JME Workflow Router (jme-workflow)
Overview
This is the router. It does not replace any specialized skill. It tells you which jme- skill to use at the current stage* of a manuscript aimed at the Journal of Monetary Economics (JME).
Default assumption: unless told otherwise, treat the target as JME — Elsevier's leading outlet for monetary economics and macroeconomics broadly defined (monetary theory and policy, central banking, business cycles, growth, financial intermediation, fiscal interactions, expectations), in both quantitative/DSGE and empirical/applied-policy modes. Operational tells you are at JME and not a generic top econ journal: submission via Elsevier Editorial Manager (editorialmanager.com/monec/); a US$350 fee (US$200 for full-time PhD students) charged up front (no fee on resubmission; half refunded on a direct return); single anonymized (single-blind) review with at least two reviewers; the distinctive "up or out" first-revision rule and the ~50% publication-likelihood threshold for an R&R; a strict 40-page / ≤10 tables-and-figures cap on accepted papers; a 100-word abstract that may not begin with "This paper" or "We"; and the annual Carnegie-Rochester-NYU Conference Series on Public Policy issue. Editors are S. Borağan Aruoba (Maryland) and Eric Swanson (UC Irvine). Re-verify volatile specifics on the official page.
When to trigger
- The user asks "what should I do next?"
- The user hands over a draft and needs the current bottleneck diagnosed
- Work is ping-ponging between the model, the empirics, writing, and the response letter
- A JME decision letter arrived (reject / revise-and-resubmit) and the user needs to switch modes
Routing table
| Current symptom |
Next skill |
| Idea feels narrow / unclear fit with monetary-macro scope |
jme-topic-selection |
| Contribution relative to the monetary-macro literature is fuzzy |
jme-literature-positioning |
| The "what's new / why it matters for policy" pitch is undersold |
jme-contribution-framing |
| Causal/structural identification of the shock or mechanism is undefended |
jme-identification-strategy |
| VAR/LP/DSGE estimation or moments need stress-testing |
jme-data-analysis |
| Too many exhibits for the 10-table-and-figure cap; IRFs unclear |
jme-tables-figures |
| Prose buries the result; abstract begins with "This paper"/"We" |
jme-writing-style |
| Need the ScienceDirect/Mendeley deposit + AI declaration ready |
jme-replication-and-data-policy |
| Want to understand single-blind review, two-referee, "up or out" |
jme-review-process |
| Ready to submit via Editorial Manager; need the fee + 40-page preflight |
jme-submission |
| Received an R&R; the resubmission is "up or out" |
jme-rebuttal |
Default order
jme-topic-selection — confirm a first-order monetary/macro question and JME fit
jme-literature-positioning — stake the contribution against the frontier
jme-contribution-framing — sharpen the "what's new + policy lesson" claim
jme-identification-strategy — make the shock/mechanism identification credible
jme-data-analysis — VAR / local projections / DSGE estimation and robustness
jme-tables-figures — fit IRFs and tables under the ≤10 cap, online appendix for the rest
jme-writing-style — JME house style; 100-word abstract; author-date references
jme-replication-and-data-policy — ScienceDirect/Mendeley deposit + AI declaration
jme-review-process — understand single-blind, two-referee, "up or out", 50% threshold
jme-submission — Editorial Manager preflight (fee, 40 pages, line numbers, JEL codes)
jme-rebuttal — after the R&R (the resubmission must end in accept or reject)
jme-writing-style is a late-stage polish. Do not rewrite the intro before the model and identification are settled — the argument will change.
