Slide Excellence Review
Run a comprehensive multi-dimensional review of research presentation slides. Multiple agents analyze the file independently, then results are synthesized.
Steps
1. Identify the File
Parse $ARGUMENTS for the filename. Resolve path in docs/conferences/.
2. Run Review Agents in Parallel
Agent 1: Visual Audit (slide-auditor)
- Overflow, font consistency, box fatigue, spacing, images
- Save:
docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_visual_audit.md
Agent 2: Econometric Fidelity Review (econometrics-reviewer)
- Every quantitative claim on slides must be traceable to the paper (
docs/overleaf/_main.tex)
- Check: coefficients, standard errors, sample sizes, p-values match paper tables/figures
- Check: identification strategy correctly described (hedonic pricing, repeat sales, long-difference, DiD, upstream/downstream)
- Check: treatment variables defined correctly (spill_count/spill_hrs, 12/24hr counting methodology)
- Check: confidence intervals and significance stars consistent with paper
- Check: no causal language without identification support
- Save:
docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_econometrics_report.md
Agent 3: Proofreading (proofreader)
- Grammar, typos, consistency, academic quality, citations
- Save:
docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_report.md
Agent 4: TikZ Review (only if file contains TikZ)
- Label overlaps, geometric accuracy, visual semantics
- Save:
docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_tikz_review.md
Agent 5: Substance Review (domain correctness)
- Verify environmental economics claims are accurate
- Check EDM/water company institutional context is correct
- Verify spatial econometrics descriptions match methodology
- Check hedonic pricing theory correctly invoked
- Verify England housing market characterisation
- Save:
docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_substance_review.md
3. Synthesize Combined Summary
# Slide Excellence Review: [Filename]
## Overall Quality Score: [EXCELLENT / GOOD / NEEDS WORK / POOR]
| Dimension | Critical | Medium | Low |
|-----------|----------|--------|-----|
| Visual/Layout | | | |
| Econometric Fidelity | | | |
| Proofreading | | | |
| Substance | | | |
### Critical Issues (Immediate Action Required)
### Medium Issues (Next Revision)
### Recommended Next Steps
Quality Score Rubric
| Score |
Critical |
Medium |
Meaning |
| Excellent |
0-2 |
0-5 |
Ready to present |
| Good |
3-5 |
6-15 |
Minor refinements |
| Needs Work |
6-10 |
16-30 |
Significant revision |
| Poor |
11+ |
31+ |
Major restructuring |
1---2name: slide-excellence3description: Multi-agent review for research presentation slides in the sewage-house-prices project (visual, econometric fidelity, proofreading, substance). Use for comprehensive quality check before milestones.4argument-hint: "[TEX filename]"5allowed-tools: ["Read", "Grep", "Glob", "Write", "Task"]6context: fork7metadata:8 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/brycewang-stanford/slide-excellence9---1011# Slide Excellence Review1213Run a comprehensive multi-dimensional review of research presentation slides. Multiple agents analyze the file independently, then results are synthesized.1415## Steps1617### 1. Identify the File1819Parse `$ARGUMENTS` for the filename. Resolve path in `docs/conferences/`.2021### 2. Run Review Agents in Parallel2223**Agent 1: Visual Audit** (slide-auditor)24- Overflow, font consistency, box fatigue, spacing, images25- Save: `docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_visual_audit.md`2627**Agent 2: Econometric Fidelity Review** (econometrics-reviewer)28- Every quantitative claim on slides must be traceable to the paper (`docs/overleaf/_main.tex`)29- Check: coefficients, standard errors, sample sizes, p-values match paper tables/figures30- Check: identification strategy correctly described (hedonic pricing, repeat sales, long-difference, DiD, upstream/downstream)31- Check: treatment variables defined correctly (spill_count/spill_hrs, 12/24hr counting methodology)32- Check: confidence intervals and significance stars consistent with paper33- Check: no causal language without identification support34- Save: `docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_econometrics_report.md`3536**Agent 3: Proofreading** (proofreader)37- Grammar, typos, consistency, academic quality, citations38- Save: `docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_report.md`3940**Agent 4: TikZ Review** (only if file contains TikZ)41- Label overlaps, geometric accuracy, visual semantics42- Save: `docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_tikz_review.md`4344**Agent 5: Substance Review** (domain correctness)45- Verify environmental economics claims are accurate46- Check EDM/water company institutional context is correct47- Verify spatial econometrics descriptions match methodology48- Check hedonic pricing theory correctly invoked49- Verify England housing market characterisation50- Save: `docs/conferences/quality_reports/[FILE]_substance_review.md`5152### 3. Synthesize Combined Summary5354```markdown55# Slide Excellence Review: [Filename]5657## Overall Quality Score: [EXCELLENT / GOOD / NEEDS WORK / POOR]5859| Dimension | Critical | Medium | Low |60|-----------|----------|--------|-----|61| Visual/Layout | | | |62| Econometric Fidelity | | | |63| Proofreading | | | |64| Substance | | | |6566### Critical Issues (Immediate Action Required)67### Medium Issues (Next Revision)68### Recommended Next Steps69```7071## Quality Score Rubric7273| Score | Critical | Medium | Meaning |74|-------|----------|--------|---------|75| Excellent | 0-2 | 0-5 | Ready to present |76| Good | 3-5 | 6-15 | Minor refinements |77| Needs Work | 6-10 | 16-30 | Significant revision |78| Poor | 11+ | 31+ | Major restructuring |