QA Testing

QA Testing Skill for Personal Productivity App

Version: 2.0 Last Updated: January 2026 App Stack: Vue 3 + Supabase (auth + sync) + SQLite local backup Views: Pomodoro timer, Kanban board, Calendar, Canvas (node-based) Target: Desktop browser only, single-user personal use

Purpose

Ensure data integrity, stability, and basic security for a personal productivity app. Focus on preventing data loss, memory leaks, and sync failures during daily 8-hour usage sessions. Skip enterprise-grade testing (multi-user, compliance, cross-browser).

Triggers (When to Apply This Skill)

Claude should apply this QA skill automatically when:

• "Test task persistence after refresh"
• "Verify offline sync works"
• "Check for memory leaks"
• "Test data integrity"
• "Run QA checklist"
• "Verify backup restore"
• "Test Supabase RLS"
• "Check Pomodoro timer accuracy"
• Modifying any data operations (create/edit/delete tasks)
• Adding new views or components
• Changing sync logic or offline handling
• Before marking features complete

Core Testing Principles

ALWAYS Test Before Marking Work Complete

Data Persistence (Non-negotiable):

• Create/edit/delete operations MUST survive page refresh
• All state changes MUST sync to Supabase within 2 seconds
• Local SQLite backup MUST mirror Supabase data (matching row counts)

Memory Stability:

• App MUST stay under 150MB during 8-hour workday
• View transitions MUST NOT leak memory (< 30MB growth per 50 transitions)
• NO detached DOM nodes after component unmount

Offline Resilience:

• Tasks created offline MUST sync when online without data loss or duplicates
• Multiple offline edits MUST preserve latest version only (timestamp wins)
• Sync status MUST be visible to user

Test Requirements by Feature Type

When Adding/Modifying Task Management Features

MUST test (in order):

1. Persistence Test:

   • Create task → wait 2 seconds → F5 refresh → task still visible
   • Edit task → wait 2 seconds → F5 refresh → changes saved
   • Delete task → wait 2 seconds → F5 refresh → task gone
   • Mark complete → refresh → status preserved

2. Database Verification:

// Run in browser console after creating task
const { data } = await supabase
  .from('tasks')
  .select('*')
  .order('created_at', { ascending: false })
  .limit(1);
console.log('Last task:', data); // Verify matches UI

3. SQLite Sync Check:

   • Compare Supabase task count with local SQLite count
   • Verify updated_at timestamps match
   • Check synced flag is true for all tasks

4. Offline Scenario:

// In Playwright test
await page.context().setOffline(true);
// Create 3 tasks offline
await page.context().setOffline(false);
await page.waitForTimeout(2000); // Allow sync
// Verify all 3 tasks in Supabase, no duplicates

5. Conflict Resolution:
   • Edit same task offline (Device A) and online (Device B)
   • Expected: Latest timestamp wins, no data corruption

Console verification script (copy-paste ready):

// After any data operation, verify sync status
const { data: tasks, count } = await supabase
  .from('tasks')
  .select('*', { count: 'exact' });
console.log(`Total tasks in Supabase: ${count}`);
console.log('Last 5 tasks:', tasks.slice(-5));

// Check for unsynced (if using sync flag)
const { data: unsynced } = await supabase
  .from('tasks')
  .select('*')
  .eq('synced', false);
console.log(`Unsynced tasks: ${unsynced?.length || 0}`);

When Adding/Modifying Views (Kanban, Calendar, Canvas)

MUST test:

1. Memory Leak Check:

   • Open Chrome DevTools → Shift+Esc (Task Manager)
   • Record initial memory (e.g., 80MB)
   • Navigate: Kanban → Calendar → Canvas → repeat 10 times
   • Check final memory: should be < 110MB (< 30MB growth)

2. Data Display Accuracy:

   • Create 5 tasks in Kanban → switch to Calendar → verify all 5 visible
   • Edit task in Calendar → switch to Kanban → verify change appears
   • Delete in Canvas → switch to other views → verify gone everywhere

3. State Persistence:

   • Apply filter in Kanban → switch to Calendar → return to Kanban → filter still applied
   • Canvas: create nodes → save → refresh → positions restored

4. Performance:

   • Load 100 tasks → switch between views → each transition < 500ms
   • No visible jank or lag during animations

Memory profiling (Chrome DevTools):

1. DevTools → Memory tab → Take heap snapshot (Snapshot 1)
2. Perform 10 view transitions
3. Take heap snapshot (Snapshot 2)
4. Click "Comparison" → compare Snapshot 2 to Snapshot 1
5. Check "Detached DOM tree" count → should be 0
6. Check memory delta → should be < 10MB

