Tables & Figures (jppm-tables-figures)
When to trigger
- Tables report coefficients an academic can parse but a policy reader cannot
- The evaluation has no event-study figure showing pre-trends and dynamics
- Subgroup results for vulnerable populations are scattered across prose
- The tested label/warning/disclosure stimuli are described but never shown
- The 50-page all-inclusive cap forces you to choose which exhibits survive
Exhibits for a dual audience
JPP&M exhibits are read by two audiences at once: methods-literate reviewers who will interrogate the identification, and policy-oriented readers (including practitioners on the editorial board) who need the decision-relevant magnitude at a glance. Every exhibit should therefore carry two layers: the estimation detail (specification, SEs, clustering, N) in the table body and notes, and a decision-unit translation — percentage points, dollars, calories, share of consumers — in the headline row, figure annotation, or note. Because the 50-page limit includes tables and figures at every review stage, each exhibit must displace prose, not duplicate it; move the long battery to a web appendix.
The high-value JPP&M exhibits
| Exhibit |
What it must carry |
Typical failure |
| Stimuli figure |
the actual tested labels/disclosures side by side, at realistic scale |
describing formats in prose a regulator would need to see |
| Event-study figure |
pre-period placebos + dynamic effects, CI band, policy date marked |
showing only the post-period average |
| DiD table |
group-time ATT, estimator named, cluster level, pre-trend sensitivity row |
plain TWFE with stars and no diagnostics |
| RDD figure |
binned outcomes + fit on both sides, bandwidth noted; density plot nearby |
a fitted line with no raw data visible |
| Condition-contrast table |
means/effects per policy option with the pairwise contrast the decision needs |
omnibus F with no decision-mapped contrasts |
| Subgroup forest plot |
pre-specified vulnerable-group effects with corrected CIs on one axis |
significant splits in text, the rest invisible |
| Policy-translation table |
effect × exposed population = market magnitude, with assumptions listed |
leaving the rescaling to the reader |
A stimuli figure is uniquely load-bearing at this journal: agencies regulate formats, so reviewers want to see exactly what was tested and whether it is mandatable.
House conventions (AMA journals)
- Follow the AMA journals style shared across JM/JMR/JPP&M: numbered tables and figures, descriptive titles, notes defining every abbreviation, references and tables may be single-spaced while text is double-spaced (per the AMA submission guidelines — re-check current specifics on ama.org before formatting).
- Report effect sizes and confidence intervals; stars alone do not survive review.
- State the estimator, clustering level, and fixed effects in each table's note so the exhibit stands alone.
- Keep Ns visible (per cell / per group-time), including before/after exclusions.
- Figures must survive grayscale print and small reproduction — policy briefs will screenshot them.
Economy under the 50-page cap
- Budget exhibits first: typically 1 stimuli figure, 1 identification figure, 2–3 core tables, 1 subgroup display in the body; everything else to the web appendix.
- Merge robustness variants into a single compact multi-column table rather than serial near-duplicates.
- Never present the same estimate as both table and figure; pick the form the decision reader needs.
Checklist
Anti-patterns
- Coefficient wall: a 12-column regression table with no translated magnitude anywhere
- Invisible stimuli: regulating formats the reader never gets to see
- Post-only plots: dynamics figures that start at the policy date
- Star tables: significance markers standing in for effect sizes and CIs
- Subgroup scatter: heterogeneity sprinkled through prose instead of one comparable display
- Cap blindness: ten body exhibits that force the text out of the 50-page envelope
Output format
【Exhibit budget】body tables/figures list vs. web-appendix list (within 50-page cap)
【Stimuli figure】tested formats shown at scale? [Y/N]
【Identification display】event-study / RDD / placebo figure with pre-period evidence? [Y/N]
【Decision-unit layer】each body exhibit translated for the policy reader? [Y/N]
【Notes discipline】estimator, clustering, Ns, abbreviations in every note? [Y/N]
【Next skill】jppm-writing-style
