Plan Ceo Review

Plan CEO Review

Review the plan from a founder/product strategy perspective before execution. Do not implement. Keep the user in control of every scope change.

Guardrails

• Challenge assumptions directly and write down unresolved ambiguity.
• Prefer focus over expansion unless the user explicitly chooses an expansion mode.
• Treat each opportunity as optional until accepted. Do not smuggle rejected ideas into scope.
• Define success in observable product or business terms, not vague quality claims.

Skill Chain

For a full founder/product review, run these local skills in order:

1. /plan-review-intake - find the plan and local .planning/* context.
2. /interrogate-me - stress-test the problem, user, scope, assumptions, risks, and tradeoffs.
3. /plan-review-scope - establish what already exists, what is in scope, and what is out of scope.
4. /plan-ceo-strategy - select the review mode and challenge the product direction.
5. /plan-ceo-opportunities - surface expansion, simplification, positioning, and trust opportunities one at a time.
6. /plan-ceo-wrapup - write the .planning/reviews/plan-ceo-review.md artifact.

If a named skill is unavailable, inline that section using the same instructions from the corresponding skill file name above.

Review Modes

• SCOPE EXPANSION: dream bigger and propose high-leverage improvements. Every expansion requires explicit opt-in.
• SELECTIVE EXPANSION: preserve baseline scope while offering optional improvements one by one.
• HOLD SCOPE: make the accepted scope sharper, more coherent, and safer without expanding or reducing it.
• SCOPE REDUCTION: find the smallest version that still achieves the core outcome.

Once the user chooses a mode, do not drift modes.

Product Review Principles

• Start with the user problem, not the proposed implementation.
• Separate reversible decisions from one-way decisions.
• Prefer focus: fewer things, better.
• Challenge proxy metrics that do not prove user value.
• Look for trust, safety, onboarding, and retention consequences.
• Ask what would make the plan fail, then remove or expose those failure paths.
• Prefer complete, bounded work over shortcuts that leave avoidable quality gaps.
• Write all durable outputs under .planning/*.

Required Output

Write or update .planning/reviews/plan-ceo-review.md with:

• Status: CLEAR, CLEAR_WITH_CONCERNS, NEEDS_DECISION, or BLOCKED
• Review mode
• Plan reviewed
• Problem framing
• Target users and use cases
• Scope decisions
• Accepted opportunities
• Rejected opportunities
• NOT in scope
• Risks and reversibility
• Success metrics
• TODO proposals
• Unresolved decisions
• Completion summary

When a larger strategy document is useful, write it under:

.planning/strategy/{feature-slug}.md

Do not write durable workflow artifacts outside .planning/*.

Install: npx skills add ChristopherAlphonse/calphonse-skills --skill plan-ceo-review