When Modifying Pomodoro Timer

MUST test:

1. Accuracy Test (25 minutes):

   • Start timer → use phone stopwatch in parallel
   • After 25 minutes, compare: timer MUST be within ±1 second

2. Pause/Resume:

   • Start → run 5 minutes → pause
   • Wait 2 minutes (paused)
   • Resume → verify continues from 5-minute mark exactly

3. Background Tab:

   • Start timer → switch to another browser tab for 5 minutes
   • Return to app → timer should have progressed 5 minutes

4. Page Refresh:

   • Start timer → wait 3 minutes → refresh page
   • Expected: Timer recovers state OR warns user of lost session

5. Completion Trigger:

   • Run full 25-minute session
   • Verify notification/sound triggers (if implemented)

Quick accuracy test (console):

// Start timer, then run this:
const start = Date.now();
setTimeout(() => {
  const elapsed = Date.now() - start;
  const error = Math.abs(elapsed - 60000); // 60 seconds
  console.log(`Expected: 60000ms, Actual: ${elapsed}ms, Error: ${error}ms`);
  if (error > 1000) console.error('Timer drift > 1 second');
  else console.log('Timer accurate');
}, 60000);

When Adding Offline Capabilities

MUST test all these scenarios:

1. Offline Create (5 tasks):

   • DevTools → Network → Offline
   • Create "Task 1", "Task 2", "Task 3", "Task 4", "Task 5"
   • DevTools → Online
   • Wait 5 seconds → verify all 5 in Supabase
   • Verify NO duplicates

2. Offline Edit:

   • Go offline
   • Create task → edit same task 2 times (3 versions total)
   • Go online
   • Expected: Only latest version exists, not 3 separate tasks

3. Offline Delete:

   • Create task online
   • Go offline → delete task
   • Go online
   • Expected: Task stays deleted (not restored)

4. Sync Status Visibility:

   • User MUST see "Syncing...", "Synced", or "Sync Failed" indicator
   • Never silent failure

5. Long Offline Period:

   • Work offline for 10 minutes (create/edit/delete multiple tasks)
   • Go online
   • All changes sync successfully without data loss

Offline test pattern (Playwright):

test('Offline sync preserves all changes', async ({ page }) => {
  await page.goto('http://localhost:5546');

  // Go offline
  await page.context().setOffline(true);

  // Create 5 tasks
  for (let i = 1; i <= 5; i++) {
    await page.fill('input[placeholder*="task"]', `Offline Task ${i}`);
    await page.click('button:has-text("Add")');
    await page.waitForTimeout(300);
  }

  // Verify locally visible
  const localCount = await page.locator('[data-testid="task-item"]').count();
  expect(localCount).toBe(5);

  // Go online
  await page.context().setOffline(false);
  await page.waitForLoadState('networkidle');
  await page.waitForTimeout(3000); // Allow sync

  // Verify in Supabase (run in browser context)
  const supabaseCount = await page.evaluate(async () => {
    const { count } = await window.supabase
      .from('tasks')
      .select('*', { count: 'exact', head: true });
    return count;
  });

  expect(supabaseCount).toBe(5);
});

Memory Leak Prevention

Common Vue 3 Leak Sources

1. Event Listeners (CRITICAL):

<script setup>
import { onMounted, onBeforeUnmount } from 'vue';

onMounted(() => {
  window.addEventListener('resize', handleResize);
});

onBeforeUnmount(() => {
  // CRITICAL: Must cleanup
  window.removeEventListener('resize', handleResize);
});
</script>

2. Timers (CRITICAL):

const intervalId = setInterval(() => {
  // Pomodoro countdown logic
}, 1000);

onBeforeUnmount(() => {
  // CRITICAL: Must cleanup
  clearInterval(intervalId);
});

3. WebSocket/Supabase Subscriptions:

const subscription = supabase
  .channel('tasks')
  .on('postgres_changes', { event: '*', schema: 'public', table: 'tasks' }, handleChange)
  .subscribe();

onBeforeUnmount(() => {
  subscription.unsubscribe();
});

4. Third-Party Libraries:

• Canvas/node editor instances: call .destroy() or .dispose() in onBeforeUnmount
• Chart libraries: clean up chart instances
• Date pickers: destroy picker instances

Memory Testing Baseline

How to Measure:

Method 1: Chrome Task Manager (Easiest)

