CasLubbers Clean Python: Complete Reference
Enforces all Clean Code principles from Robert C. Martin's Chapter 17, adapted for Python.
Comments (C1-C5)
- C1: No metadata in comments (use Git)
- C2: Delete obsolete comments immediately
- C3: No redundant comments
- C4: Write comments well if you must
- C5: Never commit commented-out code
Environment (E1-E2)
- E1: One command to build (
pip install -e ".[dev]") - E2: One command to test (
pytest)
Functions (F1-F4)
- F1: Maximum 3 arguments (use dataclasses for more)
- F2: No output arguments (return values)
- F3: No flag arguments (split functions)
- F4: Delete dead functions
- Stepdown rule: file reads top-down, callers above callees, one level of abstraction per function
General (G1-G36)
- G1: One language per file
- G2: Implement expected behavior
- G3: Handle boundary conditions
- G4: Don't override safeties
- G5: DRY - no duplication
- Composition over inheritance: inherit only for genuine is-a, compose for reuse
- G6: Consistent abstraction levels
- G7: Base classes don't know children
- G8: Minimize public interface
- G9: Delete dead code
- G10: Variables near usage
- G11: Be consistent
- G12: Remove clutter
- G13: No artificial coupling
- G14: No feature envy
- G15: No selector arguments
- G16: No obscured intent
- G17: Code where expected
- G18: Prefer instance methods
- G19: Use explanatory variables
- G20: Function names say what they do
- G21: Understand the algorithm
- G22: Make dependencies physical
- G23: Prefer polymorphism to if/else
- G24: Follow conventions (PEP 8)
- G25: Named constants, not magic numbers
- G26: Be precise
- G27: Structure over convention
- G28: Encapsulate conditionals
- G29: Avoid negative conditionals
- G30: Functions do one thing
- G31: Make temporal coupling explicit
- G32: Don't be arbitrary
- G33: Encapsulate boundary conditions
- G34: One abstraction level per function
- G35: Config at high levels
- G36: Law of Demeter (no train wrecks)
Python-Specific (P1-P3)
These adapt the Java-specific rules (J1-J3) to Python conventions:
- P1: No wildcard imports (
from x import *) — opposite of Java, per PEP 8 - P2: Use Enums, not magic constants — same principle as J3
- P3: Type hints on public interfaces — Python's equivalent of Java's static typing
Names (N1-N7)
- N1: Choose descriptive names
- N2: Right abstraction level
- N3: Use standard nomenclature
- N4: Unambiguous names
- N5: Name length matches scope
- N6: No encodings
- N7: Names describe side effects
Tests (T1-T9)
- T1: Test everything that could break
- T2: Use coverage tools
- T3: Don't skip trivial tests
- T4: Ignored test = ambiguity question
- T5: Test boundary conditions
- T6: Exhaustively test near bugs
- T7: Look for patterns in failures
- T8: Check coverage when debugging
- T9: Tests must be fast (< 100ms each)
Quick Reference Table
| Category | Rule | One-Liner |
|---|---|---|
| Comments | C1 | No metadata (use Git) |
| C3 | No redundant comments | |
| C5 | No commented-out code | |
| Functions | F1 | Max 3 arguments |
| F3 | No flag arguments | |
| F4 | Delete dead functions | |
| General | G5 | DRY—no duplication |
| G9 | Delete dead code | |
| G16 | No obscured intent | |
| G23 | Polymorphism over if/else | |
| G25 | Named constants, not magic numbers | |
| G30 | Functions do one thing | |
| G36 | Law of Demeter (one dot) | |
| — | Stepdown rule: code reads top-down | |
| — | Composition over inheritance | |
| Names | N1 | Descriptive names |
| N5 | Name length matches scope | |
| Tests | T5 | Test boundary conditions |
| T9 | Tests must be fast |
Anti-Patterns (Don't → Do)
| ❌ Don't | ✅ Do |
|---|---|
| Comment every line | Delete obvious comments |
| Helper for one-liner | Inline the code |
from x import * |
Explicit imports |
Magic number 86400 |
SECONDS_PER_DAY = 86400 |
process(data, True) |
process_verbose(data) |
| Deep nesting | Guard clauses, early returns |
obj.a.b.c.value |
obj.get_value() |
| 100+ line function | Split by responsibility |
| Helpers above the entry point | Entry point first, helpers below |
class Notifier(SMTPClient) |
class Notifier: holding an SMTPClient |
AI Behavior
When reviewing code, identify violations by rule number (e.g., "G5 violation: duplicated logic").
When fixing or editing code, report what was fixed (e.g., "Fixed: extracted magic number to SECONDS_PER_DAY (G25)").