bl-thread
The thread under a post is where its reach is decided. Every reply is a second engagement event, and the first hour does most of the work. But the comments are not worth the same amount, so this skill sorts before it writes.
Input
The user pastes the comments, ideally with names and roles. Screenshots are fine. Do not scrape the thread with a browser tool.
Sort first, and say the counts out loud
| bucket | what it looks like | what it gets |
|---|---|---|
| LEAD | describes a problem the user solves, or asks about working together | a real answer today, then a move to DM |
| SUBSTANCE | disagrees, adds evidence, or asks a hard question | the longest reply in the thread |
| PEER | someone worth knowing, adding their own angle | a reply that gives them something back |
| SUPPORT | agreement, a short story, genuine warmth | two lines, by name, no boilerplate |
| NOISE | "Great post", tagging, pitching, bots | a reaction, or nothing |
Tell the user the counts before writing: "14 comments: 1 lead, 3 substance, 4 peer, 5 support, 1 noise." That alone tells them how the post did, and it is information the reaction count does not carry.
Then write, in that order
LEAD. Answer the actual question first, in public, properly. Do not open with "DM me" - answering in the thread is what makes the next person ask. Move to DM only after the answer, and only if there is a real reason.
SUBSTANCE. These deserve the most effort, especially the disagreements. A well-handled disagreement outperforms agreement, because everyone reading is watching how the user behaves under pressure. Concede the true part first. Then the reason you still hold the position. Never the last word for its own sake.
PEER. Give them something: a reference, a counter-case, a question they would enjoy. The goal is that they remember the exchange next week.
SUPPORT. Use their name. Add one specific thing. "Thanks Sarah" is worse than no reply because it is visibly automatic.
NOISE. A reaction. Pitches get nothing. Never argue with a bot.
Rules
- Never the same opening twice in one thread. It is all visible on one screen and repetition is the most obvious tell there is.
- Vary length. Two words to two sentences. A thread of identical replies looks generated because it is.
- No new claims. Every fact in a reply comes from
ledger.md, same as a post. - Answer the question that was asked, not the one that is easier.
- Hostile comments: answer the strongest version of their point, once, then stop. Do not reply twice to someone looking for a fight.
Before showing them
cd ../bl-scrub && python3 scrub.py replies.txt --explain
Then deliver each reply in its own block, labelled with the comment it answers and its bucket. The user posts them.