1. Shift+Esc → find your app tab
2. Watch "Memory" column during test
3. Record before/after values

Method 2: Console API

// Run before and after test
const mb = (performance.memory.usedJSHeapSize / 1048576).toFixed(2);
console.log(`Memory: ${mb} MB`);

Method 3: DevTools Memory Profiler (Most Detailed)

1. DevTools → Memory tab
2. Take snapshot before test
3. Perform 50 view transitions
4. Force garbage collection (trash icon)
5. Take snapshot after test
6. Compare → check for:
   • Detached DOM nodes (should be 0)
   • Event listeners count (should not grow)
   • Total heap size growth (< 30MB)

Data Integrity Checklist

Before Every Commit Involving Data Operations

Run this 5-minute checklist:

• Create → Refresh: Task visible after refresh
• Edit → Refresh: Changes persisted
• Delete → Refresh: Task gone
• Complete → Refresh: Status saved
• Supabase Console: Data matches UI
• SQLite Count: Matches Supabase count
• Console Errors: No red errors during test
• Sync Status: "Synced" indicator visible after operations

Edge Cases to Always Consider

Sync Conflicts:

• Scenario: Same task edited offline and online simultaneously
• Expected: Latest updated_at timestamp wins, no duplicate tasks
• Test: Edit in two browser windows (one offline)

Browser Storage Limits:

• Scenario: localStorage quota exceeded (5-10MB limit)
• Expected: App shows error message, suggests clearing old data
• Test: Fill localStorage with dummy data, then try to create task

Tab Closed During Sync:

• Scenario: User closes browser tab while sync in progress
• Expected: Reopening app recovers unsaved changes from SQLite backup
• Test: Create 5 tasks, immediately close tab, reopen, verify all 5 exist

Corrupted Local Database:

• Scenario: local DB file corrupted
• Expected: App detects corruption, restores from backup, syncs with Supabase
• Test: Corrupt DB file manually, restart app, verify recovery

Backup & Recovery Requirements

Backup File Validation

On every app start, verify:

• local_data.db exists and is readable (non-zero size)
• Backup file exists (< 24 hours old)
• If primary DB corrupted, restore from backup automatically
• If both missing, create new DB and sync from Supabase

Recovery Scenarios

Security Testing (Personal App Scope)

Supabase RLS Enforcement

MUST verify these:

1. Anonymous Access Blocked:

// In browser console (logged out)
const { data, error } = await supabase.from('tasks').select('*');
console.log('Error code:', error?.code); // Should be PGRST301 or 401

2. RLS Enabled on All Tables:

-- In Supabase SQL Editor
SELECT tablename, rowsecurity
FROM pg_tables
WHERE schemaname = 'public';
-- All should show rowsecurity = true

3. User Can Only See Own Data:

-- As logged-in user
SELECT * FROM tasks;
-- Should return only tasks where user_id = auth.uid()

-- Check no orphaned records
SELECT * FROM tasks WHERE user_id IS NULL;
-- Should return 0 rows

Input Validation (XSS Prevention)

Test in UI:

1. Create task with name: <script>alert('XSS')</script>
2. Check UI: Should display literal text
3. Check DOM: Should be escaped (<script>)

Auth Edge Cases

Performance Targets

Acceptable Response Times

Stress Testing Baselines

Task Volume:

• 50 tasks: Must be smooth, no lag
• 100 tasks: Slight lag acceptable (< 2s render)
• 250 tasks: Still usable, document as soft limit
• 500+ tasks: Warn user if approaching

Long-Running Session:

• 1 hour: No memory growth, app responsive
• 4 hours: < 50MB memory growth acceptable
• 8 hours (full workday): < 100MB growth, no crashes

Testing Workflow Integration

Before Committing Code

Quick Check (2 minutes):

• Run app, perform changed operation
• Refresh page → verify persistence
• Check console for errors
• Chrome Task Manager → verify no memory spike

Standard Check (10 minutes):

• Quick check (above)
• Test offline → online sync (create 3 tasks)
• Supabase console → verify data matches UI
• Switch between all 3 views
• Run unit tests: npm run test:unit

Full Check (30 minutes, before release):

• Standard check (above)
• Create 100 tasks → verify render time < 2s
• Navigate views 20 times → memory growth < 20MB
• Leave app idle 5 mins → verify no memory leak
• Test backup restore
• Verify RLS (logged out access blocked)

When to Run Each Level

Common Failures & Fixes

Issue: Tasks disappear after refresh

Likely Cause: Sync not completing before refresh Fix: Add await to database operations, show loading state

// Bad: Fire-and-forget
const createTask = async (name) => {
  supabase.from('tasks').insert({ name });
};

