: [...]; soften: [...]85【Next】jacs-submission (suggestions) → jacs-revision (after decision)86```8788## Related resources8990- [`jacs-cover-letter`](../jacs-cover-letter/SKILL.md) — where suggested/excluded reviewers are noted91- [`jacs-methods`](../jacs-methods/SKILL.md) — closing the rigor gaps referees probe