1---2name: jppm-tables-figures3description: Use when building exhibits for a Journal of Public Policy & Marketing (JPP&M) manuscript — event-study and DiD displays, condition-contrast tables, subgroup forest plots, and stimuli exhibits that a policy reader can act on. Builds the exhibits; it does not produce the estimates (jppm-data-analysis).4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/jppm-tables-figures6---78# Tables & Figures (jppm-tables-figures)910## When to trigger1112- Tables report coefficients an academic can parse but a policy reader cannot13- The evaluation has no event-study figure showing pre-trends and dynamics14- Subgroup results for vulnerable populations are scattered across prose15- The tested label/warning/disclosure stimuli are described but never shown16- The 50-page all-inclusive cap forces you to choose which exhibits survive1718## Exhibits for a dual audience1920JPP&M exhibits are read by two audiences at once: methods-literate reviewers who will interrogate the identification, and policy-oriented readers (including practitioners on the editorial board) who need the decision-relevant magnitude at a glance. Every exhibit should therefore carry **two layers**: the estimation detail (specification, SEs, clustering, N) in the table body and notes, and a **decision-unit translation** — percentage points, dollars, calories, share of consumers — in the headline row, figure annotation, or note. Because the 50-page limit *includes* tables and figures at every review stage, each exhibit must displace prose, not duplicate it; move the long battery to a web appendix.2122## The high-value JPP&M exhibits2324| Exhibit | What it must carry | Typical failure |25|---------|--------------------|-----------------|26| Stimuli figure | the actual tested labels/disclosures side by side, at realistic scale | describing formats in prose a regulator would need to see |27| Event-study figure | pre-period placebos + dynamic effects, CI band, policy date marked | showing only the post-period average |28| DiD table | group-time ATT, estimator named, cluster level, pre-trend sensitivity row | plain TWFE with stars and no diagnostics |29| RDD figure | binned outcomes + fit on both sides, bandwidth noted; density plot nearby | a fitted line with no raw data visible |30| Condition-contrast table | means/effects per policy option with the pairwise contrast the decision needs | omnibus F with no decision-mapped contrasts |31| Subgroup forest plot | pre-specified vulnerable-group effects with corrected CIs on one axis | significant splits in text, the rest invisible |32| Policy-translation table | effect × exposed population = market magnitude, with assumptions listed | leaving the rescaling to the reader |3334A stimuli figure is uniquely load-bearing at this journal: agencies regulate formats, so reviewers want to see exactly what was tested and whether it is mandatable.3536## House conventions (AMA journals)3738- Follow the **AMA journals style** shared across JM/JMR/JPP&M: numbered tables and figures, descriptive titles, notes defining every abbreviation, references and tables may be single-spaced while text is double-spaced (per the AMA submission guidelines — re-check current specifics on ama.org before formatting).39- Report **effect sizes and confidence intervals**; stars alone do not survive review.40- State the **estimator, clustering level, and fixed effects** in each table's note so the exhibit stands alone.41- Keep **Ns visible** (per cell / per group-time), including before/after exclusions.42- Figures must survive **grayscale print** and small reproduction — policy briefs will screenshot them.4344## Economy under the 50-page cap4546- Budget exhibits first: typically 1 stimuli figure, 1 identification figure, 2–3 core tables, 1 subgroup display in the body; everything else to the web appendix.47- Merge robustness variants into a single compact multi-column table rather than serial near-duplicates.48- Never present the same estimate as both table and figure; pick the form the decision reader needs.4950## Checklist5152- [ ] Each body exhibit carries both estimation detail and a decision-unit translation53- [ ] Stimuli shown as tested, at realistic scale54- [ ] Event-study / RDD figures display pre-trends or raw discontinuity, not just fits55- [ ] Estimator, clustering, FEs, and Ns named in every table note56- [ ] Subgroup effects displayed as a single corrected family (forest plot or panel)57- [ ] Effect sizes + CIs everywhere; no stars-only columns58- [ ] Body exhibits fit the 50-page all-inclusive budget; battery moved to web appendix5960## Anti-patterns6162- **Coefficient wall**: a 12-column regression table with no translated magnitude anywhere63- **Invisible stimuli**: regulating formats the reader never gets to see64- **Post-only plots**: dynamics figures that start at the policy date65- **Star tables**: significance markers standing in for effect sizes and CIs66- **Subgroup scatter**: heterogeneity sprinkled through prose instead of one comparable display67- **Cap blindness**: ten body exhibits that force the text out of the 50-page envelope6869## Output format7071```text72【Exhibit budget】body tables/figures list vs. web-appendix list (within 50-page cap)73【Stimuli figure】tested formats shown at scale? [Y/N]74【Identification display】event-study / RDD / placebo figure with pre-period evidence? [Y/N]75【Decision-unit layer】each body exhibit translated for the policy reader? [Y/N]76【Notes discipline】estimator, clustering, Ns, abbreviations in every note? [Y/N]77【Next skill】jppm-writing-style78```