// Good: Wait for sync
const createTask = async (name) => {
  const { data, error } = await supabase.from('tasks').insert({ name });
  if (error) console.error('Sync failed:', error);
  else console.log('Task synced:', data);
};

Issue: Memory grows continuously

Likely Cause: Event listeners not cleaned up Fix: Check all addEventListener have matching removeEventListener Debug: DevTools → Memory → Compare snapshots → Look for "Detached DOM tree"

Issue: Offline changes lost

Likely Cause: No local queue for pending syncs Fix: Implement sync queue in IndexedDB/localStorage, retry on online event

Issue: Sync conflicts create duplicates

Likely Cause: No deduplication logic Fix: Use upsert with unique constraint

const { data, error } = await supabase
  .from('tasks')
  .upsert({ id: taskId, ...updates }, { onConflict: 'id' });

Issue: Pomodoro timer drifts over 25 minutes

Likely Cause: Using setInterval which compounds lag Fix: Store start timestamp, calculate remaining time on each tick

// Bad: setInterval compounds lag
let seconds = 1500;
setInterval(() => { seconds--; }, 1000);

// Good: Timestamp-based calculation
const startTime = Date.now();
const duration = 25 * 60 * 1000;

setInterval(() => {
  const elapsed = Date.now() - startTime;
  const remaining = duration - elapsed;
  const seconds = Math.ceil(remaining / 1000);
}, 100);

What NOT to Test (Overkill for Personal App)

Skip these (enterprise-only concerns):

• Cross-browser testing → Just use Chrome/Brave
• Mobile responsiveness → Desktop-only
• Multi-user conflict resolution → Single-user app
• Load testing 1000+ concurrent users → Only you use it
• WCAG accessibility compliance → Personal tool
• GDPR/compliance audits → Your own data
• Penetration testing → Not exposed publicly

Do test these (personal app essentials):

• Data integrity → No disappearing tasks (deal-breaker)
• Memory leaks → Must work 8 hours (your workday)
• Offline resilience → Common personal use case
• Backup recovery → Single point of failure
• Basic security (RLS) → Prevents accidents

Sign-Off Checklist (Before Daily Use)

Must pass ALL these before considering app ready for personal daily use:

• Create/edit/delete tasks survive F5 refresh
• Supabase and SQLite data counts match
• Offline → online sync works for 5+ tasks without duplicates
• Memory stable after 30-minute usage session (< 50MB growth)
• Can handle 100+ tasks without lag (< 2s render time)
• Pomodoro timer accurate to ±1 second over 25 minutes
• Backup restores successfully when local DB deleted
• RLS blocks unauthenticated access (test in console)
• No console errors during normal usage
• All 3 views (Kanban/Calendar/Canvas) render correctly

Example 10-Minute Test Session

Goal: Verify app is stable for daily use

1. [2 min] Data Integrity
   - Create "Test Task 1" → refresh → verify visible
   - Edit to "Test Task 1 Updated" → refresh → verify change
   - Delete → refresh → verify gone

2. [3 min] Offline Sync
   - DevTools → Offline
   - Create "Offline Task 1", "Offline Task 2", "Offline Task 3"
   - DevTools → Online
   - Wait 5 seconds → verify all 3 in Supabase console

3. [2 min] View Transitions
   - Kanban → Calendar → Canvas → Kanban → Calendar → Canvas
   - Chrome Task Manager: memory < 100MB

4. [2 min] Pomodoro
   - Start timer → wait 10 seconds → verify countdown accurate
   - Pause → wait 5 seconds → verify time frozen
   - Resume → verify continues from pause point

5. [1 min] Console Check
   - No red errors in console
   - No "401 Unauthorized" messages
   - Sync status shows "Synced"

Pass Criteria: All steps complete without errors, memory < 100MB

Refusal & Escalation

Refuse to skip these critical tests:

• Data persistence (create/edit/delete → refresh)
• Offline sync verification
• Memory leak checks after adding components/features

Escalate to human review if:

• Test failures persist after 3 attempts to fix
• Memory leak source unclear after profiling
• Sync conflicts creating data corruption

Mandatory User Verification

CRITICAL: Before claiming ANY issue is "fixed", "resolved", or "complete":

1. Run all relevant tests (build, type-check, unit tests)
2. Verify no console errors
3. Take screenshots/evidence of the fix
4. Use AskUserQuestion to explicitly ask the user to verify
5. DO NOT mark tasks as completed without user confirmation

The user is the final authority on whether something is fixed. No exceptions.

