Debate adjudication multi-agent voting
#27 · Domain: Competitive debate · Category: refinement · Difficulty: 🔴 High
Core principle
Discrete criteria scored separately with ballot justification.
AI problem addressed
Single-pass 'sounds good' evaluation hides tradeoffs.
Implementation
Agent A: logic 1–10 + justification Agent B: evidence 1–10 + justification Agent C: completeness 1–10 + justification Synthesis: final score + which dimension drove decision and why
Boundaries
- Prototype as prompt scaffold (🟢) before full pipeline middleware (🟡/🔴)
- Category router:
ai-transfer-refinement - Catalog:
ai-transfer-ecosystem-primer - Runtime plugin id:
debate_judging