Revision & Response (mind-revision-and-response)
A Mind decision that invites resubmission is a strong signal at a venue with >800 submissions a
year. The referees are expert and their objections are philosophical, not procedural. The task is to
answer each objection on its merits — rebut, concede-and-limit, or bite the bullet — without
diluting the thesis that earned the invitation, and to keep the resubmission prepared for
triple-anonymous review.
When to trigger
- A revise-and-resubmit or reject-with-encouragement arrived and you are planning the revision
- Referees disagree with each other and you must decide whom to follow
- A referee raises an objection that would, if right, change the conclusion
- Writing the response letter / cover note that accompanies the resubmission
Strategy
- Read the editor's letter as the rubric. The editor signals which objections are decisive. Solve
those first; the editor adjudicates disagreements among referees.
- One point-by-point response, every objection addressed. Quote each referee point, then respond.
Never skip one — silence reads as evasion to an expert reader.
- Answer philosophically, not deferentially. For each objection do one of three things and say
which: rebut (show it fails, with a reason), concede and limit (narrow the thesis so it no
longer bites), or bite the bullet (accept the cost and argue it is worth paying). A well-argued
disagreement earns more respect than a capitulation that breaks the argument.
- Protect the thesis. Sharpen, qualify, and add the missing reply — but resist changes that hollow
out the central claim. Defend scope conditions rather than retreating into vagueness.
- Reconcile conflicting referees openly. When one wants the opposite of another, say so, choose a
principled path, and explain the tradeoff to the editor. Do not silently satisfy one and ignore the other.
- Keep it anonymous and house-style-ready. The resubmission must remain prepared for
triple-anonymous review (no self-identifying additions), line-numbered, and consistent with the
MIND house style for any accepted-stage copy (see
mind-citation-and-style, mind-submission).
Response-letter format
For each referee point:
> [Quoted referee comment]
Response: [Rebut / concede-and-limit / bite-the-bullet — with the actual reason].
Change: [Section / page / line numbers where the revision appears].
Open with a short summary of the main changes to the editor; group by referee; end each entry with
the location of the change so the editor and referees can verify quickly.
Worked micro-example: one response entry
- Weak: "We thank the referee for this insightful comment and have revised accordingly." — no tag,
no reason, no location; an expert referee reads this as evasion dressed up as courtesy.
- Strong: "> The counterexample in §3 also refutes premise 2. — Rebut: the case trades on an
equivocation between propositional and doxastic justification; premise 2 concerns only the former.
We now flag the distinction where the premise is introduced. Change: §3.2, lines 214–228."
The strong entry names its move, gives the philosophical reason, and cites the line numbers Mind
requires on the manuscript — making verification fast for editor and referees.
Resubmission preflight
Anti-patterns
- Ignoring or quietly merging away an objection without a visible response
- Capitulating to a request that breaks the argument just to placate a referee
- A defensive or dismissive tone toward expert referees
- "We thank the referee" with no actual change and no argued reason
- Adding a concession that silently undercuts the original thesis
- Reintroducing self-identifying material into the resubmission (breaks anonymity)
Output format
【Editor's decisive points】addressed first? [list]
【Coverage】every referee objection answered? [Y/N]
【Each response tagged】rebut / concede-and-limit / bite-the-bullet + change location
【Referee conflicts】reconciled and explained to editor? [Y/N]
【Thesis protected】no dilution of the central claim? [Y/N]
【Anonymity + line numbers preserved】[Y/N]
【Next】resubmit via ScholarOne
Supplementary resources
1---2name: mind-revision-and-response3description: Use when responding to a Mind decision — a revise-and-resubmit, a reject-with-encouragement, or referee reports to address before resubmitting. The response must answer expert philosophical objections without weakening the thesis, while keeping the manuscript prepared for triple-anonymous review. Structures the revision and the response letter; it does not fabricate new arguments.