CaseMark Conducting Reserve And Resource Analysis
Evaluates mineral and hydrocarbon reserves with classification methodology, resource conversion rates, and valuation per unit analysis.
When To Use
- Reviewing a Competent Person's Report (CPR), NI 43-101 technical report, or SEC-compliant reserve filing
- Validating proved/probable/possible (1P/2P/3P) reserve classifications prior to an acquisition or financing
- Assessing resource-to-reserve conversion ratios for mine-stage or field-development economics
- Building depletion schedules for NAV models on oil & gas or mining assets
- Benchmarking reserve replacement ratios, finding & development costs, or reserve life indices across a portfolio
Inputs To Gather
- Reserve/resource report — the third-party or internal engineering estimate (identify preparer, effective date, reporting standard)
- Commodity type — oil/gas (specify BOE conversion ratios used), hard-rock mineral, coal, or other
- Classification standard — PRMS (SPE/WPC), CRIRSCO-aligned code (JORC, CIM, SAMREC), SEC Subpart 1200, or NI 43-101 [VERIFY which standard governs the filing jurisdiction]
- Price deck — strip pricing, SEC trailing 12-month average, or operator forecast; note date and source
- Production history — at least 3 years of monthly production data if available; type-curve parameters for undeveloped locations
- Cost assumptions — OPEX per unit, CAPEX for development/infill, abandonment/reclamation obligations
- Fiscal terms — royalty rates, production taxes, PSC terms, or mining royalty/tax regime [VERIFY jurisdiction-specific rates]
Workflow
Identify the reporting framework and audit the classification
- Confirm whether the report follows PRMS, JORC, CIM, SEC S-K 1200, or another standard
- Map each category to a confidence tier: Proved/Measured → ≥90%, Probable/Indicated → ≥50%, Possible/Inferred → lower confidence
- Flag any categories labeled "contingent resources" or "exploration target" — these sit outside reserves and must not be treated as bookable
Reconcile reserves to production history
- Compare prior-year reserve bookings to actual production and revisions; compute the reserve replacement ratio (net additions ÷ production)
- Identify technical revisions vs. price revisions vs. discoveries; large negative technical revisions signal estimation risk
- For mining assets, reconcile mill feed grades against the block-model predictions to assess estimation bias
Evaluate resource-to-reserve conversion potential
- Determine what fraction of indicated/probable resources can convert to measured/proved given planned development CAPEX
- Assess modifying factors: metallurgical recovery, cut-off grade sensitivity, well-spacing assumptions, regulatory permits outstanding [VERIFY permitting status]
- Assign a probability-weighted conversion rate (e.g., 60-80% for brownfield infill, 20-40% for greenfield exploration upside)
Build the depletion profile
- For oil & gas: apply decline-curve analysis (hyperbolic/exponential) using fitted b-factor, Di, and terminal decline rate; cross-check against type curves for analogous wells
- For mining: construct a life-of-mine (LOM) schedule from the mine plan, sequencing ore blocks by grade and strip ratio
- Sensitize the profile to ±10-20% recovery factor or grade variation
Compute per-unit valuation metrics
- Calculate in-ground value: commodity price × net revenue interest × recovery factor, less development CAPEX per unit
- Derive NAV per proved BOE (or per recoverable ounce/ton) using a DCF at an appropriate discount rate (typically 10% for SEC PV-10)
- Benchmark against recent comparable transactions ($/BOE, $/oz, $/lb in-situ)
Assess risk factors and flag uncertainties
- Geological risk: structural complexity, fault compartmentalization, grade continuity
- Regulatory risk: outstanding permits, environmental liabilities, indigenous land claims [VERIFY jurisdiction]
- Commercial risk: price sensitivity (run breakeven at ±20% commodity price), infrastructure access, offtake agreements
Output
- Reserve summary table — quantities by category (1P/2P/3P or Measured/Indicated/Inferred), commodity, and asset/field, with effective date and reporting standard noted
- Depletion schedule — annual production forecast through reserve life, with key assumptions (decline parameters, mine sequencing, recovery factors)
- Valuation summary — NAV per unit at base, upside, and downside price cases; PV-10 or NPV at stated discount rate; comparison to market transaction benchmarks
- Conversion and replacement analysis — resource-to-reserve conversion assumptions, historical reserve replacement ratio, F&D cost per unit
- Risk register — itemized geological, regulatory, and commercial risks with [VERIFY] tags on jurisdiction-dependent items
Quality Checks
- Reserve categories match the definitions of the stated reporting standard — do not conflate contingent resources with proved reserves
- Price deck date and source are explicitly stated; SEC filings must use the prescribed trailing average [VERIFY current SEC pricing rule]
- Decline-curve or LOM parameters are cross-referenced against at least one independent data point (analogous field, historical actuals, or third-party audit)
- BOE conversion ratios are stated and consistent (standard: 6 Mcf = 1 BOE for energy equivalence; note if economic equivalence is used instead)
- All per-unit metrics use a consistent denominator (net vs. gross acres, WI vs. NRI volumes, recoverable vs. in-situ resource)
- Abandonment and reclamation obligations are included in NAV calculations — omission overstates asset value
- Any estimate carrying greater than ±30% uncertainty range is flagged for further engineering review