oracle · spec · judge — grade scope, by discipline
The Oracle bar (spec gate only), backward: grade the spec's scope and kill-or-ship. Same sections as the producer, read as checks.
product
- Is the component's reason-to-exist stated and real (not a duplicate)? Is a kill/revert condition reachable?
api-design
- Is the prop surface bounded with explicit non-goals? Any speculative prop → flag.
dx
- Does it cohere with the library's existing patterns, or introduce an unjustified new one?