Mediation Statement
Drafts a mediation statement that educates the mediator on case strengths and positions the client for favorable settlement. Works for both plaintiff and defense — adjust framing accordingly.
Prerequisites
Gather before drafting:
- Case file — complaint, answer, case number, mediation date, mediator name
- Confidentiality designation — mediator-only or shared with opposing counsel
- Discovery materials — deposition transcripts, interrogatory responses, document production
- Medical records — treatment history, bills, expert reports (PI cases)
- Settlement history — all demands and offers with dates
- Key exhibits — photos, contracts, communications, expert reports
Quick Start
Target 5–15 pages, single-spaced, numbered exhibits. Submit 7–10 days before mediation unless mediator specifies otherwise.
Sections
1. Header & Introduction
Caption (Party v. Party, Case No.), mediation date, mediator name, brief cooperative opening.
2. Executive Summary
2–3 sentences: case type, central disputed issue, client's position.
3. Factual Background
Present chronologically with strategic framing:
- Lead with context favorable to client
- Key dates, times, locations, witnesses
- Reference exhibits by number
- Active voice for opponent's bad acts; passive for client's unfavorable facts
- Plaintiff: dangerous conditions, lack of warnings, defendant knowledge
- Defense: plaintiff's conduct, obvious hazards, proper maintenance
4. Liability Analysis
Structure element-by-element (duty → breach → causation → comparative fault):
- Cite applicable statutes and case law
- Show why each element favors client
- Distinguish adverse authority
- Preemptively rebut opponent's strongest arguments
5. Testimony & Discovery
- Highlight favorable admissions from opposing party
- Identify contradictions, credibility problems, discovery gaps
- Cite specific deposition pages; attach key excerpts as exhibits selectively
6. Medical/Injury Analysis
PI cases — analyze each category with client-favorable framing:
| Category |
Focus |
| Pre-incident history |
Frame favorably for client |
| Post-incident treatment |
Records vs. claims |
| Causation |
Medical evidence linking injuries to incident |
| Objective vs. subjective |
Emphasize objective findings |
| Treatment gaps |
Inconsistencies, delayed treatment |
| Activity level |
Exaggeration or genuine limitation |
Non-PI cases — analyze business records, contracts, communications; assess damage documentation.
7. Damages Analysis
Break down each category and assess credibility:
- Medical bills — reasonable/necessary vs. excessive/unrelated
- Lost wages — documented vs. speculative
- Pain and suffering — objective support vs. subjective claims
- Property/economic losses — properly calculated vs. speculative
- Expert opinions — reliability, basis, methodology
Frame in light most favorable to client.
8. Expert Witness Analysis
- Client's expert: qualifications, methodology, key opinions
- Opponent's expert: weaknesses, potential bias
- Anticipated trial impact
9. Trial Outlook
- Jury appeal — which party benefits and why
- Pending motions (MSJ, motions in limine)
- Evidentiary and credibility problems opponent faces
- Costs/fees exposure; appeal risks
10. Settlement History
Chronological table of all demands and offers (date, party, amount, notes). Analyze movement and why opponent's current position is unrealistic.
11. Settlement Path
Do not propose a specific number. Instead:
- Identify what opponent must concede
- Describe non-settlement consequences (cost, time, risk)
- Address impediments to resolution
- Frame which side has further to move and why
12. Exhibits
Attach only high-impact documents: key deposition excerpts, medical chronologies, expert reports, critical communications. Limit volume — excess dilutes impact.
Guidelines
- Tone: Persuasive and professional — advocate hard but do not overstate disprovable facts
- Confidentiality: Mediator-only statements can be more candid about weaknesses and realistic ranges
- Jurisdiction: U.S. practice; adjust for state-specific mediation confidentiality rules
- Ethics: Strategic framing is appropriate; misrepresentation of facts or law is not
Checklist
1---
2name: mediation-statement
3language: en
4description: Drafts persuasive mediation statements for litigation, structuring narrative across liability, damages, medical evidence, experts, and settlement positioning for plaintiff or defense. Use when preparing mediation briefs, settlement statements, ADR submissions, or pre-mediation filings.
5metadata:
6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/casemark/mediation-statement
7---
8
9# Mediation Statement
10
11Drafts a mediation statement that educates the mediator on case strengths and positions the client for favorable settlement. Works for both plaintiff and defense — adjust framing accordingly.
