Literature Review
Conduct a structured literature search and synthesis for the sewage-house-prices project.
Input: $ARGUMENTS — a topic, paper title, research question, or phenomenon.
Project-Specific Context
Core Literature Strands
- Environmental disamenity capitalisation — Hedonic pricing of pollution, noise, flood risk on house prices
- Water quality and property values — Clean/dirty water effects on housing markets
- UK water industry — Privatisation, regulation, sewage overflows, EDM monitoring
- Hedonic pricing methodology — Rosen (1974), Palmquist (1982), repeat sales, spatial approaches
- Infrastructure and house prices — Transport, utilities, public goods capitalisation
- Rental market effects — Disamenity capitalisation in rental vs owner-occupied markets
- Media and information effects — How news coverage affects price discovery
Target Journals (by tier)
Tier 1 (General): AER, Econometrica, QJE, JPE, REStud
Tier 2 (Field): JEEM, Journal of Urban Economics, Regional Science and Urban Economics, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, Ecological Economics, Environmental and Resource Economics
Tier 3 (Applied/Policy): JEEA, Journal of Applied Econometrics, Economics Letters, Land Economics, Environment and Planning B
Existing Bibliography
- Check
docs/overleaf/refs.bib for papers already in the project
- Check
docs/lit_review/ for any literature notes
Workflow
Step 1: Context Gathering
- Parse the topic from
$ARGUMENTS
- Read
docs/overleaf/refs.bib for papers already in the project
- Check the manuscript sections in
docs/overleaf/ for existing literature discussion
Step 2: Search Protocol
Search in this order:
- Top-5 general interest journals (AER, Econometrica, QJE, JPE, REStud)
- Field journals (JEEM, JUE, RSUE, JREFE, EE, ERE)
- NBER/SSRN/IZA working papers
- Citation chains (forward + backward from key papers found)
- UK-specific policy sources (Ofwat, Environment Agency, DEFRA)
Use web search to find recent and relevant papers.
Step 3: Assess and Annotate
For each paper found, assign a proximity score (1-5):
- 1 = Directly competes (same question, similar data/method)
- 2 = Closely related (same outcome or same treatment, different context)
- 3 = Methodologically relevant (same identification strategy, different topic)
- 4 = Background context (theoretical foundation, institutional detail)
- 5 = Tangentially related
Step 4: Identify Gaps
Check for:
- Missing seminal papers in hedonic pricing or environmental capitalisation
- Missing recent UK water quality studies
- Missing methodological context for the identification strategies used
- Coverage across journal quality tiers
Step 5: Present Results
# Literature Review: [Topic]
**Date:** YYYY-MM-DD
**Query:** [Original query]
## Summary
[2-3 paragraph overview of the state of the literature]
## Key Papers
### [Author (Year)] — [Short Title]
- **Journal:** [venue]
- **Proximity:** [1-5 score]
- **Contribution:** [1-2 sentences]
- **Identification:** [DiD / IV / RDD / hedonic / descriptive]
- **Key finding:** [result with effect size]
- **Relevance to sewage project:** [specific connection]
## Thematic Organization
### Environmental Disamenity Capitalisation
### Water Quality and Property Values
### Identification Strategy Literature
### UK Water Industry Context
## Gaps and Opportunities
1. [Gap 1 — what's missing and how our paper fills it]
2. [Gap 2]
## Research Frontier
### Active Debates
### Recent Working Papers
### Emerging Methods
## BibTeX Entries
```bibtex
@article{...}
Save to `output/log/lit_review_[topic].md`.
---
## Principles
- **Be honest about uncertainty.** If a citation cannot be verified, mark as `% UNVERIFIED`.
- **Prioritize published work** over working papers. Note publication status.
- **Do NOT fabricate citations.** Flag any uncertain details.
- **Identification strategy is key.** Always note how each paper identifies effects.
- **Effect sizes matter.** Report magnitudes, not just signs.
- **Project relevance.** Score proximity specifically to the sewage-house-prices question.
1---
2name: lit-review-2
3description: Structured literature search and synthesis for the sewage-house-prices project. Searches top-5 journals, field journals (JEEM, JUE, JREFE, EE), NBER/SSRN, and citation chains. Produces annotated bibliography with proximity scores, gap identification, and BibTeX entries. This skill should be used when asked to "review the literature", "find papers on X", or "lit review".
4argument-hint: "[topic, paper title, or research question]"
5allowed-tools: ["Read", "Grep", "Glob", "Write", "WebSearch", "WebFetch", "Agent"]
6metadata:
7 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/lit-review-2
8---
9
10# Literature Review
11
12Conduct a structured literature search and synthesis for the sewage-house-prices project.
