Speckit Specify Fix

User Input

$ARGUMENTS

You MUST consider the user input before proceeding (if not empty).

Purpose

This is the issue / bug-resolution counterpart to /speckit-specify. It produces a defect-framed specification (problem, reproduction, root-cause hypothesis, fix scope, regression risk, acceptance) using the dotCMS issue template, and then feeds the normal /speckit-plan → /speckit-tasks → /speckit-implement → /speckit-converge flow — so the plan phase's Legacy Impact and ADR Alignment gates still apply.

Use /speckit-specify instead when the work is a NEW FEATURE rather than fixing existing behavior.

Outline

1. Create the feature directory (reuse the standard Spec-Kit script — do NOT reimplement numbering):

   .specify/scripts/bash/create-new-feature.sh --json "<short issue description>"
   

   Parse the JSON for BRANCH_NAME and SPEC_FILE. If the user explicitly provided a feature directory or branch name, honor it.

2. Swap in the issue-resolution template. The script above seeds SPEC_FILE with the feature template; overwrite it with the issue template (respecting the override stack):

   • If .specify/templates/overrides/spec-issue-template.md exists, copy that over SPEC_FILE.
   • Otherwise copy .specify/templates/spec-issue-template.md over SPEC_FILE.

3. Load .specify/memory/constitution.md for project principles (legacy-awareness, ADR rules) — they inform how you scope the fix.

4. Fill the issue spec at SPEC_FILE, preserving section order and headings, using the bug report / issue text in the user input:

   1. Parse the report. If empty: ERROR "No issue description provided".
   2. Problem Statement + severity/impact.
   3. Reproduction: environment, numbered steps, expected vs actual, reproducibility. If the report lacks repro detail, mark with [NEEDS CLARIFICATION: ...] (max 3 total).
   4. Scope of Investigation: name the affected dotCMS area; note suspected surface (modern com.dotcms.* vs legacy com.dotmarketing.*) as a best guess — the plan confirms it. Do NOT do code-level root-causing here beyond a hypothesis.
   5. Root-Cause Hypothesis: current best theory (may be refined/replaced in planning).
   6. Fix Scope & Non-Goals: keep the fix bounded; list explicit non-goals to avoid scope creep and unintended legacy rewrites.
   7. Regression Risk: blast radius, backward compatibility, data considerations.
   8. Acceptance & Verification: measurable ACs tied to the reproduction, plus the specific test(s) to add/run.

5. Quality validation. Create a checklist at <feature-dir>/checklists/requirements.md and validate the spec against it:

   # Issue Spec Quality Checklist: [ISSUE TITLE]
   
   ## Content Quality
   - [ ] Problem and impact are clear to a non-author
   - [ ] Reproduction steps are concrete and ordered
   - [ ] Expected vs actual behavior are unambiguous
   
   ## Completeness
   - [ ] Affected area / suspected surface identified
   - [ ] Fix scope bounded with explicit non-goals
   - [ ] Regression risk (blast radius, back-compat, data) assessed
   - [ ] Acceptance criteria are measurable and tied to the repro
   - [ ] Verification method (specific test/steps) named
   - [ ] No unresolved [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers (or ≤3, most critical only)
   
   ## Readiness
   - [ ] Ready for /speckit-plan (Legacy Impact + ADR Alignment will run there)
   

   If items fail (excluding [NEEDS CLARIFICATION]), update the spec and re-validate (max 3 iterations). If [NEEDS CLARIFICATION] markers remain, present up to 3 numbered questions with suggested-answer tables and wait for the user's response.

6. Report the branch, the issue SPEC_FILE path, and any open clarifications. Recommend next step: /speckit-plan (which will consult ADRs and assess legacy impact).

Guardrails

• This skill scopes a fix; it does not write code. /speckit-implement does that later.
• Never create, edit, or commit an ADR (here or in dotCMS/platform-adrs). If the fix implies a new architectural decision, it will be captured as a proposal in the plan's "Proposed ADRs" section. ADRs are authored only in dotCMS/platform-adrs via new-adr.sh.