12
13## Prerequisites
14
15Gather before drafting:
16
171. **Case file** — complaint, answer, case number, mediation date, mediator name
182. **Confidentiality designation** — mediator-only or shared with opposing counsel
193. **Discovery materials** — deposition transcripts, interrogatory responses, document production
204. **Medical records** — treatment history, bills, expert reports (PI cases)
215. **Settlement history** — all demands and offers with dates
226. **Key exhibits** — photos, contracts, communications, expert reports
23
24## Quick Start
25
26Target 5–15 pages, single-spaced, numbered exhibits. Submit 7–10 days before mediation unless mediator specifies otherwise.
27
28## Sections
29
30### 1. Header & Introduction
31
32Caption (Party v. Party, Case No.), mediation date, mediator name, brief cooperative opening.
33
34### 2. Executive Summary
35
362–3 sentences: case type, central disputed issue, client's position.
37
38### 3. Factual Background
39
40Present chronologically with strategic framing:
41- Lead with context favorable to client
42- Key dates, times, locations, witnesses
43- Reference exhibits by number
44- Active voice for opponent's bad acts; passive for client's unfavorable facts
45- **Plaintiff**: dangerous conditions, lack of warnings, defendant knowledge
46- **Defense**: plaintiff's conduct, obvious hazards, proper maintenance
47
48### 4. Liability Analysis
49
50Structure element-by-element (duty → breach → causation → comparative fault):
51- Cite applicable statutes and case law
52- Show why each element favors client
53- Distinguish adverse authority
54- Preemptively rebut opponent's strongest arguments
55
56### 5. Testimony & Discovery
57
58- Highlight favorable admissions from opposing party
59- Identify contradictions, credibility problems, discovery gaps
60- Cite specific deposition pages; attach key excerpts as exhibits selectively
61
62### 6. Medical/Injury Analysis
63
64**PI cases** — analyze each category with client-favorable framing:
65
66| Category | Focus |
67|----------|-------|
68| Pre-incident history | Frame favorably for client |
69| Post-incident treatment | Records vs. claims |
70| Causation | Medical evidence linking injuries to incident |
71| Objective vs. subjective | Emphasize objective findings |
72| Treatment gaps | Inconsistencies, delayed treatment |
73| Activity level | Exaggeration or genuine limitation |
74
75**Non-PI cases** — analyze business records, contracts, communications; assess damage documentation.
76
77### 7. Damages Analysis
78
79Break down each category and assess credibility:
80- Medical bills — reasonable/necessary vs. excessive/unrelated
81- Lost wages — documented vs. speculative
82- Pain and suffering — objective support vs. subjective claims
83- Property/economic losses — properly calculated vs. speculative
84- Expert opinions — reliability, basis, methodology
85
86Frame in light most favorable to client.
87
88### 8. Expert Witness Analysis
89
90- Client's expert: qualifications, methodology, key opinions
91- Opponent's expert: weaknesses, potential bias
92- Anticipated trial impact
93
94### 9. Trial Outlook
95
96- Jury appeal — which party benefits and why
97- Pending motions (MSJ, motions in limine)
98- Evidentiary and credibility problems opponent faces
99- Costs/fees exposure; appeal risks
100
101### 10. Settlement History
102
103Chronological table of all demands and offers (date, party, amount, notes). Analyze movement and why opponent's current position is unrealistic.
104
105### 11. Settlement Path
106
107Do **not** propose a specific number. Instead:
108- Identify what opponent must concede
109- Describe non-settlement consequences (cost, time, risk)
110- Address impediments to resolution
111- Frame which side has further to move and why
112
113### 12. Exhibits
114
115Attach only high-impact documents: key deposition excerpts, medical chronologies, expert reports, critical communications. Limit volume — excess dilutes impact.
116
117## Guidelines
118
119- **Tone**: Persuasive and professional — advocate hard but do not overstate disprovable facts
120- **Confidentiality**: Mediator-only statements can be more candid about weaknesses and realistic ranges
121- **Jurisdiction**: U.S. practice; adjust for state-specific mediation confidentiality rules
122- **Ethics**: Strategic framing is appropriate; misrepresentation of facts or law is not
123
124## Checklist
125
126- [ ] Persuasive tone throughout
127- [ ] Client's position clearly articulated
128- [ ] Opponent's weaknesses supported with specific evidence
129- [ ] Settlement path provided without proposing a number
130- [ ] Mediator name and date correct
131- [ ] Exhibits numbered and referenced in text
132- [ ] Proofread for grammar, spelling, formatting