13
14**Input:** `$ARGUMENTS` — a topic, paper title, research question, or phenomenon.
15
16---
17
18## Project-Specific Context
19
20### Core Literature Strands
21
221. **Environmental disamenity capitalisation** — Hedonic pricing of pollution, noise, flood risk on house prices
232. **Water quality and property values** — Clean/dirty water effects on housing markets
243. **UK water industry** — Privatisation, regulation, sewage overflows, EDM monitoring
254. **Hedonic pricing methodology** — Rosen (1974), Palmquist (1982), repeat sales, spatial approaches
265. **Infrastructure and house prices** — Transport, utilities, public goods capitalisation
276. **Rental market effects** — Disamenity capitalisation in rental vs owner-occupied markets
287. **Media and information effects** — How news coverage affects price discovery
29
30### Target Journals (by tier)
31
32**Tier 1 (General):** AER, Econometrica, QJE, JPE, REStud
33**Tier 2 (Field):** JEEM, Journal of Urban Economics, Regional Science and Urban Economics, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, Ecological Economics, Environmental and Resource Economics
34**Tier 3 (Applied/Policy):** JEEA, Journal of Applied Econometrics, Economics Letters, Land Economics, Environment and Planning B
35
36### Existing Bibliography
37- Check `docs/overleaf/refs.bib` for papers already in the project
38- Check `docs/lit_review/` for any literature notes
39
40---
41
42## Workflow
43
44### Step 1: Context Gathering
45
461. Parse the topic from `$ARGUMENTS`
472. Read `docs/overleaf/refs.bib` for papers already in the project
483. Check the manuscript sections in `docs/overleaf/` for existing literature discussion
49
50### Step 2: Search Protocol
51
52Search in this order:
531. Top-5 general interest journals (AER, Econometrica, QJE, JPE, REStud)
542. Field journals (JEEM, JUE, RSUE, JREFE, EE, ERE)
553. NBER/SSRN/IZA working papers
564. Citation chains (forward + backward from key papers found)
575. UK-specific policy sources (Ofwat, Environment Agency, DEFRA)
58
59Use web search to find recent and relevant papers.
60
61### Step 3: Assess and Annotate
62
63For each paper found, assign a proximity score (1-5):
64- **1** = Directly competes (same question, similar data/method)
65- **2** = Closely related (same outcome or same treatment, different context)
66- **3** = Methodologically relevant (same identification strategy, different topic)
67- **4** = Background context (theoretical foundation, institutional detail)
68- **5** = Tangentially related
69
70### Step 4: Identify Gaps
71
72Check for:
73- Missing seminal papers in hedonic pricing or environmental capitalisation
74- Missing recent UK water quality studies
75- Missing methodological context for the identification strategies used
76- Coverage across journal quality tiers
77
78### Step 5: Present Results
79
80```markdown
81# Literature Review: [Topic]
82**Date:** YYYY-MM-DD
83**Query:** [Original query]
84
85## Summary
86[2-3 paragraph overview of the state of the literature]
87
88## Key Papers
89### [Author (Year)] — [Short Title]
90- **Journal:** [venue]
91- **Proximity:** [1-5 score]
92- **Contribution:** [1-2 sentences]
93- **Identification:** [DiD / IV / RDD / hedonic / descriptive]
94- **Key finding:** [result with effect size]
95- **Relevance to sewage project:** [specific connection]
96
97## Thematic Organization
98### Environmental Disamenity Capitalisation
99### Water Quality and Property Values
100### Identification Strategy Literature
101### UK Water Industry Context
102
103## Gaps and Opportunities
1041. [Gap 1 — what's missing and how our paper fills it]
1052. [Gap 2]
106
107## Research Frontier
108### Active Debates
109### Recent Working Papers
110### Emerging Methods
111
112## BibTeX Entries
113```bibtex
114@article{...}
115```
116```
117
118Save to `output/log/lit_review_[topic].md`.
119
120---
121
122## Principles
123
124- **Be honest about uncertainty.** If a citation cannot be verified, mark as `% UNVERIFIED`.
125- **Prioritize published work** over working papers. Note publication status.
126- **Do NOT fabricate citations.** Flag any uncertain details.
127- **Identification strategy is key.** Always note how each paper identifies effects.
128- **Effect sizes matter.** Report magnitudes, not just signs.
129- **Project relevance.** Score proximity specifically to the sewage-house-prices question.