LLM Council
Five advisors answer independently, then review each other blind, then a chairman synthesizes. One model, five thinking lenses, plus a peer-review round that catches what any single pass misses.
Run it when being wrong is expensive. Skip it when there's one right answer, or when the user wants something made rather than judged.
Workflow
1. Enrich, then frame. Glob/Read for context that would make advice specific instead
of generic: CLAUDE.md, any memory/ folder, files the user referenced, prior
council-transcript-*.md in the cwd. Cap it at 2-3 files. Then write one neutral framed
question carrying: the decision, the user's context, the workspace context (stage,
audience, constraints, numbers), and what's at stake. No opinion, no steering. If the
question is too vague to frame, ask exactly one clarifying question, then proceed.
2. Convene. Dispatch all 5 advisors in a single message so they run in parallel. Prompts in ADVISORS.md. 150-300 words each.
3. Peer review. Shuffle the 5 responses into A-E (record the mapping). Dispatch 5 reviewers in parallel, each seeing all five anonymized responses. Under 200 words each.
4. Chairman. One agent gets the framed question, the de-anonymized responses, and all 5 reviews. Fixed five-section verdict.
5. Render. Write the session to JSON, then:
python3 ~/.claude/skills/llm-council/scripts/render.py session.json .
It emits council-report-<timestamp>.html and council-transcript-<timestamp>.md in the
cwd and prints both paths. Send the HTML to the user with SendUserFile
(display: "render"). JSON schema is documented at the top of the script.
Rules
- Parallel, always. Sequential dispatch lets earlier responses bleed into later ones.
- Anonymize for review. Named advisors get deferred to by reputation, not merit.
- Advisors do not hedge. Each leans fully into its lens. Balance is the chairman's job.
- The chairman may side with the minority when the dissenter's reasoning is strongest, and should say why.
- Don't council trivia. If there's one right answer, just answer it.