Decision shortcuts
- "Is my question monetary-macro enough for JME?" →
jme-topic-selection
- "My TWFE/VAR shock is not really identified" →
jme-identification-strategy
- "Should I report VAR and local projections?" →
jme-data-analysis
- "I have 14 figures" →
jme-tables-figures
- "My abstract starts with 'We'" →
jme-writing-style
- "Editor may require my Dynare code" →
jme-replication-and-data-policy
- "Submitting tomorrow; do I pay the fee now?" →
jme-submission
- "Got an R&R — what does 'up or out' mean for me?" →
jme-rebuttal
Routing snapshot (copy, fill, keep at the top of the working notes)
JME MANUSCRIPT ROUTING SNAPSHOT
================================================================
Venue : Journal of Monetary Economics (Elsevier)
Portal : Editorial Manager — editorialmanager.com/monec/
Editors : S. Borağan Aruoba (Maryland) | Eric Swanson (UC Irvine)
Issue track : [ ] regular [ ] Carnegie-Rochester-NYU policy issue
Review model : single-blind, at least two referees
Revision rule : first revision is "up or out" — resubmission ends in
accept or reject; R&R only if publication likelihood
is judged roughly >= 50%
STAGE GATES — mark exactly one line CURRENT
[ ] G1 scope question is aggregate/monetary ... jme-topic-selection
[ ] G2 positioning frontier delta staked .......... jme-literature-positioning
[ ] G3 framing "new + policy lesson" pitched .. jme-contribution-framing
[ ] G4 identification shock/mechanism defended .... jme-identification-strategy
[ ] G5 estimation VAR/LP/DSGE stress-tested ...... jme-data-analysis
[ ] G6 exhibits IRFs/tables fit the cap ........ jme-tables-figures
[ ] G7 prose house style applied ............ jme-writing-style
[ ] G8 deposit replication package staged ..... jme-replication-and-data-policy
[ ] G9 process review rules understood ........ jme-review-process
[ ] G10 submission Editorial Manager preflight .... jme-submission
[ ] G11 rebuttal up-or-out response drafted ..... jme-rebuttal
SUBMISSION PREFLIGHT (all must be Y before G10 closes)
[ ] Abstract <= 100 words; does NOT begin with "This paper" or "We"
[ ] Text + references + footnotes <= 40 pages (accepted-paper cap;
online supplement exempt)
[ ] Tables + figures combined <= 10
[ ] Submission fee ready: US$350 (US$200 full-time PhD students),
paid up front; no fee on resubmission
[ ] Generative-AI declaration included per Elsevier policy
BLOCKER LOG
- current bottleneck : ______________________________________
- routed sub-skill : jme-__________________________________
- unverified fact to re-check on the official page: __________
Re-fill the snapshot after every decision letter: a reject closes the file; an R&R moves CURRENT straight to G11 with the up-or-out clock running.
Anti-patterns
- Do not skip
jme-literature-positioning and jump to estimation — referees judge the contribution first
- Do not polish exhibits while the shock identification or model is still shaky
- Do not treat the 40-page / ≤10 exhibit cap as a final-stage edit — design for it from the start
- Do not let
jme-rebuttal draft the response before the revised manuscript exists — and remember the resubmission is up or out, not another R&R round
1---2name: jme-workflow3description: Use when deciding which jme-* sub-skill to invoke next, or when sequencing manuscript work from topic selection through the "up or out" rebuttal for a Journal of Monetary Economics (JME) submission. Routes — it does not replace — the specialized skills.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/jme-workflow6---78# JME Workflow Router (jme-workflow)910## Overview1112This is the router. It does not replace any specialized skill. It tells you **which jme-* skill to use at the current stage** of a manuscript aimed at the *Journal of Monetary Economics* (JME).1314Default assumption: unless told otherwise, treat the target as JME — Elsevier's leading outlet for **monetary economics and macroeconomics broadly defined** (monetary theory and policy, central banking, business cycles, growth, financial intermediation, fiscal interactions, expectations), in both quantitative/DSGE and empirical/applied-policy modes. Operational tells you are at JME and not a generic top econ journal: submission via **Elsevier Editorial Manager** (`editorialmanager.com/monec/`); a **US$350 fee** (US$200 for full-time PhD students) charged **up front** (no fee on resubmission; half refunded on a direct return); **single anonymized** (single-blind) review with at least two reviewers; the distinctive **"up or out" first-revision rule** and the **~50% publication-likelihood threshold** for an R&R; a strict **40-page / ≤10 tables-and-figures** cap on accepted papers; a **100-word abstract** that may not begin with "This paper" or "We"; and the annual **Carnegie-Rochester-NYU Conference Series on Public Policy** issue. Editors are S. Borağan Aruoba (Maryland) and Eric Swanson (UC Irvine). Re-verify volatile specifics on the official page.1516## When to trigger1718- The user asks "what should I do next?"19- The user hands over a draft and needs the current bottleneck diagnosed20- Work is ping-ponging between the model, the empirics, writing, and the response letter21- A JME decision letter arrived (reject / revise-and-resubmit) and the user needs to switch modes2223## Routing table2425| Current symptom | Next skill |26|--------------------------------------------------------------------------|----------------------------------|27| Idea