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/mind-revision-and-response6---78# Revision & Response (mind-revision-and-response)910A Mind decision that invites resubmission is a strong signal at a venue with **>800 submissions a11year**. The referees are expert and their objections are philosophical, not procedural. The task is to12**answer each objection on its merits** — rebut, concede-and-limit, or bite the bullet — without13diluting the thesis that earned the invitation, and to keep the resubmission **prepared for14triple-anonymous review**.1516## When to trigger1718- A revise-and-resubmit or reject-with-encouragement arrived and you are planning the revision19- Referees disagree with each other and you must decide whom to follow20- A referee raises an objection that would, if right, change the conclusion21- Writing the response letter / cover note that accompanies the resubmission2223## Strategy24251. **Read the editor's letter as the rubric.** The editor signals which objections are decisive. Solve26 those first; the editor adjudicates disagreements among referees.272. **One point-by-point response, every objection addressed.** Quote each referee point, then respond.28 Never skip one — silence reads as evasion to an expert reader.293. **Answer philosophically, not deferentially.** For each objection do one of three things and say30 which: **rebut** (show it fails, with a reason), **concede and limit** (narrow the thesis so it no31 longer bites), or **bite the bullet** (accept the cost and argue it is worth paying). A well-argued32 disagreement earns more respect than a capitulation that breaks the argument.334. **Protect the thesis.** Sharpen, qualify, and add the missing reply — but resist changes that hollow34 out the central claim. Defend scope conditions rather than retreating into vagueness.355. **Reconcile conflicting referees openly.** When one wants the opposite of another, say so, choose a36 principled path, and explain the tradeoff to the editor. Do not silently satisfy one and ignore the other.376. **Keep it anonymous and house-style-ready.** The resubmission must remain prepared for38 **triple-anonymous** review (no self-identifying additions), line-numbered, and consistent with the39 **MIND house style** for any accepted-stage copy (see `mind-citation-and-style`, `mind-submission`).4041## Response-letter format4243For each referee point:4445```46> [Quoted referee comment]4748Response: [Rebut / concede-and-limit / bite-the-bullet — with the actual reason].49Change: [Section / page / line numbers where the revision appears].50```5152Open with a short **summary of the main changes** to the editor; group by referee; end each entry with53the **location** of the change so the editor and referees can verify quickly.5455## Worked micro-example: one response entry5657- *Weak:* "We thank the referee for this insightful comment and have revised accordingly." — no tag,58 no reason, no location; an expert referee reads this as evasion dressed up as courtesy.59- *Strong:* "> The counterexample in §3 also refutes premise 2. — **Rebut**: the case trades on an60 equivocation between propositional and doxastic justification; premise 2 concerns only the former.61 We now flag the distinction where the premise is introduced. **Change**: §3.2, lines 214–228."6263The strong entry names its move, gives the philosophical reason, and cites the line numbers Mind64requires on the manuscript — making verification fast for editor and referees.6566## Resubmission preflight6768- [ ] Editor's decisive objections answered first and flagged in the summary of changes69- [ ] Every referee point quoted and tagged rebut / concede-and-limit / bite-the-bullet70- [ ] No new self-identifying material introduced by the revision (added acknowledgements,71 "as I argued elsewhere…") — the triple-anonymous preparation must survive the edit72- [ ] Line numbering regenerated after revising, so locations cited in the response letter are accurate73- [ ] Still within the ~8,000-word limit after additions — cut elsewhere rather than blow the cap74- [ ] If unclear whether the resubmission interacts with the one-article-per-12-months rule, confirm75 with the editorial office before uploading (需复核)7677## Anti-patterns7879- Ignoring or quietly merging away an objection without a visible response80- Capitulating to a request that breaks the argument just to placate a referee81- A defensive or dismissive tone toward expert referees82- "We thank the referee" with no actual change and no argued reason83- Adding a concession that silently undercuts the original thesis84- Reintroducing self-identifying material into the resubmission (breaks anonymity)8586## Output format8788```89【Editor's decisive points】addressed first? [list]90【Coverage】every referee objection answered? [Y/N]91【Each response tagged】rebut / concede-and-limit / bite-the-bullet + change location92【Referee conflicts】reconciled and explained to editor? [Y/N]93【Thesis protected】no dilution of the central claim? [Y/N]94【Anonymity + line numbers preserved】[Y/N]95【Next】resubmit via ScholarOne96```9798## Supplementary resources99100- [`../../resources/official-source-map.md`](../../resources/official-source-map.md) — triple-anonymous policy, referee process, resubmission via ScholarOne