Canvas Geometry Invariant Tests (TASK-256)

Critical Canvas Stability Tests

The canvas system has automated tests protecting the three most fragile parts. Run these tests when modifying any canvas-related code:

# Run all geometry/sync/smartgroup tests
npm test -- --run tests/unit/geometry-invariants.test.ts tests/unit/sync-readonly.test.ts tests/unit/smartgroup-metadata.test.ts

Test Files

Key Invariants Being Tested

1. Geometry Single-Writer Rule:

• Only useCanvasInteractions.ts drag handlers can modify:
  • Task: parentId, canvasPosition
  • Group: parentGroupId, position
• All other code must be READ-ONLY for these fields

2. Sync Read-Only Behavior:

• syncStoreToCanvas reads from stores, writes only to Vue Flow nodes
• NEVER calls updateTask or updateGroup from sync
• Position mismatches log warnings but don't mutate store

3. Smart-Group Metadata-Only:

• Power keywords (Today, Friday, High Priority) update metadata only
• applySmartGroupProperties returns only metadata fields (dueDate, status, priority)
• Never changes parentId or canvasPosition

Test Helpers Location

tests/unit/helpers/geometry-test-helpers.ts

Key helpers:

• changedTaskGeometryFields(before, after) - Detect geometry changes
• changedGroupGeometryFields(before, after) - Detect group geometry changes
• assertNoTaskGeometryChanged(beforeMap, afterMap) - Bulk assertion
• createTestTask(), createTestGroup() - Fixtures

When to Run These Tests

ALWAYS run before:

• Modifying useCanvasInteractions.ts (drag handlers)
• Modifying useCanvasSync.ts (sync logic)
• Modifying usePowerKeywords.ts or useCanvasOverdueCollector.ts
• Modifying useCanvasSectionProperties.ts
• Any changes to task/group position or parent fields

Quick validation command:

npm test -- --run tests/unit/geometry

Expected Output

✓ tests/unit/geometry-invariants.test.ts (20 tests)
✓ tests/unit/sync-readonly.test.ts (12 tests)
✓ tests/unit/smartgroup-metadata.test.ts (26 tests)

Test Files  3 passed
Tests       58 passed

If Tests Fail

Geometry invariant failure:

• Check if your code accidentally mutates parentId, canvasPosition, parentGroupId, or position
• Ensure only drag handlers call position-changing methods

Sync read-only failure:

• Remove any updateTask/updateGroup calls from sync functions
• Sync should only call setNodes (Vue Flow display layer)

Smart-Group failure:

• Ensure applySmartGroupProperties only returns metadata fields
• Check ENABLE_SMART_GROUP_REPARENTING flag is false

Integration with Stress Testing (TASK-338)

For comprehensive stress testing beyond the standard QA checklist, use the stress-tester skill:

# Full stress test suite
npm run test:stress:full

# Quick stress tests
npm run test:stress:quick

# Generate stress test report
npm run test:stress:report

When to use stress-tester instead of qa-testing:

• Before major releases
• After significant refactoring
• When investigating reliability issues
• Security audits
• Performance regression testing

Skill chaining:

qa-testing → stress-tester (for deeper testing)
stress-tester → dev-debugging (for fixes)
dev-debugging → qa-testing (to verify fix)

See .claude/skills/stress-tester/SKILL.md for full documentation.

Version History:

• v1.0 (Jan 2026): Original functional testing skill
• v2.0 (Jan 2026): Enhanced with data integrity, memory testing, offline sync, backup verification, and security testing for personal app use
• v2.1 (Jan 2026): Added Canvas Geometry Invariant Tests (TASK-256)
• v2.2 (Jan 2026): Integration with stress-tester skill (TASK-338)

Automatic Skill Chaining

IMPORTANT: After QA testing, Claude should automatically invoke related skills based on findings:

1. If tests fail due to bugs → Use Skill(dev-debugging) to investigate and fix
2. If canvas geometry issues → Use Skill(vue-flow-debug) for specialized debugging
3. If planning needed for fixes → Use Skill(chief-architect) to break down complex work
4. If UI/UX issues found → Use Skill(dev-implement-ui-ux) for design fixes

Mandatory Pre-Success Chain: Before claiming ANY feature is "done", "fixed", or "complete":

1. Run relevant tests (this skill)
2. If tests pass → Ask user to verify
3. Only after user confirms → Mark as complete

This skill is automatically invoked by other skills after:

• Bug fixes (dev-debugging chains to qa-testing)
• Feature implementation (chief-architect chains to qa-testing)
• UI changes (dev-implement-ui-ux chains to qa-testing)