feels narrow / unclear fit with monetary-macro scope | `jme-topic-selection` |28| Contribution relative to the monetary-macro literature is fuzzy | `jme-literature-positioning` |29| The "what's new / why it matters for policy" pitch is undersold | `jme-contribution-framing` |30| Causal/structural identification of the shock or mechanism is undefended | `jme-identification-strategy` |31| VAR/LP/DSGE estimation or moments need stress-testing | `jme-data-analysis` |32| Too many exhibits for the 10-table-and-figure cap; IRFs unclear | `jme-tables-figures` |33| Prose buries the result; abstract begins with "This paper"/"We" | `jme-writing-style` |34| Need the ScienceDirect/Mendeley deposit + AI declaration ready | `jme-replication-and-data-policy`|35| Want to understand single-blind review, two-referee, "up or out" | `jme-review-process` |36| Ready to submit via Editorial Manager; need the fee + 40-page preflight | `jme-submission` |37| Received an R&R; the resubmission is "up or out" | `jme-rebuttal` |3839## Default order40411. `jme-topic-selection` — confirm a first-order monetary/macro question and JME fit422. `jme-literature-positioning` — stake the contribution against the frontier433. `jme-contribution-framing` — sharpen the "what's new + policy lesson" claim444. `jme-identification-strategy` — make the shock/mechanism identification credible455. `jme-data-analysis` — VAR / local projections / DSGE estimation and robustness466. `jme-tables-figures` — fit IRFs and tables under the ≤10 cap, online appendix for the rest477. `jme-writing-style` — JME house style; 100-word abstract; author-date references488. `jme-replication-and-data-policy` — ScienceDirect/Mendeley deposit + AI declaration499. `jme-review-process` — understand single-blind, two-referee, "up or out", 50% threshold5010. `jme-submission` — Editorial Manager preflight (fee, 40 pages, line numbers, JEL codes)5111. `jme-rebuttal` — after the R&R (the resubmission must end in accept or reject)5253> `jme-writing-style` is a late-stage polish. Do not rewrite the intro before the model and identification are settled — the argument will change.5455## Decision shortcuts5657- "Is my question monetary-macro enough for JME?" → `jme-topic-selection`58- "My TWFE/VAR shock is not really identified" → `jme-identification-strategy`59- "Should I report VAR and local projections?" → `jme-data-analysis`60- "I have 14 figures" → `jme-tables-figures`61- "My abstract starts with 'We'" → `jme-writing-style`62- "Editor may require my Dynare code" → `jme-replication-and-data-policy`63- "Submitting tomorrow; do I pay the fee now?" → `jme-submission`64- "Got an R&R — what does 'up or out' mean for me?" → `jme-rebuttal`6566## Routing snapshot (copy, fill, keep at the top of the working notes)6768```text69JME MANUSCRIPT ROUTING SNAPSHOT70================================================================71Venue : Journal of Monetary Economics (Elsevier)72Portal : Editorial Manager — editorialmanager.com/monec/73Editors : S. Borağan Aruoba (Maryland) | Eric Swanson (UC Irvine)74Issue track : [ ] regular [ ] Carnegie-Rochester-NYU policy issue75Review model : single-blind, at least two referees76Revision rule : first revision is "up or out" — resubmission ends in77 accept or reject; R&R only if publication likelihood78 is judged roughly >= 50%7980STAGE GATES — mark exactly one line CURRENT81[ ] G1 scope question is aggregate/monetary ... jme-topic-selection82[ ] G2 positioning frontier delta staked .......... jme-literature-positioning83[ ] G3 framing "new + policy lesson" pitched .. jme-contribution-framing84[ ] G4 identification shock/mechanism defended .... jme-identification-strategy85[ ] G5 estimation VAR/LP/DSGE stress-tested ...... jme-data-analysis86[ ] G6 exhibits IRFs/tables fit the cap ........ jme-tables-figures87[ ] G7 prose house style applied ............ jme-writing-style88[ ] G8 deposit replication package staged ..... jme-replication-and-data-policy89[ ] G9 process review rules understood ........ jme-review-process90[ ] G10 submission Editorial Manager preflight .... jme-submission91[ ] G11 rebuttal up-or-out response drafted ..... jme-rebuttal9293SUBMISSION PREFLIGHT (all must be Y before G10 closes)94[ ] Abstract <= 100 words; does NOT begin with "This paper" or "We"95[ ] Text + references + footnotes <= 40 pages (accepted-paper cap;96 online supplement exempt)97[ ] Tables + figures combined <= 1098[ ] Submission fee ready: US$350 (US$200 full-time PhD students),99 paid up front; no fee on resubmission100[ ] Generative-AI declaration included per Elsevier policy101102BLOCKER LOG103- current bottleneck : ______________________________________104- routed sub-skill : jme-__________________________________105- unverified fact to re-check on the official page: __________106```107108Re-fill the snapshot after every decision letter: a reject closes the file; an R&R moves CURRENT straight to G11 with the up-or-out clock running.109110## Anti-patterns111112- **Do not** skip `jme-literature-positioning` and jump to estimation — referees judge the contribution first113- **Do not** polish exhibits while the shock identification or model is still shaky114- **Do not** treat the **40-page / ≤10 exhibit** cap as a final-stage edit — design for it from the start115- **Do not** let `jme-rebuttal` draft the response before the revised manuscript exists — and remember the resubmission is **up or out**, not another R&R round